Your Complete Guide to Effectively Handling Tenant Evictions

by |

If you have been a landlord for any length of time at all, the topic of evicting tenants is on your mind on a continual basis. If you have been doing the right things with your tenant screening, it is on your mind a lot less. If you need the rent to pay the mortgage on the rental or you will lose it, you are praying every week it doesn’t ever come to that.

No matter how well you screen tenants, no matter how great your tenants are, you will at some point be in the position where you may have to evict. Divorces happen, deaths happen, people get laid off and people have friends that cause a ruckus so large you have to do something.

Related: Considering Accepting Money after the Eviction? Beware!

One of the first mistakes a landlord makes is to not look at a tenant application like a mortgage application; an eviction is like a foreclosure, but a lot cheaper.

Download Your FREE guide to evicting a tenant!

We hope you never have to evict a tenant, but know it’s always wise to prepare for the worst. Navigating the legal and financial considerations of an eviction can be tricky, even for the most experienced landlords. Lucky for you, the experts at BiggerPockets have put together a FREE Guide to Evicting Tenants so you can protect your property and investments.

Click Here For Your Free Tenant Eviction Guide

The Tenant Underwriting Process

The first way to avoid an eviction is to get solid tenants to begin with.

You need to make sure the tenant’s income level is high enough to pay rent. And it is verifiable. There are no liar loans in this game; you are not a mortgage broker from 2005. You are loaning your $100K property to a tenant, and you need to do proper underwriting on them before you give them the keys. They need to pay less than 30% of their income in rent. If you charge more than that, any eviction is your own fault; you have set the tenants — and yourself — up for failure.

The second step in the underwriting process is to check the credit score. If a tenant has a sub-620 credit score, you have a less than C-grade tenant. With a lower credit score, the tenant is telling you, “I do not pay my other bills; why would I pay you?”

There are numerous other behavioral indicators that credit score will help you determine, but at this point, know a low credit score is a recipe for disaster.

Have a Plan to Deal with Problem Tenants

In my leases — and most other leases I have seen — there is a clause included that says, “RESIDENT will pay MANAGEMENT the full monthly rent before midnight of the first day of each month.”

That means rent is technically late on the first of the month. But most people expect rent to be paid on the first and do not charge a late fee until the fifth. Some landlords have excessive daily late fees, and that is going to set them up for a Judge discarding the fees altogether. Have a reasonable late fee; if you have a daily fee, cap the total fee at 8% or so.

If a tenant has not either paid rent or contacted you by the first of the month to say when they will be paying rent, you need to be concerned. You need to contact them, either with a courtesy call or a cure/quit notice, and see what the problem is. If they do not return your calls or pay rent, you are headed down a slippery slope.

Once the late fee date passes, and you do not have the rent, you need to act fast. Some people like it when their tenants pay the rent late. They want the late fees. But when a tenant pays late, it is only a matter of time before they do not pay at all.

Late Rent Payments

Knowing that rent is always due by the first, a tenant who is going to pay late should at least have some money on the first — and certainly some more by the late fee date.

I would like to see at least half of the rent on the first if they cannot pay it all. You need to ask how much they can pay and get it in your hands as soon as possible. Even $100 shows good faith. I have had tenants tell me they have $300, and by the time I get it a few hours later, it is already down to $280. Any money in your hand could mean the difference between a good month and a bad month. If you are in a state that does not allow an eviction when a tenant pays partial rent, never take anything but the full amount.

It is not out of line to go into detail questioning how much money the tenant has, why it is late and requesting proof that they can actually pay. Most tenants would prefer that over an eviction notice straight away.

If a tenant is going to be late, hopefully they will have contacted you and made arrangements to pay. Or they have made an arrangement to move out by the weekend. It is always preferable to have a mutual agreement to terminate the lease and move out voluntarily than an eviction. But sometimes that is not possible. Never let the move out go longer than a week or you will be facing a sure eviction just later in the month.

When to Evict?

