Registration is now open for our Wholesaling and Fix & Flip Bootcamps. Register Now!

Hide this

Jump to Category View All

Click a category below to view different forum categories.

BiggerPockets

General Info

Rss10 BiggerPockets Q&A, Site Questions, & Announcements

964 topics, 7692 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 05:05AM

Rss10 BiggerPockets Exclusive PRO Area

10 topics, 73 posts — Last Post 02/06/12, 09:15PM

Rss10 New Member Introductions

4490 topics, 25662 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 06:47AM

Rss10 BiggerPockets Success Stories

142 topics, 1632 posts — Last Post 01/28/12, 09:34AM

Rss10 BiggerPockets Real Estate Investing Summit

16 topics, 560 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 04:23PM

General Real Estate

General Real Estate

Rss10 Buying Real Estate

1195 topics, 9017 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 06:24AM

Rss10 Selling Real Estate

303 topics, 2364 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 10:05AM

Rss10 Renters

189 topics, 1529 posts — Last Post 12/28/11, 05:55AM

Rss10 Get Foreclosure Help - Help Stop Foreclosure Forum

218 topics, 1728 posts — Last Post 02/02/12, 10:07PM

Rss10 Home Owner Association (HOA) Issues & Problems Forum

105 topics, 662 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 09:42AM

Rss10 Do it Yourself

312 topics, 2699 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 07:25PM

Reviews & Feedback

Rss10 Real Estate Deal Analysis and Advice

1554 topics, 12278 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 02:00PM

Rss10 Real Estate Guru, Book & Course Reviews and Discussions

677 topics, 6767 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 04:25AM

Rss10 Ask About A Real Estate Company

309 topics, 4634 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 03:12PM

Real Estate Investing

Real Estate Strategies

Rss10 Wholesaling

2406 topics, 18098 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 10:20PM

Rss10 Rehabbing and House Flipping

1478 topics, 12679 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 11:27AM

Rss10 Real Estate Development

190 topics, 1025 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 10:14AM

Rss10 Pre-Construction & New Home Construction

85 topics, 530 posts — Last Post 01/10/12, 07:04PM

Rss10 Innovative Strategies

328 topics, 2304 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 06:41PM

Rss10 Tax Liens, Notes, Paper, & Cash Flows Discussion

435 topics, 2411 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 02:29AM

Rss10 Rent to Own a.k.a. Lease Purchase, Lease Options

341 topics, 2086 posts — Last Post 02/07/12, 07:38PM

Rss10 1031 Exchanges

58 topics, 316 posts — Last Post 12/17/11, 05:10PM

Foreclosure Investing

Rss10 General Foreclosure & Pre-Foreclosure Forums

1096 topics, 6537 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 11:07AM

Rss10 HUD, VA, and Tax Sales

197 topics, 1221 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 12:34PM

Rss10 REOs

922 topics, 7646 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 02:54PM

Rss10 Short Sales

1220 topics, 10051 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 02:43AM

Landlord & Tenant Forums

Rss10 Rental Property Questions & Landlording Issues

2940 topics, 26276 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 06:44AM

Rss10 Land & Farm Investing

116 topics, 728 posts — Last Post 01/29/12, 06:46PM

Rss10 Mobile Homes & Mobile Home Park Investing

391 topics, 2864 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 02:32AM

Real Estate Dealmaking

Rss10 Make Deals, Find Partners, Mentors & BirdDogs, etc.

