From the BiggerPockets Blog

 BiggerPockets Blog »

Jump to Forum View All

Click a category below to view different forum categories.

BiggerPockets

General Info

BiggerPockets Q&A, Site Questions, & Announcements

1522 topics, 14441 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 03:10PM

BiggerPockets Exclusive PRO Area

117 topics, 841 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 08:28AM

New Member Introductions

10994 topics, 86660 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 04:13PM

Real Estate Success Stories

400 topics, 6219 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 04:12PM

General Real Estate

General Real Estate

Buying & Selling Real Estate

5998 topics, 47269 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 04:13PM

Renters

651 topics, 5873 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 03:20PM

Get Foreclosure Help - Help Stop Foreclosure Forum

317 topics, 2561 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 08:28PM

Home Owner Association (HOA) Issues & Problems Forum

238 topics, 1611 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 04:02AM

Do it Yourself

660 topics, 6333 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 02:46PM

Reviews & Feedback

Real Estate Deal Analysis and Advice

3716 topics, 29808 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 04:17PM

Real Estate Guru, Book & Course Reviews and Discussions

1140 topics, 11614 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 03:27PM

Ask About A Real Estate Company

743 topics, 7348 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 03:12PM

Real Estate Investing

Real Estate Strategies

Wholesaling

5643 topics, 43993 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 04:06PM

Rehabbing and House Flipping

3354 topics, 31111 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 03:45PM

Real Estate Development & New Home Construction

554 topics, 4695 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 06:22AM

Innovative Strategies

705 topics, 6044 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 04:06PM

Tax Liens, Notes, Paper, & Cash Flows Discussion

869 topics, 6700 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 02:46PM

Rent to Own a.k.a. Lease Purchase, Lease Options

700 topics, 4961 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 11:26AM

1031 Exchanges

143 topics, 1063 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 11:10AM

Foreclosure Investing

General Foreclosure & Pre-Foreclosure Forums

1692 topics, 11317 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 09:26PM

HUD, VA, and Tax Sales

416 topics, 3103 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 02:29PM

REOs

1217 topics, 10604 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 07:13AM

Short Sales

1539 topics, 13154 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 08:25PM

Landlord & Tenant Forums

Landlord & Rental Property Questions

7258 topics, 71267 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 04:18PM

Mobile Homes & Mobile Home Park Investing

639 topics, 5146 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 05:13AM

Investor Basics

Starting Out

7737 topics, 60715 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 03:04PM

Investor Psychology

434 topics, 6119 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 04:14PM

General Real Estate Investing

4731 topics, 37332 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 02:34PM

Real Estate Investor Marketing

1740 topics, 14164 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 01:46PM

Commercial Real Estate

Commercial Real Estate Investing Forum

1414 topics, 9022 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 04:12PM

Multi-Family and Apartment Investing

1123 topics, 9405 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 03:21PM

The Business of Real Estate

Real Estate Technology and the Internet

Real Estate Technology, Social Media & Blogging

645 topics, 4913 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 12:21PM

Business Basics

Goals, Business Plans & Entities

835 topics, 7594 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 12:52PM

Real Estate Finance & Legal

Financial, Tax, and Legal

Tax, Legal Issues, Contracts, Self-Directed IRA

2803 topics, 20140 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 03:50PM

Property Insurance

312 topics, 2059 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 10:22AM

Personal Finance Discussion

330 topics, 2754 posts — Last Post 04/22/14, 12:06PM

Loans, Mortgages, Credit Lines

Private & Conventional Lending Discussion

2853 topics, 19854 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 04:15PM

Creative Real Estate Financing

1221 topics, 8870 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 03:19PM

Crowdfunding Real Estate

35 topics, 463 posts — Last Post 04/19/14, 06:24PM

Real Estate Professionals

Real Estate Professionals

Real Estate Agents

1218 topics, 8051 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 01:43PM

Bankers, Lenders, and Mortgage Brokers

442 topics, 1931 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 09:04PM

Contractors

268 topics, 1689 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 01:14PM

Local Real Estate

Local Real Estate

Local Real Estate Networking & Recommendations

2020 topics, 11766 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 02:33PM

Americans & International Real Estate

162 topics, 572 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 03:31AM

Foreigners Buying in the USA

62 topics, 409 posts — Last Post 04/10/14, 06:27AM

Canadian Real Estate

66 topics, 440 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 05:54AM

Marketplace

Real Estate Marketplace

Real Estate Marketplace

15096 topics, 54161 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 04:10PM

Real Estate Events and Happenings

168 topics, 2617 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 02:26PM

Off-Topic

Off Topic

Off-Topic

2908 topics, 32448 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 03:32PM

Housing News & Real Estate Market

922 topics, 8397 posts — Last Post 04/24/14, 02:57PM

BiggerPockets Real Estate Investing Summit

97 topics, 1752 posts — Last Post 04/23/14, 04:51AM

BiggerPockets Resources

Forums » Innovative Strategies » Rolling over an old 401K into real estate

Rolling over an old 401K into real estate

24 posts by 11 users

Signup

· Northern, California


Does anybody have any advice on rolling over a 401K into long term real estate investments from a previous employer? I heard that it can be done but I’m having a tough time finding information about it on the interwebs. Thanks!



