NY-ISH STR Picks and rationale

[Alex Lee]

So, a debate popped up between family and friends, and I'm curious to know your thoughts. We have:

1. Upstate NY

2. Long Island

3. New Jersey

4. Pennsylvania (debate went between Philly, Bristol Area, and then Poconos--but for the sake of this post figure I'll clump it into 1)

If you had to pick up a STR, which area would it be and why?

If you had to pick a place for LTR which area would it be and why?