3648 topics, 13401 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 09:40AM

Rss10 Promote Your Real Estate Buyer's List

152 topics, 669 posts — Last Post 01/23/12, 12:35PM

Rss10 Property Wanted

626 topics, 3019 posts — Last Post 01/19/12, 02:47PM

Rss10 Seeking Financing, Money, or Loans

1218 topics, 7344 posts — Last Post 02/03/12, 11:21PM

Rss10 Tax Liens, Notes, Paper, & Cash Flows Dealmaking

273 topics, 1990 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 02:30AM

Rss10 Bulk REO Discussion and REO Dealmaking

845 topics, 5917 posts — Last Post 02/02/12, 04:20PM

Investor Basics

Rss10 Starting Out

4060 topics, 29632 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 05:53AM

Rss10 Investor Psychology

289 topics, 4281 posts — Last Post 01/26/12, 07:52PM

Rss10 General Real Estate Investing

3057 topics, 20771 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 12:54PM

Rss10 Real Estate Investor Marketing

868 topics, 7051 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 04:09AM

Commercial Real Estate

Rss10 Commercial Real Estate Investing Forum

718 topics, 3839 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 09:28PM

Rss10 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing

141 topics, 1347 posts — Last Post 02/07/12, 05:47AM

Rss10 Office Investing

3 topics, 36 posts — Last Post 11/15/11, 02:42PM

Rss10 Industrial Property Investing

3 topics, 12 posts — Last Post 07/05/11, 10:41AM

Rss10 Retail Property Investing

6 topics, 42 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 10:19AM

Rss10 CRE Financing and Lending

17 topics, 188 posts — Last Post 01/26/12, 05:55PM

Rss10 CRE Syndication and Fundraising

25 topics, 208 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 12:57PM

Rss10 CRE Property Management & Leasing

2 topics, 11 posts — Last Post 12/11/11, 05:05PM

The Business of Real Estate

Real Estate Technology and the Internet

Rss10 Technology, Social Media, Real Estate & The Web

244 topics, 2018 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 06:20AM

Rss10 Real Estate Blogs & Blogging

23 topics, 278 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 11:01AM

Business Basics

Rss10 Goals, Business Plans & Entities

400 topics, 3913 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 07:12PM

Real Estate Finance & Legal

Financial, Tax, and Legal

Rss10 Tax, Legal Issues, Contracts, Self-Directed IRA

1210 topics, 8252 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 05:36AM

Rss10 Credit & Credit Repair

177 topics, 1444 posts — Last Post 01/25/12, 06:56AM

Rss10 Property Insurance

117 topics, 753 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 11:33PM

Rss10 Bankruptcy

21 topics, 110 posts — Last Post 12/09/11, 10:01AM

Loans, Mortgages, Credit Lines

Rss10 Private & Conventional Lending Discussion

1244 topics, 7159 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 11:23PM

Rss10 Creative Real Estate Financing

623 topics, 3989 posts — Last Post 01/30/12, 05:35PM

Real Estate Professionals

Real Estate Professionals

Rss10 Real Estate Agents

611 topics, 3290 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 06:32PM

Rss10 Bankers, Lenders, and Mortgage Brokers

351 topics, 1252 posts — Last Post 02/03/12, 06:47AM

Rss10 Contractors

117 topics, 626 posts — Last Post 02/08/12, 10:17AM

Local Real Estate

International Real Estate

Local Real Estate

Rss10 Local Real Estate Networking

573 topics, 3013 posts — Last Post 02/07/12, 04:58PM

Rss10 Americans & International Real Estate

138 topics, 499 posts — Last Post 12/24/11, 07:44AM

Rss10 Foreigners Buying in the USA

54 topics, 281 posts — Last Post 01/18/12, 09:33PM

Rss10 Canadian Real Estate

25 topics, 117 posts — Last Post 02/06/12, 05:17PM

Marketplace

Real Estate Marketplace

Rss10 Mortgages & Lending

388 topics, 1730 posts — Last Post 01/23/12, 02:23PM

Rss10 Residential Property, Land, & Farms For Sale

756 topics, 1414 posts — Last Post 12/26/11, 01:22PM

Rss10 Real Estate Events & Happenings

113 topics, 453 posts — Last Post 01/11/12, 05:36PM

Rss10 Commercial Properties for Sale or Lease

223 topics, 668 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 10:59AM

Rss10 Domains & Website Reviews