· Littleton, Colorado


I've been using American Pension Services in Riverton, UT. I am very well pleased with them.



Private Money Lender · Los Angeles, California


It’s remarkably easy and done all the time, @James Zachary. The easiest way is to roll your 401k into a self-directed IRA. The basic rules are simple though enforcement is strict. You can begin by searching this board for “self-directed IRA” and also by visiting the web site of a few of the bigger self-directed companies show here:

http://www.pensco.com/
http://www.theentrustgroup.com/
http://www.trustetc.com/
https://www.iraservices.com/

There are many others and all have a pages that explain how investing through an IRA works, your investment options, as well as the rules. If you do some searches here, you read opinions and individual preferences among these companies, pro and con.

Lot’s to read about and to learn but you’re on the right track.

Jeff



Real Estate Agent · Shawnee, Kansas


We have some experience in helping people with this once it's a self directed IRA. The websites posted by Jeff are a great resource.



Accountant · Lake Villa, Illinois


@James Zachary,

Look into ROBS RollOver as Business Startup. You can go the self directed route; however, you can also use it to start a C-corporation and use it to invest.

-Steven


Small_hta_logoSteven Hamilton II, Hamilton Tax and Accounting
E-Mail: [email protected]
Telephone: (224) 381-2660
Website: http://www.HamiltonTax.Net
-Steven the Tax Guy Hamilton Tax and Accounting LLC (224) 381-2660


Accountant · Lake Villa, Illinois


Forgot to link this http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/207190#


Small_hta_logoSteven Hamilton II, Hamilton Tax and Accounting
E-Mail: [email protected]
Telephone: (224) 381-2660
Website: http://www.HamiltonTax.Net
-Steven the Tax Guy Hamilton Tax and Accounting LLC (224) 381-2660


Real Estate Investor · Manteno, Illinois


Why bother rolling it over? Just take it out and take the hit on the early withdrawal now. The advantages to doing that?
1) You get the cash flow now instead of having to wait til retirement - at which time you'll have to pay taxes on it when you pull it out.

2) You can leverage that money to buy more properties.

3) Real estate income is pretty much tax free anyway so what do you really gain by leaving it in a tax free vehicle that is only temporarily tax free - you'll pay when you end up pulling that real estate out of the 401k.

example with some VERY loose guestimates on the numbers:
100k buys you one house (worth about 130k) free and clear in your 401k. You net $800 a month for that house for the next 20 years. It appreciates and ends up being worth 250k plus you pocketed another 200k in net profits. You now have 450k in your 401k that you have to pay taxes on when you pull out so you're left with 340k?

Same example: Take your 100k out of your 401k now, you end up with 60k. Buy two 100k houses with leverage putting down 30k on each. You net $450 per month on each house (total $900/mo net income) that you get to put in your pocket today tax free.

At the end of the 20 years, you have both houses paid off and they're worth 500k total. You then sell those and only get hit with a capital gain tax instead of earned income bracket and you put 400k in the bank. Plus you will have pocketed roughly 11k a year for the past 20 years (another 220k).

So I just don't see why people wouldn't pull their money out of their 401k and take the hit now. The benefits of doing it today provided you use it to buy real estate are far better than keeping it in.

401k - 1 100k house free and clear. Your net retirement nest egg from that investment would be roughly 340k in cash.

Pull the same 100k house and use it and leverage to buy two of the same house types as above and you end up with 400k in cash when you sell the houses. Plus another 220k in cash (almost all of which was tax free) from the rental income.

340k for option 1 (buying with 401k)
620k for option 2 (pulling money out and taking penalty)

This obviously has some flaws in the math. One is that rental income would be greater over the 20 year period. Assumes appreciation of the value of the house almost doubling in 20 years. Thats historically correct but who knows if that will be true.

You can argue some of the numbers maybe should be adjusted a bit here or there. But there's no way you can tell me the numbers for option 1 can ever come out better than option 2.