If the late fee date passes and you do not have any money in hand, and your tenant has not returned your calls, emails or texts, or you do not have a date that rent will be paid, you must file an eviction as soon as possible, preferably by the 6th. If the tenant said they were going to be late, and said rent will be paid on Friday, and Friday comes and goes, file an eviction on Monday. If they say they will have rent on the 10th, get as much as you can on the first and the rest on the 10th.

Most landlords who file an eviction wait way too long to file it. If you are waiting longer than ten days to get a resolution for unpaid rent, you should be evicting, not waiting longer. There is always some windfall coming, but it never comes. Unless you see an official document saying money is forthwith, proceed with an eviction.

Once you file an eviction, stay away from the tenant. You have just created an adverse relationship.  DO NOT attempt to collect more rent, inspect the unit, show the unit, change furnace filters — or anything that puts your face in front of the tenant — unless they call you. Stay away, or the tenant might take legal steps to make you stay away.

Always continue the eviction process until the end unless the Court stops you. You started the eviction; now finish it. Get the tenant legally out. Re-rent, and get a new tenant. Do not have the possibility that your bad tenant still has legal possession. Be aware: evicting even a single bad tenant will consume you, even if you have 100 tenants, if you let it.

Related: Self-Help Evictions: What You Should NEVER Do as a Landlord

What does an eviction actually cost? It really depends on the state in which you evict. Some states have low court fees, but high costs in terms of time. Some have high fees and fast evictions. If you have never been through an eviction, get an attorney to walk you through the first one. If you have a long timeline and you flub it, you will have a longer timeline.

For example, a typical cost in Minnesota might be like this:

Eviction Filing. $320. That is just the fee to the court in MN. There is no way around it. A Court date is typically granted within two weeks after paying the fee.

Serving The Complaint. $100. The number one defense to an eviction is being improperly served. Do not mess this one up and do it the cheap way by paying $20 paid to a high school kid. Hire an attorney or a process server. If you use an attorney, they will roll this fee into their total cost.

Attorney Fees. $160. In MN, if you are incorporated or an LLC, you need to have an attorney represent you in Court. There are plenty of attorneys that do low-cost evictions, and they handle the first court appearance for a small sum.

Vacancy Expense. $3,000+. Assuming rent of $1,000 per month, you are going to be out a lot. You are not going to get any rent the month you are evicting; that is why you are evicting. If you waited beyond the 10th, your tenant will still be in your rental after the first of the next month. You need to turn your unit, and show it — but not while you have a tenant you are evicting in the unit. Great tenants look for a place 6-8 weeks out, so at a minimum, you are looking at three month’s vacancy.

The Writ. $55. If you go through with the eviction to the end, you need to file a writ. The Judge will issue the writ a week after the court date if the tenant has children under 18. If not, they issue one immediately. Once the writ is issued, it needs to be served by the Sheriff Civil Division.

Serving the Writ. $125. This needs to be done by the Sheriff, and it is an official notice that the tenant has 24 hours to vacate the premise. It takes two or three business days for the sheriff to actually post it.

Tenant Removal. Free; it is included in the $125 you have already given the sheriff. If your tenants are still in the unit after the 24 hour notice, you need to contact the sheriff to get the tenants out. It may take a couple of days; longer if there are holidays and weekends in the mix. There are no sacred dates here. The Sheriff will do it on Christmas Eve if that is the date they have available.

Repairs and garbage removal. $1,000. When a tenant is getting evicted, they often leave the place a mess. They leave old furniture and mattresses behind. They do not clean anything. This is a big unknown, but a figure of $1,000 is not out of line.

The total costs of an eviction are tallied up like this:

Total Out of Pocket: $760

Vacancy: $3,000

Trash Removal and Repairs: $1,000

Total Cost: $4,760

If you only have a small cash flow margin, a single bad tenant can eat up the cash flow in a hurry.

What has been your experience with evictions? How long did you wait to evict? What’s the most important thing you learned from the process?

Leave me a comment below! 

About Author

Eric D.

