Bulk REO Buyer? Subscribe to Bulk REO Buyer? 34 posts by 10 users

David P.

Real Estate Consultant
Tallahassee, Florida
Cimg0097_forum_avatar

727 posts

I have a buyer that claims he wants to buy bulk REO properties in my market area. He says that he is looking for bulk packages around 500 properties.

Can somone explain to me the basic Bulk REO process?

How does it work?

What is the likelihood of success (given a qualified buyer)?

What are the biggest hurdles?

My intent is to learn enough so that I can qualify this " buyer" .

Any help is greatly appreciated.

Dave

Sponsors:

Christopher L.

Real Estate Consultant
Little Town, Oklahoma
Floyd_forum_avatar

549 posts

What is your market area?

What are their thoughts in pricing in reference to current BPO / Appraised values?

The likliehood of success is 100% if the buyer is purchasing at market levels

Most if not all sale opportunities are grounded because of the unfamiliar context of a sale

Start with a 65% of current BPO and if the buyer is on board there's a ton of banks releasing at those levels

You may have some hurdles getting to the actual seller so be smart and call the banks yourself,

Cash is KING.....if the buyer is borrowing money you will be ignored

flipper101

Real Estate Investor
San Ramon, California
Motor-_bad_ass_harley_forum_avatar

2810 posts

CA has the highest concentration of REO in the nation. Here is an e-mail from one of the TOP REO listing and selling Brokers in the entire Northern CA region. Banks are not dumping there inventory.

CC:

See attached for this week’s foreclosures, NOD-NOT-REO Northern CA.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Buyers beware…This Buyer’s market is getting a bit unfriendly to Buyers.

We are working with Buyers around the Entire greater Norther CA region. In most areas the lower to mid price-point homes are selling with multiple offers in a short time.

I saw a home in last week in Antioch which had 31 offers!

It’s no longer reasonable to make low offers on most REOs (bank owned properties). The banks are finally pricing correctly and many of the new listings are selling quick.

If you want to buy one of these great deals you need to make a solid offer and be ready to take action quickly if you see a good deal.

Paul C.

Banker
Scottsdale, Arizona
Bloodfire_forum_avatar

309 posts

I think banks are more interested in cutting their losses right now and not lending money, hence the reason we are seeing REOs listed around Fair market value instead of 60-80% of what the current BPO is.

James/Chris, Can you explain what happens to institutions when they have too much REO inventory? This obviously has an effect on their ability to lend more, but to what extent?

flipper101

Real Estate Investor
San Ramon, California
Motor-_bad_ass_harley_forum_avatar

2810 posts

hence the reason we are seeing REOs listed around Fair market value instead of 60-80% of what the current BPO is.

Yes, that is what were seeing in CA where the majority of REO are.
The listings with high DOM at 75% of FMV, which was the norm up until early May, are now sold for the most part. EVEN IN THE CENTRAL VALLEY!

New listings are at FMV and there are multiple offers now that the prices are way down as far as FMV.

The auction companies are getting much less dead inventory from the banks as well.

We all know that the real channels for Bulk REO always had HIGH expectations as far as what they needed for the properties, that FAR exceeded most vulture investors expectations and hence, most deals never went through.

Now the trend is multiple offers on most REO so the banks don't have that pressure of " alternative disposition" like they did before. They also have the ability to use the bad assets as colladeral for new money to loan!

As far as you question about institutions having too much on the books, that is answered in many threads and it all depends on weather it's a federally chartered bank, private investment bank or Hedge fund and the answer is not a one size fits all.

Christopher L.

Real Estate Consultant
Little Town, Oklahoma
Floyd_forum_avatar

549 posts

It's a matter of balance

When banks sell their debt it's an IMMEDIATE correction and there's nothing left to fudge

It's the primary reason I laugh when i hear that there's an 80B package...and of course it's in " escrow"

There are NO BANKS that could take an overnight writedown and stay solvent at that level

It would sink them.....Banks are paper tigers

Look at what happened to Bear after their confidence and liquidity went away.......Their building alone was worth 4 or 5 times what JPM offered

REO and NPN's are a weight around a banks neck yet it's also the only lifeline they have, The valuation of the asset is likely tw plus years old so we all know it's junk but it's what was written at the time that creates the value and will again be reconstructed at the time of the " sale"

Every bank has been in turbo mode to acquire capital (liquid) at all costs so the sales can be consumated.

Take a look at the sale of 15B from UBS to Blackrock. Blackrock borrowed a significant portion from UBS to buy the debt. Interesting shuffling of the deck. UBS is now receiving interest from the leverage and Blackrock acquires assets at 68-72........another reason I scoff at the sales I run into is the larger boys are very familiar who scratches backs the best. It doesn't mean that they don't make it down the ladder but the real biggies are handled on a golf course or swanky club

Just go back one short year and see what was happening

http://www.stlreo.com/more_news.php?news=343

It makes the next year coming pretty intriguing to see who will be left. M&A's are going to be leading the news is my guess. How will Merrill and Morgan fare.....CSFB?

We live in interesting times

Paul C.

Banker
Scottsdale, Arizona
Bloodfire_forum_avatar

309 posts

Thanks James

Looks like I will have to dig up some old threads and do some research for my second question.

Christopher L.

Real Estate Consultant
Little Town, Oklahoma
Floyd_forum_avatar

549 posts

Paul try this.......I posted this bit of chrade nonsense last month

http://forums.biggerpockets.com/viewtopic.php?t=19066

Stephen M.

Residential Real Estate Agent
Moreno Valley, CA
The_house_forum_avatar

189 posts

Oh...now I understand why banks look for a consistant buyer. They would rather sell of 10m-50m a month or quarter for the sake of liquidity.

