Skip to content
Welcome! Are you part of the community? Sign up now.
x

Posted almost 13 years ago

How to Fix Housing, Employment and The Economy (Part 3)

In the first two part of this series we talked about the Government needing to take an active role followed by the Banks needing to be the oil or grease that kept the system functioning.  

Well the Builders need to become change agents in the short term. I call them change agents as most builders should change their traditional business model in the short term (2-4 years). Builders need to stop building new properties if we are to turn housing around, lower unemployment and produce a stronger economy.

I have no idea how new construction can pencil in our current market with relatively new REO’s going for 30%-40% of the cost of new construction.  How can builders compete against these prices???  The short answer is they can’t and they should stop trying or they will burn through capital quickly and be in a world of hurt eventually.  

From where I sit builders either need to take the next 2-4 years off completely or change their business model. It is that simple.  I propose that builders should actively look into purchasing distressed properties in communities they once built.  Think about it.  Who could remodel a unit quicker and more cost effectively than the one who built it???  If this proves to be too small a market for a builder they should look to pick up other distressed assets and create value by turning ugly ducklings into beautiful swans.  

I have seen homes go for land value and a builder with their skill and experience could create a nice business model buying at 30 cents on the dollar and creating a new and finished product sold at 80 cents on the dollar.

If Builders stopped building and instead focused on the distressed inventory we currently have what would happen? Well first competition would go up slowly, which would raise prices and most importantly we would burn through our shadow inventory.  The sooner we reduce supply the quicker we get back to replacement cost where builders can start to pencil new construction.

Think about all the new jobs, tax revenue, etc that would be created by turning builders into remodelers for the next 2-4 year period???  Things could get real interesting really quickly.

So why won’t builders do this?  Well I hope some do but the chances are not many as they are wired to do one thing and what I propose is just too outside the box for them.  That is unfortunate as they would earn more money for their shareholders by buying distressed assets and turning them into functioning properties.

So if builders became change agents with the tax benefits offered in Part One and the Financing offered in Part Two we would turn prices around quickly, we would add a lot more jobs and the economy would be a lot stronger!!!

In the final part we will discuss the role of the investors and how they are the most critical part.

Good Investing

Comments (5)

  1. Michael - Great blog post. We are seeing a lot of local builders getting heavily into the renovation business as more home owners are looking to spruce up their current homes instead of moving to new ones. There are not a lot doing flips today, but your point is well made. The business man can find an angle in today's market to work his craft, even the home builder. Good stuff Chris


  2. Bryan, I don't know if the following works in your dads market. But maybe he could look to buy a ugly or just a small 2/1 house on a nice old city lot and then make turn it into a nice 3/2 or even a 4/2. The goal is to marry his strengths as a builder with the gifts the current market are giving away. Builders can either be busy standing still (making no profit) or they can just change the lense they opperate under a little and make a lot more cash. I am not saying every builder has to turn into a flipper or but if they can just tweak their business model a little maybe we can all get back to replacement cost faster and your dad can be busy again making a profit Good investing and thanks for everything you do on Biggerpockets


  3. interesting perspective...my dad builds homes for a living and has been real slow the past few years...things have ticked up, but they're practically giving the homes away now...not only that, but my dad often sees what i do, and doesn't fully comprehend what goes into it...he may be able to build a house from the ground up, but he doesn't necessarily know how to gut a distressed house, diagnose and address bad areas, and fix those up...seems counterintuitive, i know :)


  4. Frank, That is great news!!! I have not seen that in my area. If this continues we should see a bottom in the market and when it turns it could turn fast. Good News and thanks for sharing!!!


  5. Mike interesting discussion. I drive around alot looking at properties and just seeing what other investors are doing. I'm just a curious person, I want to know everything about everything. When I see a a dumpster at a property getting rehabbed or a house I lost to another investor I research that property and find out who the new owner is, how much they paid, if they own other properties, where are those other properties. I will drive by those properties just to see what kind of efforts other investors put into these properties... I want to know the smallest details, you get my point. What I've found is that local big time builders are purchasing REOs to flip and or holding to rent. The builders I'm talking about are the Sunday paper ad builders. These builders are buying hundreds of properties all over our area. I've learned some very interesting things about these people... they build million dollar homes but also invest in 40K dollar properties. So to answer to your question about... Builders are "building" and investing in REOs.