Real Estate News & Commentary

What Constitutes Passive Income?

4 Articles Written

A recent BiggerPockets forum thread discussed bonds versus real estate and how real estate wasn't passive. Real estate investors often employ property managers to help them manage their assets so that they can focus their time and effort on making quality offers on good product. Gurus often use the idea of sit-in-the-hammock lifestyle to sell their program and the notion of investing money in real estate in general.

Want more articles like this?

Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up for free

What constitutes truly passive income?  Where is the line drawn?

First of all, strictly speaking bonds are not truly passive investments either. If you want to get nitpicky about things there are big risks with investing in bonds or even bond funds. Individual bonds carry default risk and funds are still largely exposed to inflation risk. Try sitting in a hammock owning long-term bonds when inflation is clicking off at double the coupon rate for the bond! Your frozen daiquiris may start to get a little less appetizing when they cost twice as much and your fixed income is still kicking along at the same rate. There are certainly things that can be done to immunize this risk, but all bonds suffer when interest rates follow inflation expectations north.

So is there really an appreciable difference between investing in real estate “passively” and bond funds? 
The goal of both investments seems to be to limit management activity while supplying ample spendable cash for fixed income.  Free and clear real estate exhibits many of the same features that a bond does, but is intrinsically valuable and thus does a decent job of hedging inflation risk.  With the government’s spendthrift policies many believe inflation will rear its ugly head in the long run.  However, real estate has many negative factors like capital expenditures and high transaction costs. 

Real estate has the capacity to be highly leveraged rather easily and thus carries higher risks in many cases. Investors generally try to optimize their ROE by employing high leverage and thus the capital expenditures and other gotchas make it seem less passive than bonds. Free and clear real estate kicks off large annual cash flows and thus provides a high margin of safety for downside risk. Thus I would argue that real estate can be every bit as passive as bonds if you have a competent manager and low levels of leverage to cover risk. Vacancies and roofs leaking are traded off for a lack of inflation protection and default risk.

Photo: Brendan Riley

    Replied over 9 years ago
    Completely Agree. Even though I’ve seen guys with large portfolios come, I’ve also recently seen them go given the fact that they were highly leveraged and their entire portfolio values dropped dramatically leaving them holding the bill. I’d rather grow slow but have the peace of mind knowing that the profit is truly being made, no matter the value of the underlying asset.
    Adam B
    Replied over 9 years ago
    Any money that I receive residually without performing for it. Great Post Knowledge is not the key it is applied knowledge that is the key.
    Replied over 9 years ago
    Hi, Great post on passive income… with regard to real estate as passive income, if the occupancy is solid, you can meet the expenses of ownership, and you have a management company with a solid track record then real estate can definately be a passive form of income. In the end passive is just about being incontrol of ones time right? A writer makes passive income when he creates a book and it sells while he’s sleeping… in the same way owning realestate requires the work of getting it setup (getting funding, finding the right management company, etc… etc…) Passive happens after the work is done… but once it is, then your income should outpace the cost of your frozen daiquiris with no problems… (Certainly CDs, bonds and other middle class investment vehicles can’t do that!) Great article… Sincerely, Jay