We must be behind the time in the Inland Empire. We still have 80% of our bank inventory sitting without an offer. Our pendings have quadroupled though. It's still 1 escrow for 3 new listings per day.

Paul C.

Banker
Scottsdale, Arizona
Bloodfire_forum_avatar

309 posts

Originally posted by "Oklahoma1"
The likliehood of success is 100% if the buyer is purchasing at market levels

Start with a 65% of current BPO and if the buyer is on board there's a ton of banks releasing at those levels

Chris, Can you please clarify what you mean in the first comment here?

I think you might confuse Dave here because you are telling him that there are a ton of banks releasing (I am assuming you mean selling?) at the 65% of current BPO levels, but if you are purchasing at market levels (FMV?), then wouldn't he expect his clients to pay 80-90% of the current BPO?

Christopher L.

Real Estate Consultant
Little Town, Oklahoma
Floyd_forum_avatar

549 posts

Paul

65% is the minimum (pricing levels) we are seeing product being released at. Those would be current BPO valuations

Simply put:

If you asked me for REO at 64 I wouldn't be of any use.......

We have moved away from quantity and focused on quality. I am sure there are others out there that have better levels but you'll have a hell of a time closing,

How's the gig going?

Paul C.

Banker
Scottsdale, Arizona
Bloodfire_forum_avatar

309 posts

The gig is going good man, I am set to liquidate $3.5mil this month which is a pretty big deal for an individual to do around here.

I am still confused though, I thought that you were seeing deals at a lot lower than 65%? Are there really a ton of banks selling @ 65%?

At what bulk volumes are you seeing tons of banks liquidate at 65%.
Closed any deals like this in the past couple of months? Please share.

Christopher L.

Real Estate Consultant
Little Town, Oklahoma
Floyd_forum_avatar

549 posts

We are seeing " JUNK" at less than 65% and it won't sell because of the obvious reasons mentioned at every stop on the " net"

Direct to
Mandate
Compiler
POF

And every other intermediary reason to screw up a deal......we went back to institutional only trades,

We are closing a Builder closeout as we speak and trying to deal with the last 50+ units that are rented.....

As we went back to the quality format we entered into a number of DD efforts immediately and I am not familiar with where they stand (as of today)

Back to working smart as they say....

As to 65%..........yes there is PLENTY of inventory at those levels

Paul C.

Banker
Scottsdale, Arizona
Bloodfire_forum_avatar

309 posts

I am still very skeptical of large Bulk REO only trades going on at 65%. I can see NPNs selling at these numbers, but not REOs...the bank has put way too much time and money(fcl/holding costs) during fcl to just liquidate their inventory that low. I feel that most institutions would rather market their REOs individually in hopes of getting 80-90% of the FMV.

Stephen M.

Residential Real Estate Agent
Moreno Valley, CA
The_house_forum_avatar

189 posts

Paul: This may be a stupid observation but what choice do they have. In order to stay liquid you have to move properties. No one wants to sell there toys right now for 50 cents on the dollar but they gotta go.

Paul C.

Banker
Scottsdale, Arizona
Bloodfire_forum_avatar

309 posts

I guess I am speaking from my own experience as a servicer. The two largest investors we service for are Deutsche and Lehman. We liquidate REOs on an individual basis for both of these investors. There is no hurry or sense of urgency to get any bulk deals done at 65% from what I have seen from these two. They would rather us list it at FMV and then accept anything between 10-15% less than FMV. To liquidate a property at 65% or less would be a bad business decision IMO. I could only see the bank doing this if the property has been on the market for 1+ years, it is a real junker, or more taxes are owed than what it is potentially worth, but not just to stay liquid. Banks want top dollar, its the only way they are going to stay in business.

Christopher L.

Real Estate Consultant
Little Town, Oklahoma
Floyd_forum_avatar

549 posts

Bring me your checkbook and I'll show you what a 65% (REO) product list looks like and who's moving it....NPN's are market level at 50's " before" due diligence

Remember Paul I said " minimum" some trades like TX are at 68-72 (REO)

Austin is crazy high......Charlotte is similar. Every region has it's market level

I have a bank list of 180+ in TX for sale at 80

The reason they aren't moving as of yet is the noose gets tighter in the Q3 and Q4 environments. Banks cannot take financials across the year end and expect to continue the shuffling of the deck. It always gets furious in Nov-Dec

I have access to DB paper.....I'll let you know what I get (see) next week. Lehman is more of a buy side opportunity with us so I doubt I'm going to get anything there for sale

But I'll let you know,

Happy 4th

Stephen M.

Residential Real Estate Agent
Moreno Valley, CA
The_house_forum_avatar

189 posts

I am guessing the mood has changed a little sense the government now recognizes a REO as an asset and not a hold to there line. Does it make sense to liquidate quickly to save servicing costs? What whould you say tha average cost (servicer wide) is per property up to REO and from REO to close of escrow? Lets say it took six months to sell.

Is that something you are allowed to answer or will post?

Paul C.

Banker
Scottsdale, Arizona
Bloodfire_forum_avatar

309 posts

Originally posted by "Licwidsand"
I am guessing the mood has changed a little sense the government now recognizes a REO as an asset and not a hold to there line. Does it make sense to liquidate quickly to save servicing costs? What whould you say tha average cost (servicer wide) is per property up to REO and from REO to close of escrow? Lets say it took six months to sell.

Is that something you are allowed to answer or will post?

I honestly don't know what our costs for servicing are, I guess I should find out. These are usually figures that only a select few in my orginization know, I will see what I can find.

Christopher L.

Real Estate Consultant
Little Town, Oklahoma
Floyd_forum_avatar

549 posts

Market values for servicing are .25 bps