· Northern, California


@Mike H.
You bring up a very interesting point and it is something I have been bouncing around in my head. From what I have read on the web, most people advise against taking money out of your 401K. I must admit, I haven’t dove to deep into the reasons why but I will now. Thanks. Oh, one more question… Where do you find houses with $450 net income?!?! :-)



Rehabber · Santa Clarita, California


Mike has some valid points, though I do not agree with taking it out to cash and paying both the tax AND the PENALTY (additional 10%).

Also, I do not agree with others on rolling over to an IRA (unless that is your only option) but rather, rolling into a solo 401k plan which is a self administered 401k plan requiring you to have your own business without any employees other than you and a spouse (or multiple spouses if you live in Utah - J/K) :)

Advantages of 401k over IRA is ability to place more in each year (contributions that is), borrowing provisions (IRA's do not have them), and company matches to contributions.

If you were going to take it out and take the hit, i would only recomend doing so by rolling into a ROTH solo 401k plan. No 10% penalty, all future profits are tax free, and you retain all the benefits of the 401k over an IRA.

lastly, holding RE in a tax advantaged account (retirement plan) is not (in my opinon and that of many others) not the best use of the funds. More appropriate is to use the funds in a lender capacity. Buy and hold offers depreciation, leverage, and other advantages that are either lost or much more difficult in a retirement plan.
I have commented in many threads in full detail on this subject here on BP. Do a search for it here on BP.


Small_be_logoWill Barnard, Barnard Enterprises, Inc.
E-Mail: [email protected]
Website: http://www.barnardenterprises.com
http://www.InvestorExperts.com


Real Estate Investor · Austin, Texas


I use IRAServices as linked above. They are very hands off. Once you have it all set up, you're ready to get to work.

You do have to be careful with the tax implications of using SDIRA money as well as borrowing with an entity that receives funds from an SDIRA. IE, better not to do it.

I've also heard good things about solo 401ks but don't have one. I'm not too keep to switch as my SDIRA is working for me for flip projects that I use the capital for. I don't use the capital for any buy and hold, it's all flip projects.


John Blackman, Bullseye Capital Fund
Website: http://bullseyecapital.capitalgroupkit.com/fund/
Join Our Fundrise Network To See Our Deals: https://fundrise.com/networks/inner-10-development/view


Accountant · Lake Villa, Illinois


It looks like for once @Will Barnard and I agree. I STRONGLY suggest going the Roth account route. I've been assisting man of my clients to roll over their traditional accounts to roth over several years or in the case of 2012 very quickly.

Tax free growth sounds better.

-Steven


Small_hta_logoSteven Hamilton II, Hamilton Tax and Accounting
E-Mail: [email protected]
Telephone: (224) 381-2660
Website: http://www.HamiltonTax.Net
-Steven the Tax Guy Hamilton Tax and Accounting LLC (224) 381-2660


Real Estate Investor · Anaheim, California


I will throw my vote in for the Roth 401K option as well. I took the plunge last year and converted over to a Roth 401k (with Steven Hamilton's help, thank you Steven!). In addition to the benefits described by Will Barnard, with a 401K you don't have to deal with a custodian and you can often use leverage without taxation (UBIT).

As stated before, you will need a business to be able to open a self-directed 401K. But, it does not need to be an Inc. or LLC. Anyone can create a simple sole-proprietorship, open a bank account and use it to start a 401k.



Rehabber · Santa Clarita, California


Originally posted by Steven Hamilton II:
It looks like for once Will Barnard and I agree. I STRONGLY suggest going the Roth account route.
I would not go as far as to say that, we may disagree on a few things, but agree on many others including this thread.


Small_be_logoWill Barnard, Barnard Enterprises, Inc.
E-Mail: [email protected]
Website: http://www.barnardenterprises.com
http://www.InvestorExperts.com


Accountant · Lake Villa, Illinois


@Will Barnard maybe for once was a bit of an exaggeration. Usually we tend to have slightly differing viewpoints.

-Steven


Small_hta_logoSteven Hamilton II, Hamilton Tax and Accounting
E-Mail: [email protected]
Telephone: (224) 381-2660
Website: http://www.HamiltonTax.Net
-Steven the Tax Guy Hamilton Tax and Accounting LLC (224) 381-2660


Rehabber · Santa Clarita, California


To each his own. One of he great things about BP Nation community is the ability to get multiple view points.

Some things are a matter of opinion, others a matter of fact. When facts are wrong, someone will correct. When opinions are given, others can provide alternate ones.