44 topics, 334 posts — Last Post 11/15/11, 09:55AM

Rss10 Classifieds - Promote your Website, Newsletter, or Product

582 topics, 2646 posts — Last Post 02/10/12, 04:56PM

Off-Topic

Off Topic

Rss10 Off-Topic

1769 topics, 18864 posts — Last Post 02/11/12, 06:41AM

Rss10 Housing News & Real Estate Market

647 topics, 6308 posts — Last Post 02/09/12, 08:59AM

BiggerPockets Resources

Forums » Starting Out » Price to rent ratio

Price to rent ratio Subscribe to Price to rent ratio

33 posts by 12 users

Signup


Total newbie here, considering buying a property to rent (two family home) and hold for 5-10 years before selling.

I'd like to have a break even or positive cash flow and was wondering if there was a rule of thumb of what ratio of home cost (sale price) / (annual rent) would be a good place to start?

Thanks


Real Estate Investor · Denver, Colorado


One rule of thumb is the rent should be 2% or more of the price. That translates into a rent multiplier just over 4.

A better rule of thumb is to assume expenses will be 50% of the monthly rent. Subtract the desired cash flow off the remaining 50%, and that's your max P&I payment. Use the rate and term you can get to do a present value calculation to get the max price. Ignore down payments, since you don't want your money working for free.

So, for example, with that calculation, if market rents are $1000, your NOI is $500. Subtract $100 for desired cash flow, and that leaves $400 for the max payment. At 7% and 30 years, that will give a PV of $60,123.

Small_flying-phoenixJon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC



Hmm, I wonder if these #'s need to be adjusted in different markets. I'm on Long Island (NY) and the absolute cheapest houses are 300K, I'm looking at a property 350K, that can rent for about 3200 a month. Does that sound like a horrible investment?


Real Estate Investor · Ohio


I'm looking at a property 350K, that can rent for about 3200 a month. Does that sound like a horrible investment?

Yes, horrible sounds like the right word!

Mike


Real Estate Investor · Denver, Colorado


Originally posted by Frank Apap
Hmm, I wonder if these #'s need to be adjusted in different markets.


No. The math is the same everywhere. I've heard some people claim expenses may be a bit lower in mild climates than in harsher ones. But the basic idea doesn't depend on your market.

Small_flying-phoenixJon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC



Wow, it just seems like it would make it almost impossible to do a buy and rent type of thing here then.


Real Estate Investor · Denver, Colorado


If a place costs $350K and rents for $3200/month, you could certainly buy it and rent it. P&I on a 100% note would be $2328/month. NOI after 50% expenses will be $1600. That puts you in the hole by $728/month.

Even with a more optimistic assumption of expenses being 40% of rent, you're still in the hole $408/month.

If you pay cash, and using the optimistic 40% for expenses, you get $1920/month in cash flow. That's a 6.6% return on your cash. Slightly better than CDs, but not much.

Small_flying-phoenixJon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC


Real Estate Investor · Montgomery County, Maryland


Those numbers might work in some markets but not in mine. In markets where home values are higher and rents have not kept up it is impossible to experience that much cash flow.


Real Estate Investor · Larchmont , New York


Does this investment make sense..

Purchase price of 3 family home: $70,000
Taxes: $2000 per year
Gross Rental Income: $1500

Landlord pays water, insurance and taxes only. Tenants pay utilities.

What do you guys think ?


Real Estate Investor · Denver, Colorado


Well, the landlord pays more than that. You have to pay maintenance, property management (which you might do yourself), advertising, tenant screening, capital expenses (roof, sewer, etc.), evictions, vacancies, tenant damage, etc.

Still, that looks like a good deal.

Rent: $1500
All expenses: $750
NOI: $750
P&I: $466 ($70K, 30 years, 7%)
Cash flow: $284

Those numbers might work in some markets but not in mine. In markets where home values are higher and rents have not kept up it is impossible to experience that much cash flow.

