Business Management

20 Questions To Ask Before Hiring Rental Property Management!

Expertise: Personal Development, Real Estate Investing Basics, Landlording & Rental Properties, Real Estate News & Commentary, Business Management, Real Estate Marketing, Mortgages & Creative Financing
143 Articles Written
Questions for hiring property management

I get this question a lot from real estate investors and it came up recently on the forums. "How do I know if a property management company is any good?" My answer always comes back to the questions you are asking the company you are getting ready to hire. Before you will know if they are any good at the service you are looking for, you have to know the right questions to ask. I have been advising real estate investors to ask these same 20 questions for years and so far, they have helped keep many investors out of trouble.

Want more articles like this?

Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inbox

Sign up for free

Investing Out of Area

Before listing out the questions, we have to remember that all real estate is local.  Where we live and where we invest do not have to be and often are not in the same city.  Even when we are investing in the same city that we live, when hiring a property management company, an investor is looking for a passive solution to the day to day operation of the property.  It is easy to hear key selling words in a companies proposition and forget to ask the really important questions that let you really dig into the details of a company.

So, with that being said, real estate investors have to be extra vigilant when hiring a property management company or simply accepting a property management company because the service came attached to a turnkey or passive investment. We also have to remember that what works in the market that we live, will not always apply to the market that we are investing in so investors really need to understand the questions and why they are asking them.

Keeping those couple of points in mind as we go through the questions…

Seven Owner Centered Questions

1.  How long have you been in the property management business?

2.  How many properties do you have under management?

3.  Are you an active real estate investor in your market?

4.  What zip codes do you own investment properties?

5.  How many team members does your company employ?

6.  What is your personal definition of rent ready?  (Very important when buying Turnkey)

7.  What is your personal philosophy on deferred maintenance?  (Very important when buying Turnkey)

As a future client, you want to know that the owner of the property management company actually knows what they are doing.  Not  just managing properties, but also managing a business.    These first questions should help you to form an impression.  Does the owner know the business inside and out.  Are they growing and actively involved in the business they are operating?  These are important internal questions for you to answer.  Not to mention, do their ideas about real estate investing line up with yours?

Lastly, you want to know that they actually invest themselves.  As you ask these questions, make sure that you keep the answers and reflect back on them as you are asking some of the other questions.

Related: A Real-Life Property Management Setup

Nine Company Operations Questions

1. How many properties do you rent in an average month? (Follow up with how many are 1st time rentals?)

2.  How many properties go vacant in an average month?

3.  How many days does it take a property to get re-occupied from the day it goes vacant?

4.  What is the average length of occupancy per tenant?

5.   What is the average rental rate per property?

6.  What is the average deposit per property?

7.  What percentage of the billed rent is collected by the 10th, 20th and last day of each month?

8.  What percentage of the billed rent is paid to owners by the last day of each month?

9.  What is your average vacancy rate by month?

The reason that I tell investors to ask these specific questions is so they can compare numbers.  It is really easy for a company to quickly list off how good they are and what I have seen is owners who give answers off the top of their heads.  They think it simply sounds better to give an answer than to say, “I am not sure, but I will find out.”  As a prospective client, you want to know that they track and monitor everything and that their numbers match up.

If you ask the above questions and use the answers, you can back calculate into many of the other numbers.  Unfortunately, this will be able to show you when someone is just making the numbers up as they go.

Related: 10 Ways to Help Out Your Property Management Company

Three Company Specific Questions

1.  What deferred maintenance costs can I expect in the next 5 years?

2.  What specific program(s) are in place to increase tenant satisfaction?

3.  What specific program(s) are in place to increase owner communication?

Really good property management companies will have evolved away from simply managing properties and the process. They will understand that outreach and service are going to be the main factors in a rental property owners success. Longer occupancy, lower holding costs, fewer repair bills and lower move-out bills all will result from doing business with a company that understand how to communicate and offer top notch service to tenants.

One Final Question

What has been your biggest mistake as an investor or business owner?

This is one of those questions that will really test the integrity and value system of the person you are asking.  If they take offense to it, then they are never going to build a relationship with you as a client of their company.  They are never going to see you as a valuable asset to their company.  If they answer the question with a nice short “I have never made a mistake,” then again, you may want to reconsider them as a partner.  Anyone who has been investing in real estate for the last 10 years has made mistakes.  Maybe not major mistakes, but this has been a wild 10 years for real estate.

Same goes for being a business owner.  If they can’t pinpoint an area or event or decision that was a major mistake as a business owner, then they likely will not be able to pinpoint how they are improving their company for you as an owner.  Every smart entrepreneur can self analyze and point out mistakes and areas for improvement.  As an investor, I suggest you ask that question before making your final decision on hiring a property management company and listen closely to the answer.

I know there have to be other questions that you would suggest an investor ask a property management company.  What are the questions you would advise investors to ask?