Small_be_logoWill Barnard, Barnard Enterprises, Inc.
E-Mail: [email protected]
Website: http://www.barnardenterprises.com
http://www.InvestorExperts.com


Private Money Lender · Los Angeles, California


Originally posted by @Steven Hamilton II:
It looks like for once Will Barnard and I agree. I STRONGLY suggest going the Roth account route. I've been assisting man of my clients to roll over their traditional accounts to roth over several years or in the case of 2012 very quickly.

Well, we finally disagree Steven Hamilton II, but only slightly. Taking the tax hit and rolling into a Roth is not necessarily a good idea. This is going to depend on age of the investor and tax bracket. In general, the older you are and the higher your tax bracket, the less a Roth rollover is in your interest. It really requires an analysis to determine how fast you can grow what's left after taking the hit.

I’m always amazed over the arguments against investing tax deferred (or even better, tax free in a Roth!!) over the long term. These never seem to consider the immense power of compounding and the time value of money.

Where I STRONGLY agree, is that hard real estate assets are best kept out of a retirement plan in favor of paper investments such as notes and lending, which are normally taxed as ordinary income. In addition to the obvious contribution limitations, the dangers of self-dealing, and general ease of “messing up,” a self-directed retirement plan also eliminates the ability to take advantage of significant real estate benefits as depreciation and many business deductions.

Jeff



Rehabber · Santa Clarita, California


Where I STRONGLY agree, is that hard real estate assets are best kept out of a retirement plan in favor of paper investments such as notes and lending, which are normally taxed as ordinary income. In addition to the obvious contribution limitations, the dangers of self-dealing, and general ease of "messing up," a self-directed retirement plan also eliminates the ability to take advantage of significant real estate benefits as depreciation and many business deductions.
Agreed.
As far as the debate over Roth rollover or not, you are also correct that in large part, it depends on age and income level of account holder. Older people have less years to save and thus, are already at (typically) the higher tax brackets and have less years to live through additional tax hikes (which we all know come every 4 years.

A younger person, it makes all the sense in the world to go ROTH right away!


Small_be_logoWill Barnard, Barnard Enterprises, Inc.
E-Mail: [email protected]
Website: http://www.barnardenterprises.com
http://www.InvestorExperts.com


· Northern, California


Man, I am so happy I joined BP. You all are amazing! Thank you so much for all your suggestions and comments. Just to recap, it sounds like most of you advise against using a 401K (Solo or Self Directed) to purchase real estate because you lose some of the tax benefits that are already built into Real Estate. Very valid points, however, if an older 401K (from a previous employer) is enough to get you started now in REI, would you do it? Or would you try to find other ways to build funds, even if it meant sitting out for 6 or so months?



Private Money Lender · Los Angeles, California


It sounds like you have money burning a hole in your pocket, James :-).

The tax consequences noted above don’t change because you currently have enough cash.

If you have enough money to buy a house now in a 401k, you have enough to loan on a house now in a 401k -- or, a few houses. That would be my preference (on short term flips). If it will only take you 6 months to reach a point where you can use your after tax income to purchase property, you could do that too. This would give you an opportunity to form some relationships and get the lay of the land.

You’re not specific about your real estate interests, but in my view, you could shelter your RE profits before tax in the 401k and build a large passive note and loan portfolio. Understand, we loan money, so I’m obviously biased in that direction, but you seem to be in a good position, James. Good luck.

Jeff



Commercial Landlord · Oshkosh, Wisconsin


What makes me nervous about 401k's are that who know's if congress gets greedy and goes to the moon with taxes on these regulated retirement plans. I just hate having my capital tied up in it. It doesnt even feel like mine especially when they are in trouble.
When I had a 401k I toke the hit:( Ya I probably shoulda put it into a roth but I didnt. I did use the 401k money to buy more income property when I left my earned income and transitioned to living on my income properties. In my defense it was less then 20k.
I like retirement income like the next guy but i also like liquidity and real estate is illiquid enough without putting more regulation onto it.
So here is my question? If we dont work a job anymore and are a long ways from retirement and we view our equity in our income property as retirement money as well why should it be in a plan of any type since its just tied up further by gov rules?
For example if I have a 3 million dollar complex and I get 10k a month off of it what benefit is there to keep some of that money tied up when I want access to all of it?
I mean to have the gov tell me I have to keep my dirty hands off my money. I can co mingle, I cant do this, I cant do that...
@#$% Uncle Sam he can keep his defined pensions and his 401k's and other various toilet paper they come up with to screw up an average guy. I know you grow tax free and all that but in my defense I can move my money without being tied into something. Taxes ya I know Il pay that or i could just keep the apt building to my death and let my son pay taxes instead. On my flips Im screwed having to pay fat taxes. Maybe what I need to do is strictly income and quit flipping so I dont get taxed to death.





Sign up