From the BiggerPockets Blog

 BiggerPockets Blog »

Jump to Forum View All

Click a category below to view different forum categories.

BiggerPockets

General Info

BiggerPockets Q&A, Site Questions, & Announcements

1521 topics, 14438 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 03:19PM

BiggerPockets Exclusive PRO Area

118 topics, 844 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 08:28AM

New Member Introductions

10971 topics, 86467 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 03:13PM

Real Estate Success Stories

398 topics, 6192 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 03:13PM

General Real Estate

General Real Estate

Buying & Selling Real Estate

5987 topics, 47187 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 03:25PM

Renters

649 topics, 5857 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:47PM

Get Foreclosure Help - Help Stop Foreclosure Forum

316 topics, 2557 posts — Last Post 04/21/14, 03:59PM

Home Owner Association (HOA) Issues & Problems Forum

238 topics, 1611 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 04:02AM

Do it Yourself

658 topics, 6316 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 09:50AM

Reviews & Feedback

Real Estate Deal Analysis and Advice

3706 topics, 29715 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 03:26PM

Real Estate Guru, Book & Course Reviews and Discussions

1139 topics, 11598 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:31PM

Ask About A Real Estate Company

743 topics, 7344 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 11:25PM

Real Estate Investing

Real Estate Strategies

Wholesaling

5632 topics, 43923 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 03:09PM

Rehabbing and House Flipping

3351 topics, 31097 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:09PM

Real Estate Development & New Home Construction

554 topics, 4694 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 09:17PM

Innovative Strategies

705 topics, 6044 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 04:06PM

Tax Liens, Notes, Paper, & Cash Flows Discussion

867 topics, 6692 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 08:22PM

Rent to Own a.k.a. Lease Purchase, Lease Options

698 topics, 4926 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 01:33PM

1031 Exchanges

143 topics, 1062 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 03:21PM

Foreclosure Investing

General Foreclosure & Pre-Foreclosure Forums

1691 topics, 11313 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 09:26PM

HUD, VA, and Tax Sales

416 topics, 3103 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:29PM

REOs

1217 topics, 10595 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 09:23AM

Short Sales

1538 topics, 13139 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 01:38PM

Landlord & Tenant Forums

Landlord & Rental Property Questions

7243 topics, 71117 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:51PM

Mobile Homes & Mobile Home Park Investing

639 topics, 5144 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 07:57AM

Investor Basics

Starting Out

7727 topics, 60654 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:30PM

Investor Psychology

431 topics, 6107 posts — Last Post 04/20/14, 06:04AM

General Real Estate Investing

4727 topics, 37315 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:57PM

Real Estate Investor Marketing

1738 topics, 14146 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 03:15PM

Commercial Real Estate

Commercial Real Estate Investing Forum

1412 topics, 9004 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:19PM

Multi-Family and Apartment Investing

1123 topics, 9379 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:55PM

The Business of Real Estate

Real Estate Technology and the Internet

Real Estate Technology, Social Media & Blogging

644 topics, 4910 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 10:40AM

Business Basics

Goals, Business Plans & Entities

832 topics, 7571 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 09:48AM

Real Estate Finance & Legal

Financial, Tax, and Legal

Tax, Legal Issues, Contracts, Self-Directed IRA

2802 topics, 20134 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 03:16PM

Property Insurance

311 topics, 2057 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 01:20PM

Personal Finance Discussion

330 topics, 2754 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 12:06PM

Loans, Mortgages, Credit Lines

Private & Conventional Lending Discussion

2852 topics, 19842 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:44PM

Creative Real Estate Financing

1219 topics, 8850 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 03:24PM

Crowdfunding Real Estate

35 topics, 463 posts — Last Post 04/19/14, 06:24PM

Real Estate Professionals

Real Estate Professionals

Real Estate Agents

1217 topics, 8024 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 08:23AM

Bankers, Lenders, and Mortgage Brokers

442 topics, 1929 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 11:03AM

Contractors

269 topics, 1690 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 07:33AM

Local Real Estate

Local Real Estate

Local Real Estate Networking & Recommendations

2014 topics, 11746 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 03:10PM

Americans & International Real Estate

162 topics, 568 posts — Last Post 04/14/14, 11:19AM

Foreigners Buying in the USA

62 topics, 409 posts — Last Post 04/10/14, 06:27AM

Canadian Real Estate

65 topics, 439 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 09:27AM

Marketplace

Real Estate Marketplace

Real Estate Marketplace

15079 topics, 54108 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:57PM

Real Estate Events and Happenings

167 topics, 2591 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:26PM

Off-Topic

Off Topic

Off-Topic

2907 topics, 32441 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 11:24AM

Housing News & Real Estate Market

920 topics, 8391 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:43PM

BiggerPockets Real Estate Investing Summit

97 topics, 1752 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 04:51AM

BiggerPockets Resources

Forums » Private & Conventional Lending Discussion » Cashing out 401k to invest in RE

Cashing out 401k to invest in RE

86 posts by 39 users

Signup

· Louisville, Kentucky


Has anyone cashed out their 401k to try and get a greater return on their money and use the proceeds to invest in RE? I have contemplated doing this.



Multi-family Investor · South Jordan, Utah


I took a loan out against my 401k to do it...

You could also roll the 401k into a SDIRA to avoid the tax implications and invest through there. More restrictions there which may limit your potential versus just taking the tax hit and going balls to the wall, but I haven't delved too deeply into that comparison.



SFR Investor · Texas


One of our BP members @Greg B. did such a thing I believe.



Residential Landlord · Hampton Bays, New York


@Daniel Thomas If you no longer work for the Employer who the 401k was with you can roll it over to a self directed IRA and use it to invest in real estate. This is what I did. If you are still working for the employer then you can borrow the money and essentially pay yourself back with interest . this is a win win situation. If you cash out and are under 59 1/2 you will be hit with ordinary income tax and a 10% penalty , IMO too big a price to pay even if you are not in a high tax bracket.



· Louisville, Kentucky


My wife and I will both have state pensions. Not sure if I should factor that in or not.



Accountant · Lake Villa, Illinois


@Daniel Thomas,

You will be giving away too much money. You could consider rolling over part of it into a ROTH SDIRA this will allow you to pay some tax on the money and move it into an account that you will no longer be paying any tax on.

I strongly suggest in most cases the loan from the 401k. As you can deduct the interest you are paying yourself.

It would take some significant tax planning to split the tax hit. In which case you will lose a lot more than you should allow. The first step to making money is don't lose money.

If your state taxes retirement income at say 5% and you're in the federal 25% tax bracket and plus 10% early withdrawal penalty. You are looking as losing 40% of the money.

If you're in the 28% bracket the loss to taxes is 43%.

The juice isn't worth the squeeze. Consider the possibility of rolling it over.

-Steven the Tax Guy

Your guide to IRS laws, rules and regulations.


Small_hta_logoSteven Hamilton II, Hamilton Tax and Accounting
E-Mail: [email protected]
Telephone: (224) 381-2660
Website: http://www.HamiltonTax.Net
-Steven the Tax Guy Hamilton Tax and Accounting LLC (224) 381-2660


Real Estate Investor · Texas


Yes I did do this in 2005 and never looked back. Cashing out is not for everyone and I would not do it if you don't have a viable plan.

Here is my argument about the 401k thing.... A 401k is a tax DEFERRED entity. You will pay income tax on the money at some point in time. The pitch was that you would be in a lower tax bracket upon retirement. Maybe, maybe not, but you will still pay income taxes on the money eventually. So the argument about paying the income taxes is a non issue for me.

The other part of the argument is the penalty, 10%. Agreed, it is a penalty, but it is surmountable.

My thing is, I put MY money into an account to defer MY income. The money is supposed to grow for decades. The actual growth will depend on your choice of investments. You may even break even over the decades or LOSE money. However, the managers that promote the investments(including fund managers) ALWAYS make money. Even in 2001, when my 401k funds lost 40% of value my fund manager was making money and never even picked the phone up to warn me that I need to make some adjustments.

The fund manager that you pay for is not looking out for your interests. Your finances are not something you can give to someone else to trust to manage. That was a tough lesson for me.

Now, while you are putting you income into the 401k for decades with the possibility that it may lose value, the 401k is NOT putting money into your pocket each month. You will not enhance your standard of living from a 401k.

What if I took that same money and put it into something that could pay me now AND pay me later? Hmm. It was a no brainer to me. I paid the penalty and income taxes and invested into income producing property.

Here's another point... Yes, my real estate investments may lose money occasionally. It could happen. However, I don't have to pay someone else to lose my money if it happens. I can take full responsibility and not have to rely on someone else to try and sell me something that will only benefit them.

Real estate investing has been a great choice for me.

Your mileage may vary.



Real Estate Investor · Texas


One more example: My wife has a 403b. We stopped contributing years ago. It has been invested in domestic and international growth equities for about 25 years now. In all of those years the value of the fund has grown a whopping 10% AND has still never put one dime in my pocket. 10% growth over 25 years, I know I can do better than that on my own. :-/



SFR Investor · Phoenix, Arizona


Much like the poster above, my wife and I cashed in old 401k's. During the stock-market crash, I transferred our old 401s into self-directed iras, when things calmed down last year, we paid the penalties & dumped the cash into down payments for two rentals. It wasn't our entire nest-egg, but the deal worked for us.

What's the actual return on your 401k in a "safe" investment? In our case, we were getting a few hundred a year on $60k in a money market account. Now we're netting that every month, and call it skill or luck, the properties have increased in value significantly.

The tax arguement doesn't wash with me, I'm 100% certain my tax rate will never go down, better to pay it now & invest in something useful that I can control.



· West, Michigan


Wow, what's plan B if things go to pot?



SFR Investor · Phoenix, Arizona


Originally posted by Ryan M.:
Wow, what's plan B if things go to pot?

Oh, you mean when "safe" "professionally managed" investments lose half their value in a 90 day period of time?

At least then I can light them on fire & get the satisfaction of watching them burn. I'm told the fenced lots would be good land to raise chickens & pigs on. When you burn a house down, you get fire trucks & sometimes a news chopper might fly over. The neighbors come over & tell you how bad they feel for you...

