The Top 7 Costly Mistakes Seasoned Real Estate Investors Make

by |

“Smart people learn from their mistakes. But the real sharp ones learn from the mistakes of others.” – Brandon Mull

Hi, all. It’s Liz (Matt’s wife) back this week to discuss the most common mistakes experienced investors make in this business! There are a ton of articles written here on BP for newbies and rightfully so! When you are starting out in this business, there are A LOT of mistakes to avoid. However, as you grow your portfolio and move from being a “newbie” to being experienced, there are different (and new) mistakes to avoid. I think there is a lot of truth to the quote at the beginning. If you can learn from the mistakes of others, then why make them yourself?

My husband Matt and I have been in this real estate investing game for more than 10 years, and we certainly continue to make mistakes. We are far from perfect. However, we have improved our business and success rate over the years as well.

As you become a seasoned investor, you want to avoid these more costly mistakes. The key is to not only learn from your mistakes, but also to improve yourself and your business as a result. As an experienced and seasoned investor, here are the top seven mistakes to avoid.

Related: Confessions of Serial Mistake-Maker: How I’ve Found Real Estate Success Through Failure

Download Your FREE Tenant Screening Guide!

Hey there! Screening tenants can be a tricky business, and this critical step can be the difference between profits and disaster. To help you with your real estate investing journey, feel free to download BiggerPockets’ complimentary Tenant Screening Guide and get the information you need to find great tenants.

Click Here For Your Free Tenant Screening Guide

The Top 7 Costly Mistakes Seasoned Real Estate Investors Make

1. They stop doing the necessary due diligence.

I can’t stress this one enough. I have seen so many seasoned investors not do their necessary homework and due diligence on deals because they think they know all the numbers already! Obviously, as you become more experienced, due diligence might look a little different. As a seasoned vet, you are more confident and you are able to make decisions faster. However, this does not mean you don’t have to run the numbers and ensure the deal you are buying (as a rental or flip or whatever) makes sense financially.

2. They stop surrounding themselves with people who have more experience/success.

It is really easy for seasoned investors to surround themselves with new investors. Many investors enjoy teaching others about their mistakes and helping those who are starting out. And that is great and should always continue happening. That is what is great about this business. However, it is imperative for seasoned investors to also surround themselves with investors who have more success and experience. If you own 10, 20 or 50 rental units, find someone who owns 100 units. If you flip 10 properties a year and want to expand, find someone who flips 25 a year. Remember the old saying, “You become who you surround yourself with.”

3. They try to do it all by themselves.

I know of a few guys in our local REI club who make this mistake. Quite honestly, you can be successful and seasoned and never build a team. But the question is, will you be able to grow? I know one gentleman in particular who owns about 25 rental units and as a result was able to quit his day job. It seems like he runs a very successful business.

During a recent networking meeting, we were chatting about business together. He made a comment that he is done trying to find help rehabbing his properties. He told me he can’t find anyone who can fix up his properties as well as he can. I certainly understand his challenge. Finding great contractors is not the easiest task; however, this investor’s time is maxed out at 25 units. He won’t grow if he does it all by himself.

4. They don’t review (and reassess) their plan ALL THE TIME.

Seasoned investors may or may not want to grow their portfolio. And that is fine. Many seasoned investors grow their portfolio to a point and focus on managing it instead of continuing to build it. Regardless, they still need a plan to keep them focused and need to assess the plan on an ongoing basis. I hate to use this word – but seasoned investors can get lazy. When you look at the top athletes, companies, and people in the world, a habit that ensures success is that they are always reassessing their plan and committing themselves to new actions and goals.

5. They don’t use or learn new technology.

Last night I was at an event and heard a couple of ladies (younger than me!) talking about “Snapchat.” I have heard of it, but was not familiar. So I asked what it was all about. I felt a little stupid, but technology and social media apps are evolving fast! I don’t need to tell you that technology is always changing – even as we speak. I can attest very personally to this one. Our team certainly needs to do a better job of utilizing technology for achieving our goals. From using social media more effectively to better optimizing our website, we have lots of room to grow. However, we at least realize this and are making a plan to improve this area!

6. They don’t seek new financing strategies.

Seasoned investors get in the habit of paying their bills and don’t review their financing strategies often enough. Maybe you have grown as much as you can and have been avoiding looking for private money. Maybe you have an “interest only” loan on one of your rentals that you have been dragging your feet to refinance. Maybe you are over leveraged on a property (in other words you have too much debt on the property). Whatever the case may be, you have to continually (at least yearly) review your financing strategies and look for ways to improve your financial situation.

Related: 5 Common Mistakes That Sabotage Fix & Flip Profits

7. They stop “sharpening the saw.”

I wish I could take credit for this phrase “sharpening the saw,” but I can’t! It is actually one of the habits Steven Covey discussed in his international bestseller The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People. This book was actually published in 1989; however, it is probably one of my favorite business books of all time. With the habit he calls “sharpening the saw,” he discusses the importance of taking time for yourself – mentally, spiritually, physically, etc. I can’t stress enough the importance of this one, not just for effectiveness in your real estate business, but in your life in general. The key is to find out what “sharpening the saw” looks like for you and then create habits to make it happen in your daily and weekly life. No excuses!