Then you can't own rental properties there except as speculation. If you get some appreciation, enough to make up for your monthly losses, you'll make money. If appreciation is less, or, as is happening in many, many, many places, negative, you'll lose money each month and when you sell. The math could care less about your market. The math tells you whether its an investment (i.e., generates income each month) or speculation (requires appreciation to avoid losses.)

Small_flying-phoenixJon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC


· Ohio


Jon,

What an easy and straightforward answer. I think this should be kept at the top of the starting out page (sticky?) and labeled "The Basics."

Clearly there are a large number of real estate investors out there paying way to much for their investment real estate. Most don't take into account their own money - that includes the agents selling the properties. The goal is to keep hunting and find those gems that you can add value (equity) too. Then bring the 50% rule into affect. Let the losers buy the losers and you will be laughing all the way to the bank.


Handyman · Scottsdale, Arizona


Jon - thanks for responding - good info. Do you have any links for additional info?


Real Estate Investor · Denver, Colorado


I've made a couple of threads in the Landlording forum on this topic sticky. Have a look at those for more than you ever wanted to know about expenses.

Really, expenses are the only tricky piece of evaluating a rental. Everything else is just simple math.

Small_flying-phoenixJon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC


Rehabber · Santa Clarita, California


The 50% rule has been spoken here as if it were gospel and relevant on every single investment. In my book, it is not so. Particularly with Frank's property he is looking at (or was looking at).

A property that has a monthly gross rental income of $3200 will not have expenses reaching anywhere close to 50% in most cases. For properties with $400-$700, I am sure they do. Percentages can change dramatically depending on the gross rent. Rather than using a percentage rule, why not calculate the taxes & insurance, then add in a vacancy reserve, a capital reserve, and a misc. expense reserve. Paying 10% for PM on this type of property would be ridiculous and probably self manageable, even from a distance, so that fee can be erased. Properties of this caliber will have a much lower tenant turnover ratio, little to most likely NONE tenant damage beyond the deposit, and evictions will be much less likely. People able to afford this amount in rent are middle to upperclass and less likely to cause problems. If the property is in great condition or close to new, the capital expenses will be minimal in a 5-10 year period as well.

Point being, do the math with actaul figures and estimate reserves and other expenses that do not occur on a monthly basis, rather than use a simple percentage.

Can this be a good investment? That question can only be answered by the investor who does the proper and necessary due diligence on the property and if it fits within their game plan.

Small_barnardenterprisesWill Barnard, Barnard Enterprises, Inc.
E-Mail: info@barnardenterprises.com
Website: http://www.barnardenterprises.com
info@barnardenterprises.com


Real Estate Investor · Ohio


A property that has a monthly gross rental income of $3200 will not have expenses reaching anywhere close to 50% in most cases. For properties with $400-$700, I am sure they do. Percentages can change dramatically depending on the gross rent.

I disagree. First, this is a duplex, so the rent is only $1,600 per unit per month. While this COULD have a middle class tenant in it, it could also have a bunch of lower class tenants sharing the rent. A $1,600 per month rental would be unheard of here in Ohio, but $1,600 for rent certainly isn't upper class on Long Island or NYC - not even close.

Will is correct that IF you had a well-screened middle class tenant, that the eviction rate and tenant damage could be lower. However, the property taxes are sky-high on Long Island (one of the highest in the nation) as are all the other taxes. In addition, socialist bastions usually have some of the most unfavorable eviction laws in the country. So, while you may not have as many evictions, the cost of the eviction and the time it will take will be much greater. The point being that it all averages out and the 50% rule is still the most accurate gauge going.

That is not to say that a person shouldn't do all possible due diligence. While expenses are almost never much below the 45% to 50% range over time, they could be higher on an individual basis. You might also find that the government issues are so onerous that it isn't worth holding rentals on Long Island even if you could find a property that would cash flow. Even here in Ohio, dealing with the government stupidity is very frustrating and can be more aggravating than dealing with tenants because it's harder to fight.