My Vanguard statement wasn't nearly as satisfying. Even with both accounts there, the statement was only perhaps ten pages or so - not much of a fire from those...



Real Estate Investor · Texas


@Ryan M., plan B would be the same as if your 401k was worth 60% of its value when you retire. You will be required to work more or share expenses.

The thing is you ask your question as if the 401k is guaranteed. It's not. You have no downside protection. You cannot get out if things are going bad. You can shift investments.

With RE I can decide to sell, mortgage, 1031, rent, or occupy.



· West, Michigan


Its certainly everyones own decision but when re is bought typically your name is on there if things go bad which did/is happening to a lot of landlords they come after you personally. I had lunch the other day with a former agent that had things go south for him, lost all his rentals including his house and now rents a apartment with his family.

Again, not stirring the pot but these things happen.



· North Wilkesboro, North Carolina


I have actually been thinking of doing this. I have an old 401k from a job I had 3 years ago. The 401k is in a medium risk category and after 3 years it is worth $100 less than when I left that job. So help me understand, I will pay a 10% penalty off the top, then I will pay tax on the remaining balance? Will the remaining balance be added as ordinary income or does it get hit at its own tax rate? I am self employed so I tend to do very well on taxes. Last year I was at 15% due to all of my deductions.

Thanks



Real Estate Investor · Cincinnati, Ohio


Originally posted by Ryan M.:
Its certainly everyones own decision but when re is bought typically your name is on there if things go bad which did/is happening to a lot of landlords they come after you personally. I had lunch the other day with a former agent that had things go south for him, lost all his rentals including his house and now rents a apartment with his family.

Again, not stirring the pot but these things happen.

When you hear of landlords losing their portfolio, its typically because they paid way too much for properties in the first place. In our market, you can pay 35k-50k for a house that sold for >100k 5 years ago. I think you can really limit your downside risk by making educated purchase decisions.



Hard Money Lender · Tyngsboro, Massachusetts


Almost everyone who cashed in an IRA or 401k seems to have done so to invest in real estate. You can move that IRA or 401k to a self directed IRA or 401k and still invest in real estate. So you have the best of both worlds.

I personally lend out of both my 401k's and my IRA, because it is easier to manage than real estate. I don't hold real estate in either one, I hold it in individual LLC's.

@Steven Hamilton II had a good breakdown of the cost of cashing in


Small_small_logoAnn Bellamy, Buy Now, LLC
Telephone: 800-418-0081
Website: http://www.buynowhardmoney.com
Hard money lending in NH and MA, and for free networking in MA, http://www.BlackDiamondREI.com


· Louisville, Kentucky


I am doing very well with the six properties I have. I thought since I will have a pension it might be best to cash out the 401k and pay off all the mortgages and then pay cash for a house every two to three years with the rents from the properties. Seems like this may give a better income in retirement then the 401k would. Any thoughts?



Residential Landlord · Hampton Bays, New York


@Ann Bellamy has hit the nail on the head why would you pay a large tax on cashing out a 401k when you can invest by rolling over to a self directed IRA. The tax you would pay would then remain available to invest . No one knows what future taxes will Look Like but you can control what you distribute until age 70 1/2 when you must start taking modest distributions which will be taxed as ordinary income.



Residential Landlord · Hampton Bays, New York


@Daniel Thomas If you can roll over the 401k you could purchase real estate now in a self directed IRA and buy property while it has substantially declined. You could also use the net income to buy additional properties as they are earned. If you are still working you can accomplish similar results by borrowing from you 401k and using that to invest in real estate. IMO these are much better alternatives to cashing out and taking a substantial loss before you even start to make money.



SFR Investor · Phoenix, Arizona


Originally posted by Michael Lauther:
Ann Bellamy has hit the nail on the head why would you pay a large tax on cashing out a 401k when you can invest by rolling over to a self directed IRA. The tax you would pay would then remain available to invest . No one knows what future taxes will Look Like but you can control what you distribute until age 70 1/2 when you must start taking modest distributions which will be taxed as ordinary income.

I question the wisdom of "hoping" your taxes will be lower in the future. You *are* going to pay taxes on any money in your 401k or IRA plan, or you'll be dead and it won't matter to you.

Those are your only choices.

I hate to see so many people stuck in a "loop", afraid of paying taxes, even on fairly insignificant amounts of money, when there are better options out there.

Every one is different, every situation is different, but there are deals that are *worth* doing, even if you have to pay some taxes.

My first deal with former IRA funds was a $70k property, purchased with about $20k down. It rents for $950 per month. After less than a year of ownership, Zillow says I could get $95k for the property, but the most recent comp was a few days ago @ $120k. Paying the taxes made that deal *possible* - I could not have done the deal without the IRA money.

It was an extraordinary deal, in an extraordinary time, and I probably couldn't do another like it today, without months of work, and a pile of luck. But I don't need to score like that every day. Just a few deals like that can make retirement possible. If you've got more time than money, sometimes you have to break the "rules".





Sign up