Eric is a 55 year old, soon to be former, computer professional. He started several years ago to replace his “work income”, with other alternate streams. He is well on his way to retirement at age 56, and is currently making more money at extracurricular activities, than he is working at his full time job. Whether that is Financially Independent, or just old fashioned entrepreneurial spirit, is in the eyes of the beholder.


  1. Eric

    Great article! I strongly agree with your approach to swift action. Many times tenants will try and string you out with the hope of the full payment amount but rarely does that day ever come. You can try and work with them but still proceed with the 5 day notice and filing until full amount is received.


    • Thank you for the comment!

      Evictions are never fun, you should avoid them at all costs. A tenant needs to show some initiative to avoid them. I have seen often promises after promises that never come to fruition. Waiting a month or two only makes the pain worse.

  2. Eric, thank you for writing this article. My most common problem is waiting too long to begin evictions. Due to my profession I have only had to file one eviction on property I had an ownership interest in. When I had a partner he was very good about doing an immediate contact to say why don’t I have your rent money yet? He always enforced late penalty fees. I am too lenient. I listen to their story and if it is not grossly stupid and I believe them, I will work with them. I think I( dread the rehab more than I do the eviction. My state has very fast eviction laws and I have had several pay cases where I had evictions done in less than 2 weeks. I have universally found that evictions are the worst for property being in bad shape.

    • Thank you for the comment!

      You are not alone. There is a lot of work after an eviction, usually. the secret to avoiding evictions is to get solid tenants, in the first place. I have known landlords that have had to evict two tenants from the same place, in the same year. That is far to high of a percentage.

      Make sure you have a quality place. Know what to look for in regards of tenant quality. Then stick to your standards.

  3. I had always wondered what the eviction process was and how much it would cost. Fortunately we have not had to perform an eviction yet, but we were close. Thanks for the great article.

    • Thank you for the comment!

      When I first started as a landlord, I was in the middle of evictions quite often. Now I have many more units, and have not had an eviction in a few years.

      Tenant screening is the key.

    • Thank you for the comment!

      Your cost might be different, especially of you live in a more tenant friendly city/state, like CHI or NY. Starting early is the way to reduce costs. In some states, it takes months.

  4. Eric, thank you for this article.

    When a tenant gives notice, it’s like a clock starts ticking in my head. I can get anxious. To counteract that, I place this quote on the top of my screen:

    “It is better to have NO tenant, then to have the wrong tenant.”

    I will also copy and keep your advice.

  5. One of the hardest things to do is to not let an eviction CONSUME YOU and your time. As was poiinted out, one bad tenant can ruin your whole quarter. I am as guilty as the next person….slackiing on the front end and paying the price later. I have adoped the policy of “i’d rather pay up front with a vacancy than have a tenant living in (and doing damage) to my property while the court process drags on! Cash for keys? Why not…its cheaper. However, sometimes it is worth my time and effort to nail one of these “peop;e” and put a judgment on their credit whether I ever get it or not. In the future, with a registered judgment on their file, they will pay more for any credit (if they can get it) and I admit to some degree of satisfaction in that. Particularly if they have trashed my place!! I DO AGREE, screen screen screen and ask as many quesitions as you can until you are satisfied. Still… will get by you from time to time….but TRY to not let the eviction process and dealing with a bad tenant consume you…………….he says as he tries to yield to his own advice. Best to all

    • Thank you for the comment!

      You are 100% correct! Vacancy is way cheaper than a bad tenant. Even if you have criteria that weeds out 90% of bad tenants, that one out of 10 will wipe out your profit.

  6. I use a realty for property management and also i am very involved in possess as well very active.every few years I have eviction. after this I update property so much that I also actually moving ahead and me and property are far better.

  7. Alan Sparks

    I have procured some great data from the above substance. The landlord-tenant relationship can be harmonious. But sometimes we face some weird situation. But we need to keep in mind that eviction is not an easy task. In order to avoid it, the main solution is to find out solid tenants and check their previous backgrounds thoroughly.

Leave A Reply

Pair a profile with your post!

Create a Free Account


Log In Here