Thank you as always for reading and commenting!

Seasoned investors – which mistakes am I missing? What would you add to this list?

Leave your comments below, and as always, happy investing!

About Author

Matt Faircloth

Matt Faircloth, Co-founder & President of the DeRosa Group, is a seasoned real estate investor. The DeRosa Group, based in historic Trenton, New Jersey, is a developer and owner of commercial and residential property with a mission to “transform lives through real estate." Matt, along with his wife Liz, started investing in real estate in 2004 with the purchase of a duplex outside of Philadelphia with a $30,000 private loan. They founded DeRosa Group in 2005 and have since grown the company to owning and managing over 370 units of residential and commercial assets throughout the east coast. DeRosa has completed over $30 million in real estate transactions involving private capital including fix and flips, single family home rentals, mixed use buildings, apartment buildings, office buildings, and tax lien investments. Matt Faircloth is the author of Raising Private Capital, has been featured on the BiggerPockets Podcast, and regularly contributes to BiggerPockets’s Facebook Live sessions and educational webinars.


  1. Jonna Weber

    Thanks Matt – really good reminders! #2 particularly struck me. I need to be more intentional about surrounding myself with more experienced, successful people than myself. Podcasts and books are one effective way I do this, but there is something different about actually spending time with a network that challenges and grows you.

    • Elizabeth Faircloth

      Hi Jonna,
      I actually wrote this week’s blog post! Thanks for your comment! And yes, I can’t agree with you more about #2. I can do better with this one as well. I am part of a “woman entrepreneur mastermind” group and we meet on a monthly basis. We are all in different types of businesses. I love the mastermind concept and in the past have loved being part of this type of group. Additionally, I am also very interested in finding a mentor as well. Just some thoughts to share with you!
      Take care and thank you so much for commenting.
      Would love to hear your progress with #2 !!

  2. Richard Guzman on

    Hi Liz- it is good to read your post again as I am enjoying some time off from school during my spring break!! As usual another “great read” for the day! I must admit as a novice investor I appreciate and admire these points you are saying, especially #1- this can be hard to avoid as sometimes one can feel they don’t have to make that extra phone call to an agent or go into that county website and spend that extra time for research resulting in making that decision “as is”. #2 – I have heard plenty of times over and over again and I guess as I get older this is seems easier for me. Talking to childhood friends or even fellow students seems awkward now especially when our focus is so much different. I like meeting likeminded people and just absorbing what they have to say (I told Matt I would do this next time I go to Philly). I particularly like #5 as recently I downloaded and learned how to use Evernote. It is a good app to basically organize and sort all kinds of notes, pictures, documents, etc. you have. I use to just write out all my notes from meetings and webinars but this allows you to store and refer back at anytime with a simple search word-very awesome!
    Thanks again for the great post (tool) I needed to sharpen my saw. Please pass my regards to Matt and I hope you both enjoy Easter Sunday.


    • Elizabeth Faircloth

      Hi Richard,
      Nice to hear from you and thanks for commenting on our blog!! #1 is an easy one to forget, but an important one (especially as you get more and more experience). #2 is not always an easy one either. I think people like teaching more than learning! 🙂 But it is crucial to keeping yourself growing!
      Thanks again for commenting and reading!
      Enjoy your Easter Sunday too!

  3. I was enjoying the post and thinking yeah that’s all good input and then you got to the saw.
    Prior to these softer, maybe easier times I find myself in, everything depended on good cutting saws. A single damaged tooth in an otherwise great saw will cause a skip that makes it grabby thus dangerous for you, overall dull is merely the difference between working a job or a job working you.
    The bigger and more powerful the saws in use the more critically important it is to every one near them that they be in good working order. A place I worked had pieces of saws stuck in solid steel where they had found reason to complain about their working conditions. I was present when many of those big saws blew up, I could take you on a tour of what your favorite business book was really talking about.
    Great post, it made me think, if just one of those things could make a difference in the way that the bigger picture would develop in the end then most certainly it is worth looking at the whole overall way that things are being done.
    Thanks for the read and the memories

    • Elizabeth Faircloth

      Hi Gary,
      Thanks for your input and comments. I did not realize the discussion of “saws” would cause a discussion! I should have guessed that though since utilizing a saw is connected to what we do in real estate investing!! Not sure if you ever read the actual analogy that Steven Covey makes, but it is a good story to illustrate the importance of keeping yourself fresh and putting time aside for yourself.
      Thanks again for commenting and thanks for reading the blog. I hope it provides some inspiration.

Leave A Reply

Pair a profile with your post!

Create a Free Account


Log In Here