Paying 10% for PM on this type of property would be ridiculous and probably self manageable, even from a distance, so that fee can be erased.

What? I thought you said that property managers MADE you money? Just kidding - I'm glad to see that you're converting to the self-manage school of thought! One little point though, even if you manage, you still can't "erase" the management expense - not unless you work for free (I don't). As I've said many times, property management is the most over-paid job on the planet! You certainly don't want to give that away!

Mike


Rehabber · Santa Clarita, California


Originally posted by MikeOH
What? I thought you said that property managers MADE you money? Just kidding - I'm glad to see that you're converting to the self-manage school of thought! One little point though, even if you manage, you still can't "erase" the management expense - not unless you work for free (I don't). As I've said many times, property management is the most over-paid job on the planet! You certainly don't want to give that away!
What I said is that PM's can make or break your business and the selection of the proper ones are crucial. I am not "converting over" as most properties owned out of state need a PM, but in this specific case, it may not be necessary.
I think Mike oversimplifies the responsibilities and duties of a real property manager (and a quality one), but there is no need to go into that as we have different opinions on that subject. If you do pay for a PM, make sure you negotiate the very best services at the very best rates and stay on top of them.

Small_barnardenterprisesWill Barnard, Barnard Enterprises, Inc.
E-Mail: info@barnardenterprises.com
Website: http://www.barnardenterprises.com
info@barnardenterprises.com


Homeowner · Abington, Pennsylvania


I do not know the other area . But in PA North Wales, $280,000 with home association fee $135 can only rent $1750 per month. A lot houses rents out like this.


Real Estate Investor · Denver, Colorado


Suffice it to say that there are various opinions as to a good ratio for expenses, or whether or not it can even be reduced to a simple ratio.

Find out what you can about a deal, then make some consideration of what you can't find out. Some expenses are impossible to predict, like tenant damage or evictions. Some are difficult, like roofs, furnaces, and sewer lines. Some are easy, like taxes, insurance, and property management if you use it. Don't stop with the simple ones because its sure there are more than just those.

I've removed quite a number of posts from this thread. This topic of the "50% rule" gets pretty heated. Its been hashed out before in the sticky threads in the landlording forum. In addition, I'll refer readers to another, more recent thread Validate the 50% Rule.

Small_flying-phoenixJon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC


Real Estate Investor · Murray Hill, New Jersey


Originally posted by nationwidepi

A property that has a monthly gross rental income of $3200 will not have expenses reaching anywhere close to 50% in most cases.

A 350K house on Long Island may very well have $1600 per month in expenses when you factor in the high taxes, cost of insurance, maintenance, etc. Especially in Nassau County, 350K does not buy you a great house. It's likely to need repairs and considerable ongoing maintenance, all of which will add up.
For these reasons, as Jon mentioned earlier, often the only way to make money there is through appreciation. Even then you have to hope that the appreciation covers the negative monthly cashflow in the end.


Real Estate Investor · Ohio


I think Mike oversimplifies the responsibilities and duties of a real property manager


That's because you don't manage properties and don't have a grasp of what's actually involved (much like the operating expense issue).

A property that has a monthly gross rental income of $3200 will not have expenses reaching anywhere close to 50% in most cases.


The recent study done by Taz representing more than 80,000 units, showed operating expenses to be consistently in the 45% to 50% range even in properties with higher rental rates (like this duplex at $1,600 per unit). That study is consistent with the larger studies that represent hundreds of thousands of rentals across the United States.

To get back to the original question, the monthly gross rents need to be close to 2% of the acquisition cost (purchase price + rehab) for a property to cash flow properly. Properties with gross rents near 1% of the acquisition cost are almost universally horrible! I use the 2% Rule strictly as a screening tool. If the monthly gross rents aren't at least close to 2% of the acquisition cost, I know it's a dud and I move on. If the gross rents are at least 2% of the acquisition cost, I then use the 50% Rule to calculate the cash flow.

Mike


Sign up