BiggerPockets


rules with your business partner? split profit

Forum Powered By:

13 posts by 7 users

To participate in forum discussions, create a free account or login.

Eva Medusa

Real Estate Investor from Bronx, New York

Aug 26 '10, 06:14 AM


Hi Everyone!
Sorry if you see this twice, i am trying to see where is the right place to put my question.

Maybe this is a very silly question but i would like to know
how you guys set up the rules with your business partner.

Example: Let's say one of the business partner is putting the credit and name for the mortgage and all the legal papers, the second person is putting the money (20 to 30k). After the deal is done, fixed, sold back, they make 40k profit ( 20k each)

Now, my point is whoever is putting the money already invested 20 to 30 k, so is kind of getting the money back. On the other hand the one with the credit get 20k also but do not put any money so is not or do not feel such a tangible resource.

Can anyone can share here please how this play, if there is a maybe instead of 50-50, maybe 80-20 profit split till the person that put the money get his or her money entire back. But also this not fair with the one that put his/her name on the deal.
There is way of putting value to this credit/name business person?

i am sorry if i did not explain myself right...just want to get an idea how this work with your partner so it is fair for everbody.

thanks



Jackie Patterson

Real Estate Investor from Kalamazoo, Michigan

Aug 26 '10, 06:35 AM
5 votes


Hi Eva,

I think you're a little confused. The profit is figured after all the expenses. If your partner puts in $20,000, that $20K is given back before the profit is calculated. In other words.....if you buy the property for $100,000 and sell it for $140,000, you would pay back the $20K and then would have $20K profit that you could split however you determine. Remember you will also have expenses that will need to come out of the profit. A good way to think of it is......Take the difference between the price you paid and the price you sell it for. From that amount subtract all of the expenses. Whatever is left is your "profit".



Jaremy Moritz

Real Estate Investor from Houston, Texas

Aug 26 '10, 07:43 AM
3 votes


I think it depends on how you set up the partnership to begin with. Some folks feel that a 50/50 split is the way to go and others might feel like a 75/25 is the fair way. It all depends on how you negotiate the deal.

I've done deals with a parnter on a 50/50 split. I found the deal, managed the rehab, and got the property sold. My partner bought the property in his company name, financed the deal, and put up all the repair funds. He had all the risk and I did all the work. 50/50 was fair for both of us.

I've also done deals with different partners on various other splits, like 80/20 and 75/25. It all depends on who does what and the amount of risk/reward each person is comfortable with.

If you want a larger cut of the deal and your partner won't budge, find a new partner or do the deal yourself.



Eva Medusa

Real Estate Investor from Bronx, New York

Aug 26 '10, 11:59 PM


Jackie and Jaremy thanks for the advice.
Really appreciate!! :)



Jon Holdman Moderator

SFR Investor from Wheat Ridge, Colorado

Aug 27 '10, 12:51 AM
2 votes


Typical split would be 50/50 is one partner brings all the money and the other does all the work. Profit, like Jackie says, is AFTER everyone's been paid back for any cash invested and all the other costs (e.g., closing costs) have been deducted.

You don't say who's doing the work, though.

Putting up credit (i.e., getting a loan and being on the hook to repay it) might be considered just as important as cash. It has to be paid back, and if its not, the borrower it going to have to find some way to pay it. So, if one partner contributes $30K in cash and the other contribues $30K in a loan (that the first partner is not obligated on), then there is arguably a 50/50 split on the money contributions.

Now, its different if the loan is secured by the property. In that case, the second partner's risk is much less because the property could be sold and the loan repaid. So, the first partner's contribution is "larger" even through the dollars are the same.



Jon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC


Eva Medusa

Real Estate Investor from Bronx, New York

Aug 27 '10, 01:16 AM


Thanks jon,
that's was exactly my question.

But if that's the case so how the partner that is putting the loan secured by the property is gonna make money?
Because the other partner put 30k, that of course he or she wanted back.

my idea here is maybe that also the partner that carry the loan, can use some credit card money for the fixing of the property till the different of 30k come to zero. But in that case so there is not value for the one who carry the mortgage and do all the legal paper on his/her name because at the end he/she is paying back to the other partner. i do not know if i explain myself clear here, sorry.

thanks



Jon Holdman Moderator

SFR Investor from Wheat Ridge, Colorado

Aug 27 '10, 06:20 AM
7 votes


Not sure I understand, so let me do a couple of examples. I will assume you will hire out all the work and that neither partner puts any value on the other's work of finding the property, hiring contracts of other such activities. The only that matters is the money.

Say the two of you buy a house for $50K that needs $20K of work. You'll have some closing costs when you buy, maybe $1000. You'll have a bunch of costs when you sell, maybe $10,000. You'll also have insurance, taxes, utilities and other holding costs. Lets guess those at $1000. So, the deal looks like this:

Selling Price: $100,000
Less all these costs:
Sales closing costs: $10,000
Buy closing costs: $1,000
Holding costs: $1,000
Purchase price: $50,000
Fixup costs: $20,000
Total costs: $82,000
Profit: $18,000

Now, you don't actually need $82,000 to do this deal because the $10,000 in sales closing costs come out of the sales proceeds. So, you actually need $72,000 to do the deal.

The simplest thing to do would be for each of you to put in $36,000. Each of you does half the work involved in making the deal happen, or, perhaps neither of you does enough work that the other cares. When you sell, you get $90,000 back from the title company after the closing costs. First, each of you takes back your $36,000 investment. That leaves the $18,000 profit. You split that 50/50 and each gets $9,000.

The "money partner" situation. Here one partner puts in all the cash and the other does ALL the work. Again, we'll do a 50/50 profit split. The money partner puts in $72,000. From the $90,000 you get from the title company, the money partner first gets $72,000. That leaves $18,000 profit. The two of you split that 50/50, giving each $9,000

Now, what if one of you puts in cash and the other gets a loan? It looks a lot like the first case. One person puts in $36,000. The other person get a $36,000 loan, secured by the house. When you buy, you need $51,000 to cover the purchase and closing costs. So the person putting in the loan signs the loan paperwork and the other person brings a check for $15,000 ($36000 + $15,000 = $51,000). The money partner pays for the repairs and holding costs for a total of $21,000. That means they've put a total of $36,000 in.

The person who took out the loan has to make the payments. That money does not count for anything.

Closing works differently this time. In this case, the same $10,000 of closing costs are subtracted from the $100,000 sales price. But the $36,000 loan also has to be paid off. So, the check from the title company is only $54,000. That's because the loan's already paid off. Out of the $54,000, the money partner gets $36,000. That's their investment. That leaves, ta-da! $18,000. That's your profit, which you split 50/50.

Now, why is 50/50 not a fair split? After all, you each put in half the money. Its not fair because the property was used as collateral for the loan. If the person taking the loan used something else for collateral, such as their residence, then I would say a 50/50 split was correct. But if the property itself serves as collateral then the borrower's risk is MUCH less than the money partner's risk. In fact, the borrower's risk is almost zero.

What? Think about what happens if something goes wrong. You buy the house, fix it up and nobody buys it. Months and months go by, still no buyer. Say the borrower gets tired of paying on the loan and stops paying. Eventually the lender forecloses and takes the house back. By that point they're owed $45K between the loan balance, missed payments and fees. The house is a mess because its been neglected for months and months. But you did put some work into it. It sells at auction for $55K. They take their $45K and hand you back the $10K that's left. That goes to the money guy. His loss is $26,000.

Or, nobody buys it at auction, and it goes to the bank. The money guy has lost $36,000. The borrow has a big hit on their credit, but loses nothing.

Or, say you find a buyer, but at $75K not $100K. After sales costs you get $67,500. (I just repossessed a house with number very much like this, bigger numbers, but the same ratio.) $36,000 goes to pay off the loan. That leaves $31,500. That all goes to the money guy, who's owed $36,000. The money guy takes a $4,500 loss while the borrower gets off with no loss at all.

What's the right split in this case? Beats me. To be honest, a deal like this is to complex and has too many chances for something to go wrong to even try to do, IMHO.



Jon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC


Eva Medusa

Real Estate Investor from Bronx, New York

Aug 27 '10, 07:10 AM
1 vote


Jon!!
THANK YOU!

you are great!! i do understand now exactly how it works, i was very confuse honestly.

Thanks to all you guys for the replies on this post!!



Tod R.

Real Estate Investor from Southlake, Texas

Aug 27 '10, 07:15 AM


I too think Jon is great!

You always give very well thought out answers that are easy to follow.

Thanks Jon!



Tod R., Thompson Realty Corporation
Telephone: 817-781-1942
Website: http://www.thompson-realty.com
[email protected] http://www.thompson-realty.com


Jimmy Oldrich

Real Estate Investor from Brooklyn, New York

Mar 09 '11, 12:26 AM


Great examples Jon.

Weren't you saying in another thread that the "money partner" situation meant the non-money role was mainly project management?

I appreciate that these deals are often negotiated case by case.



Jon Holdman Moderator

SFR Investor from Wheat Ridge, Colorado

Mar 09 '11, 01:53 AM


In the money partner situation, the non money partner would do everything. Project management while the rehab is in progress, but lots of other tasks, too. Finding the deal, buying it, getting estimates, hiring contractors. Dealing with all the inevitable issues that crop up. Listing it and getting it sold.



Jon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC


Tod R.

Real Estate Investor from Southlake, Texas

Mar 09 '11, 02:25 AM
1 vote


If you don't bring the money or the credit to a partnership, then you need to bring the expertise. If you can bring neither, then you have an employee/contract labor situation. Or maybe a mentor/student scenario.

Money and credit are virtually the same. In either case, real money is at risk should the investment property not return enough to repay both. Although the credit typically gets paid before return of equity.



Tod R., Thompson Realty Corporation
Telephone: 817-781-1942
Website: http://www.thompson-realty.com
[email protected] http://www.thompson-realty.com


Bill G.

Real Estate Investor from Springfield, Missouri

Mar 10 '11, 03:25 AM
1 vote


True, credit and collateral with the ability to borrow basically equals cash as well and don't forget the golden rule;

He who has the gold, makes the rules.



(Don't Want to See This? Log in or Create a Free BiggerPockets.com Account!)

Ubg-book

Get the Free eBook from BiggerPockets

Get The Ultimate Beginner's Guide to Real Estate Investing for FREE - read by more than 100,000 people - AND get exclusive real estate investing tips, tricks, and techniques delivered straight to your inbox twice weekly!

  • Actionable Advice for Getting Started,
  • Discover the 10 Most Lucrative Real Estate Niches,
  • Learn how to get started with or without money,
  • Explore Real-Life Strategies for Building Wealth,
  • And a LOT more!

Sign up below to download the eBook for FREE today!

We hate spam just as much as you


To post a reply or start a new discussion, create a free account or login.

Manage Keyword Alerts

View All Forums