Skip to content
Buying & Selling Real Estate

User Stats

122
Posts
18
Votes
Daniel Miller
  • Fremont, CA
18
Votes |
122
Posts

decisions for prepping house before selling

Daniel Miller
  • Fremont, CA
Posted Jun 29 2022, 14:33
I am selling a house (San Jose, CA)... I have selected an agent to handle the house; he's been in the business for many years, and has a good reputation with previous customers.  I've felt good in all my dealings with him so far, but a couple of his decisions didn't seem right to me; some I just said "no, we're not going to do that", and he's given me no problems with that... but there is one thing he wants to do, that I'm not sure about, so I wanted to ask folks here what they think about it...

The topic is hardwood vs carpet floors... we have a combined living room/dining room, and a long hallway... the living/dining room is currently carpeted, but very old and ugly, it will get replaced with *something* in any case; the hallway is 50+ year old tile.  He is a strong believer in hardwood floors, and wants to convert all of those areas into that; actually, he says that his contractor looked under the existing carpet and says there is a beautiful hardwood floor underneath that rug, that would be lovely once they cleaned it up and refinished it (it has been carpeted for at least the past 50 years).  He has told me multiple times that buyers *much* prefer hardwood floors...

However, that doesn't really match my (admittedly meager) experice; milady and I *hate* cold hardwood floors, and both of the tenants that rented it, felt the same, and they both got throw carpets to cover the two smaller rooms that are currently hardwood floors... so I don't know what to think about this...

And *yes*, it is true that I won't be living there anyway, so what do I care??  He's getting me quotes for both options, and they look at this point like the costs will be more or less comparable.

Anyway, I just would like to know what other people with experience, think about hardwood vs carpet floors, specifically in heavily-used central rooms??  I wish to have some insight into this topic, from people who have experience in dealing with many properties.  Thank you all once again for your insights!!

User Stats

136
Posts
115
Votes
Replied Jun 29 2022, 15:18

I enjoy hardwood, I believe it will be a selling point and more appealing. Carpets look cheap and exposing what's actually under them is a great step for a seller. I know you Californians have weird carpet taste.... I saw a house in Tahoe with Carpet in the bathroom 

User Stats

4,647
Posts
12,346
Votes
Mike Dymski#5 Investor Mindset Contributor
  • Investor
  • Greenville, SC
12,346
Votes |
4,647
Posts
Mike Dymski#5 Investor Mindset Contributor
  • Investor
  • Greenville, SC
Replied Jun 29 2022, 15:26

If there are nice hardwoods underneath the carpet and you are going to replace the flooring, refinishing the hardwoods is a no brainer for added value and mass appeal.

NREIG  logo
NREIG
|
Sponsored
Customizable insurance coverage with a program that’s easy to use Add, edit, and remove properties from your account any time with no minimum-earned premiums.

User Stats

2,606
Posts
2,978
Votes
Scott E.
  • Developer
  • Scottsdale, AZ
2,978
Votes |
2,606
Posts
Scott E.
  • Developer
  • Scottsdale, AZ
Replied Jun 29 2022, 15:39

From a design and salability standpoint, your realtor is right. Carpet is awful.

Your house will be 1000x more appealing to most buyers if you replace the flooring throughout with a hardwood, porcelain tile, ceramic tile, or even laminate that looks like wood.

Some people do prefer carpet in the bedrooms which I understand. But I would never put carpet in any common living space (use an area rug in the staging if you want it to feel a little cozier)

User Stats

6,552
Posts
3,929
Votes
Replied Jun 29 2022, 20:18

I will never ever consider buying a property with carpet for my residence.
Carpet is full of dust and the root cause of many diseases.

User Stats

122
Posts
18
Votes
Daniel Miller
  • Fremont, CA
18
Votes |
122
Posts
Daniel Miller
  • Fremont, CA
Replied Jun 30 2022, 08:24
ummm... okay, that's pretty consistent... I'll go with his recommendation then.  Thank you all!!