Follow Us on Social Media

email icon rss icon linked.in icon google plus icon twitter icon facebook icon

Should You Invest in a Vacation Home in 2013?

by Guest Blogger on May 6, 2013 · 6 comments

  
Vacation Home

Real estate is back.

Prices have stopped their slow, agonizing slide south, and interest rates remain blessedly low. Both institutional and individual investors are on a tear, snatching up homes to turn into rentals, leaving homebuyers – especially first-timers – empty-handed in their wake.

Those low interest rates are sure attractive, aren’t they? They kind of make you think about jumping into the market yourself, maybe picking up a cute little vacation cottage on the lake. Before you get too carried away, there’s a lot more to investing in a vacation home than doing so because of a healthy, sexy real estate market.

Crunch the Numbers

When thinking about buying a vacation home, crunch the numbers before pulling the trigger on the purchase. First, add up all the expenses for one year that you’ll encounter when trying to support a second home: taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance, repairs, property management fees, HOA fees and your mortgage payment.

Add that sum to what you currently pay, annually, for those same expenses for your primary residence. Divide the result by 12 to determine the monthly outlay required to own the vacation home.

If you didn’t have to pick yourself up off the floor after reading that figure, congratulations! You might just be the ideal candidate for owning a vacation home.

Mark Purtell, owner of LeaseYourPlace.com, a website for landlords, suggests that you divide the annual expense of owning a vacation home by how many days you’ll use it each year. Compare that figure to what it costs to rent a similar home in the area. If it’s cheaper to own than to rent, it just might make sense to purchase.

Advantages of Owning a Vacation Home

Most of the advantages that come with owning a vacation home contain caveats – covered more thoroughly in the Disadvantages section, below.

If you don’t plan on renting the home out regularly, it isn’t considered an investment property, and you may get the same mortgage interest rate that you would were you purchasing a primary residence. There is also the possibility, depending on your particular circumstances, of being able to deduct the interest you pay from your income taxes.

If you rent out the home fewer than 15 days per year, you may be able to pocket the rental income tax-free, but you can’t write off any of the expenses.

The opportunity to realize income from renting out the property more often, however, is a big attraction for many buyers. After all, who doesn’t like passive income? If the home is located in a popular vacation destination where steady occupancy is more reliable, ongoing income can cover some of your expenses.

Then there is the chance that the home will increase in value, making it a sound financial investment.

Disadvantages

Before you entertain visions of all the passive income you’ll make renting out your vacation home, understand that the business of vacation rentals is seasonal. Depending on where the home is located there could be a vast expanse of time where you aren’t bringing in any income.

If you are buying a vacation home to have a place for relaxation and recreation, you may have a rude awakening when reality hits. Many vacation-home owners complain that they end up spending their vacations performing repairs, upgrading, chopping firewood, landscaping and all the other chores that don’t get done while they aren’t there.

Remember, you are the homeowner – no matter how much or how little time you spend there – and homeownership brings with it certain responsibilities.

Get ready to plunk down a hefty amount of cash if you need financing for your vacation home – typically 30 to 40 percent of the purchase price. Second-home loans are considered riskier than mortgages on primary residences, so lenders have more stringent rules.

If the lender considers the home an investment property, expect to pay 1.5 to 2 percentage points more than you would for a primary residence. Of course, lender standards vary, and you’ll find some lenders that refuse to make second-home loans, others that actively solicit buyers for second homes, and a range of variations between the two extremes.

Finally, what look like tax benefits while you own the home – deducting depreciation, for instance – may be what John Girouard, author of “The Ten Truths of Wealth Creation,” calls a “tax time bomb.”

“If you’ve owned a rented-out vacation home and claimed the deductions you were entitled to for two or three decades, you could be in for an ugly shock,” he warns.

All that equity you thought you were building? It may be wiped out by IRS depreciation recapture rules when you sell. Girouard explains that the IRS imposes a tax on those depreciation deductions you took all those years you owned the home.