Chris Clothier began building his rental portfolio in 2003 as a successful entrepreneur looking to diversify his investments. He quickly gravitated toward passive investing, establishing a portfoli...
Read more
    Jonathan M
    Replied over 6 years ago
    This is very useful. Thank you.
    Jonathan M
    Replied over 6 years ago
    This is very useful. Thank you.
    Charlie Williams
    Replied over 6 years ago
    Very timely article for me. My business partner and I are almost at the point of having too many units for us to manage ourselves. Charlie -VA
    Lear Riojas
    Replied over 6 years ago
    To caveat off of this article I have discovered simply calling the prospective property manager is a great education. I filtered several companies pretty easily by calling them on the phone. By calling them I learned how responsive they are to calls, If they are professionals, also if they will do what they say they will do. Usually crappy companies have answering service during the business day. Slow to respond to voicemails and emails. I had a property manager return my call 6 weeks after I called him, I could imagine how awful his tenants must be suffering.
    Dan Ryu
    Replied over 6 years ago
    @Chris Clothier This is a great resource! So I’m guessing it takes about 30 minutes to go through a property management ‘interview’? Do you usually schedule an ‘appointment’ ahead of time to ask these questions?
    James Schiller
    Replied over 6 years ago
    Good work! This is a very intuitive article. These are really good suggestions of questions for both property managers and their clients. The list will give clients a sort of guide, wherein they will have a set of questions to best ask. It will also help them see if they can have a good working relationship with the property manager and that manager will be reliable. From a realtor’s point of view, I also see this guidelines as helpful ton property managers, because it will help them determine what is most expected of them by their clients. Working as a realtor, I know firsthand how it pays to be prepared by anticipating would-be questions of clients. For years, meeting my clients prepared has served me well to earn much success with them.
    Mehran Kamari
    Replied over 6 years ago
    I’m an out of state investor and have 3 different people/companies managing different properties. Knowing this information is KEY to being able to fully vet how things are actually going to run when you close on the property and it’s performing. When “first” interviewing property managers I put together a questionnaire of my own that focused mainly on operations and costs etc. This questionnaire is on a whole other level and after the year I’ve spent working with property managers, I wouldn’t hire a company unless they answered all these questions the right way. I appreciate you taking the time to write this article Chris, thanks!
    Steven Murray
    Replied over 6 years ago
    I would add a couple of more questions: 1. How soon do you pay the owner after receiving the rent from the tenant? If the property management company is going to sit on the money for a 2-3 weeks every month after receiving it from the tenant, then you will want to know that up front. You want a property management company who is going to pay the owners within a few business days after receiving rent from tenants. 2. How many of your clients have multiple properties with you? If the majority of their clients have multiple properties, the management company is probably not motivated to work very hard for you if you are just placing one property with them. Their focus is always going to be on their clients that have the most properties.
    Replied over 6 years ago
    What questions would you have for a vaccation rental?
    Replied over 6 years ago
    What a great list! I have a new place just outside where I have several units and my original solution isn’t panning out. I have mostly used people that I’ve gotten strong referrals in long distance situations in the past but no such luck here. This will be a great addition to my interviews.
    Replied over 6 years ago
    What a great list! I have a new place just outside where I have several units and my original solution isn’t panning out. I have mostly used people that I’ve gotten strong referrals in long distance situations in the past but no such luck here. This will be a great addition to my interviews.
    Replied over 6 years ago
    Property management companies are a dime a dozen. Contractors are even easier to find. Real Estate agents are like flies at the dump. And I am a RE agent… Ask the property management company what their eviction or turnover rate is. Out of 100 tenants, how many were evicted last year? Or how many new tenants did they have to get. Or how many tenants were non-renewed? What are their minimum tenant screening criteria in terms of income ratio, credit score and criminal history? Who does their tenant screening, if they do it themselves they are likely to skip important steps. They should use a company specializing in background checks. Proper tenant screening, and knowing what to do with it, will make or break you. I don’t care what a cash flow on a building is; a bad tenant can take away the cash flow for several years. That is why many people swear off being a landlord. If it was easy, everyone would be doing it. If a property management company is good, evictions will be well less than 10%. Remember, a property manager makes the MOST, when you make the LEAST. They make money on every turn. If they could, they would turn a unit every month. Spending a few hours up front, can save thousands later.
    Ben Staples Investor from Chicago IL
    Replied about 5 years ago
    Thanks so much for writing. I guess one thing I’m a little confused by is the question of if the property manager is an investor as well. I’ve heard the negatives of, well, if they are an investor and their unit has a vacancy, and yours does too, which will they fill first? Theirs. But I also see what you are saying here as far as having an investor mindset and that being a good thing. Any guidance on where to draw the line between the two? I’m assuming there is a balance.
    Replied about 4 years ago
    Good tips on what to lookout for folks looking to hire / engage with a property management company…