How to Handle Questions Prospective Tenants Ask That Legally You Can’t Answer
Prospective tenants like to ask lots questions.
Want more articles like this?
Create an account today to get BiggerPocket's best blog articles delivered to your inboxSign up for free
“Who else lives here?”
“Where do the people that live here work?”
“Are there any kids living here?”
These types of questions are to be expected. After all, choosing a new place to live and making a move are pretty big decisions. It is not unreasonable for someone to want to know as much as they can about a potential new home and the people that live there.
However, if you as the landlord answer those questions it could put you at risk or even be illegal. When fielding questions from a potential tenant, it is best to say very little if anything about the other tenants in a building.
Your other tenants have likely shared a lot of personal information with you as part of your application and screening process. You have a responsibility to keep that information private.
Plus, answering those questions could appear to be discriminatory under certain conditions and you do not want to open that can of worms.
How to Handle Questions Prospective Tenants Ask That You Cannot Answer
So how do you handle these questions if you can’t answer them? I have found three responses that work well.
1. Let your Prospective Tenant know about Your Screening Criteria.
Tell them how you screen your tenants. For example you might say that you check credit, criminal and job history and everyone must meet minimum standards.
Add that all tenants have been through this process and have been approved. Explain that it is the same process they will have to go through if they choose to rent your property. This type of response often reduces their concerns about who they will be living around.
2. Tell them that it is Against Company Policy to Reveal any Information about Existing Tenants.
Almost everyone understands “company policy.” Plus, it is true. It is against our company policy to reveal any information about our tenants. Most will simply nod their head in understanding when hearing this response.
3. If they are Persistent, Then You can Pull out the “Discrimination Card.”
Tell them that it is discriminatory to release information and against federal law. Everyone understands discrimination and federal law (well, almost everyone). So using this one usually ends the questions.
Some folks however just will not take no for an answer. You as the landlord have to be firm.
Do not give in and “whisper” a few details. Like I said, it is not right and could be illegal. You never really know who you are talking to. So landlords, be nice and respectful, but keep your mouth shut.
Has a potential tenant ever pressured you for details on existing tenants? How did you handle it?
Be sure to leave your comments below!