Get ‘em While They’re Hot

Almost half of vacation purchases are made with cash, according to the National Association of Realtors®. For these buyers, many of the downsides of owning a second home don’t apply. If you’ve stared those disadvantages in the face and decide you can swing it, the time to make your move is right now.

While real estate prices nationwide are still considered low, prices in some of the more popular states for second-home owners, such as California and Arizona, are on the rise. Expect prices in regions with low inventories, such as South Florida and the Hamptons, to rise more than the average this year, according to Jonathan Miller, president of Miller Samuel, an appraisal firm.

While 2013 is shaping up to be the year of the vacation home, and there’s an urgency to get into the market before prices rise even more, it’s important to take your time and talk to your CPA before making a final decision.

Shannon O’Brien is a staff writer for RealEstate.com. Her first love was real estate and she has over a decade of residential listing and sales experience. 

Photo: Jeda Villa Bali

Email *
  



{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

Greg May 6, 2013 at 4:30 pm

I got my vacation home as a townhouse, meaning I don’t manage the pool, the lawns, or anything outside. In FL they are at half price, and we travel there all the time, so I couldn’t resist.

I found a mortgage broker that got us a residential loan at 4.5% 18 months ago, and that’s only because I didn’t spend another nickel on fees to lower the rate.

We don’t rent it out because in the Orlando area, you can’t legally rent shorter than a year except in certain zoned areas. So there’s another thing to check out. The house has already risen in value an estimated 10% and they are building more townhomes in our neighborhood, another good sign of value. Of course, we have to pay for utilities, but that was part of my calculation, and when it made sense to stay in our townhome for a month (where I can also work) at a much cheaper price than staying in some fleabag motel, the decision was obvious.

It’s not truly an investment property, because it doesn’t yield cash. But it has grown our net worth, and if I was in a pinch, I could either sell it or take out a HELOC to get my hands on cash.

Reply

Karen Rittenhouse May 7, 2013 at 6:50 am

I appreciate the list of disadvantages. We certainly found those to be true.

And, I don’t know anyone who makes good returns unless it’s free-and-clear. Most vacation properties are very seasonal and I’ve come to the conclusion that expecting a 50% return on expenses rather than cashflow is more like it.

We have personally found owning and renting out homes to be way more income producing than vacation properties. And, in an economic downturn, vacation properties are hit first and hardest.

Buyer beware!

Reply

Melinda May 7, 2013 at 7:59 pm

Vacation rentals are by no means passive income, and more often, are active losses. Think very carefully, do your research into license & zoning laws, and be sure you are able to carry the home without the rentals (or counting on selling to tap the appreciation). There are some great values out there for those up to the task.

Reply

Page May 8, 2013 at 9:37 am

I’m considering a duplex property in which I’d rent out the bottom year-round, and the top unit would be a summer vacation rental and academic year rental the rest of the time. I’ve seen others do this, but aside from the obvious costs of furnishings and other vacation rental expenses, I’m wondering if there are other less obvious things to consider.

The long term plan if we hold the property would be to use it to live in part of the year while we live elsewhere the rest of the time. This one would fit the bill.

Reply

Greg May 8, 2013 at 9:43 am

Another thing is to investigate what deductions you can and can’t take. There are rules about the amount of time you stay in it and whether it’s considered a personal residence or an investment. Make sure you talk to the right tax person or accountant! The ones that process personal tax returns for a majority of the public might not be familiar with these parts of the IRC.

Reply

Peter June 19, 2013 at 10:59 am

We appreciate the list of down sides. Many of us surely discovered those to be accurate.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Comment Policy:

• Use your real name and only your name in the field designated for your name.
• No keywords allowed as anchor text in the name or comment fields.
• No signature links allowed under your comments
• You may use links in the body of your comment, but it must be relevant to the discussion at hand, and not merely be some promotional link.
• We will have NO reservations about deleting your content if we feel you are posting merely to get a link without adding value to our discussion.
If you add value, but still post keywords, we'll use your comment, but remove your link and keywords.
• For more information about acceptable practice, see our site rules.

Want your photo to appear next to your comments? Set up your Gravatar today.

Previous post:

Next post: