Skip to content
Tax, SDIRAs & Cost Segregation

User Stats

6
Posts
0
Votes
Reuven Kishon
0
Votes |
6
Posts

San Diego bank that opens accounts for Foreign LLC's?

Reuven Kishon
Posted Dec 2 2022, 10:58

Hi there,

I couldn't fit the full description in the title. I'm looking for San Diego banks that open accounts for Foreign LLC's without asking you to register said LLC in California as a Foreign LLC. I don't want to do that as it incurs more filings and fees.

Thanks!

User Stats

324
Posts
62
Votes
Frank Greg
  • Lender
  • rate.bid
62
Votes |
324
Posts
Frank Greg
  • Lender
  • rate.bid
Replied Dec 3 2022, 20:11
@Reuven Kishon:

Hi there,

I couldn't fit the full description in the title. I'm looking for San Diego banks that open accounts for Foreign LLC's without asking you to register said LLC in California as a Foreign LLC. I don't want to do that as it incurs more filings and fees.

Thanks!

With the exception of some credit unions, you should not have that much problem establishing a bank account for a foreign LLC at most major or reasonably sizable institutions.

User Stats

6
Posts
0
Votes
Reuven Kishon
0
Votes |
6
Posts
Reuven Kishon
Replied Dec 4 2022, 10:11
Quote from @Frank Greg:
@Reuven Kishon:

Hi there,

I couldn't fit the full description in the title. I'm looking for San Diego banks that open accounts for Foreign LLC's without asking you to register said LLC in California as a Foreign LLC. I don't want to do that as it incurs more filings and fees.

Thanks!

With the exception of some credit unions, you should not have that much problem establishing a bank account for a foreign LLC at most major or reasonably sizable institutions.


Thanks Frank, I'll give them a try. I tried Credit Unions and they all needed me to register the foreign LLC in california first.

Just to be sure, you are saying that non credit union banks won't ask for that registration?

BiggerPockets logo
BiggerPockets
|
Sponsored
Find an investor-friendly agent in your market TODAY Get matched with our network of trusted, local, investor friendly agents in under 2 minutes

User Stats

324
Posts
62
Votes
Frank Greg
  • Lender
  • rate.bid
62
Votes |
324
Posts
Frank Greg
  • Lender
  • rate.bid
Replied Dec 4 2022, 14:17
@Reuven Kishon:

Actually, there are quite a few credit unions around the country that do not have in-state LLC registration requirement either for membership or to establish a deposit account so unless you have a particular need to be in San Diego....

For non credit unions (regular banks), most typically can establish a deposit account for both domestic and foreign LLCs unless there is something in the banks charter that requires it to restrict its services to locals.

Most regional and national banks already operate in multiple states and have no issues with foreign LLCs but most of the non-regional or local banks (in terms of scope of footprint) often do 'discriminate' in lending to customers outside a certain area where it operates but usually might have not problem taking on the customer's deposit business.

User Stats

2,830
Posts
2,280
Votes
Caroline Gerardo
  • Lender
  • Laguna Niguel, CA
2,280
Votes |
2,830
Posts
Caroline Gerardo
  • Lender
  • Laguna Niguel, CA
Replied Dec 4 2022, 15:11

The root of your problem: The Patriot Act. ALL banks, credit unions and charters are required to get your clear, current identification, proof the entity you want to open is registered in the state where they operate, and can tell you to go elsewhere. They are required to do SARS reports if you move amounts of cash or have unusual activity. The state and the federal government want to see and tax any business enterprise. 

User Stats

6
Posts
0
Votes
Reuven Kishon
0
Votes |
6
Posts
Reuven Kishon
Replied Dec 4 2022, 21:04
Quote from @Frank Greg:
@Reuven Kishon:

Actually, there are quite a few credit unions around the country that do not have in-state LLC registration requirement either for membership or to establish a deposit account so unless you have a particular need to be in San Diego....

For non credit unions (regular banks), most typically can establish a deposit account for both domestic and foreign LLCs unless there is something in the banks charter that requires it to restrict its services to locals.

Most regional and national banks already operate in multiple states and have no issues with foreign LLCs but most of the non-regional or local banks (in terms of scope of footprint) often do 'discriminate' in lending to customers outside a certain area where it operates but usually might have not problem taking on the customer's deposit business.


 Yea I need it to be in San Diego because I want to open up a safety deposit box as well. I'll try a regional or national bank and see what they say.

User Stats

6
Posts
0
Votes
Reuven Kishon
0
Votes |
6
Posts
Reuven Kishon
Replied Dec 4 2022, 21:05
Quote from @Caroline Gerardo:

The root of your problem: The Patriot Act. ALL banks, credit unions and charters are required to get your clear, current identification, proof the entity you want to open is registered in the state where they operate, and can tell you to go elsewhere. They are required to do SARS reports if you move amounts of cash or have unusual activity. The state and the federal government want to see and tax any business enterprise. 


 OK then based on what you are saying I most likely won't have any luck.

User Stats

324
Posts
62
Votes
Frank Greg
  • Lender
  • rate.bid
62
Votes |
324
Posts
Frank Greg
  • Lender
  • rate.bid
Replied Dec 4 2022, 23:24
@Reuven Kishon:
@Caroline Gerardo:
 OK then based on what you are saying I most likely won't have any luck.

You have been misinformed here. No government agency have instructed any bank that the "Customer Identification Program" means the business must be incorporated in any specific state. That is false.  You are not identified by where you are incorporated.

Know your customer means just that -- to know who the customer is. The government issues to persons or entities a SSN, Tax Identification or EIN # which along with a drivers license or state issued identification, ANY bank or government agency can credibly identify who the customer is. However, like with anything else, some banks will often stretch, convolute, confuse and or distort what a customer identification program means or entails for all sorts of strange reasons that has nothing to do with identifying the customer.

There is specific documentation from the treasury that describes in detail what a bank must do at a minimum to identity a customer. Any bank can confirm the registration of an entity wherever incorporated in the US.

User Stats

324
Posts
62
Votes
Frank Greg
  • Lender
  • rate.bid
62
Votes |
324
Posts
Frank Greg
  • Lender
  • rate.bid
Replied Dec 4 2022, 23:55
@Reuven Kishon:

 Yea I need it to be in San Diego because I want to open up a safety deposit box as well. I'll try a regional or national bank and see what they say.

You should not have a problem with this. There are way too many regional and national banks in California. Worst case is a regional or national bank in California will require the business to operate in one of the states they do business in. If its a bank that only does business in California with limited footprint and resources, they may require you also operate in or be registered in California.

User Stats

2,830
Posts
2,280
Votes
Caroline Gerardo
  • Lender
  • Laguna Niguel, CA
2,280
Votes |
2,830
Posts
Caroline Gerardo
  • Lender
  • Laguna Niguel, CA
Replied Dec 5 2022, 08:40

@Frank Greg  please post your NMLS license as there is NO Frank Greg with a license registered. If you know the name of a bank who will give @Reuven Kishon an account in his foreign LLC located in San Diego please post the name of the branch and contact person. here are some of he rules https://bsaaml.ffiec.gov/docs/...                     

An ITIN is not a social security number. The US Treasury, banks, and other agencies cooperate even though they like to keep that quiet. Banks decide what level of risk they are willing to make. Doe the LLC paperwork you have has your name as sole owner of the LLC? How can a bank employee be an attorney or perform risk analysis, they will pass on the risk a it costs the bank

User Stats

6
Posts
0
Votes
Reuven Kishon
0
Votes |
6
Posts
Reuven Kishon
Replied Dec 5 2022, 09:34
Quote from @Caroline Gerardo:

@Frank Greg  please post your NMLS license as there is NO Frank Greg with a license registered. If you know the name of a bank who will give @Reuven Kishon an account in his foreign LLC located in San Diego please post the name of the branch and contact person. here are some of he rules https://bsaaml.ffiec.gov/docs/...                     

An ITIN is not a social security number. The US Treasury, banks, and other agencies cooperate even though they like to keep that quiet. Banks decide what level of risk they are willing to make. Doe the LLC paperwork you have has your name as sole owner of the LLC? How can a bank employee be an attorney or perform risk analysis, they will pass on the risk a it costs the bank

Not sure if you were asking me the question about my LLC ownership, but it's owned by Solera Bank (as an IRA custodian). I am the sole member of the LLC. It's part of the checkbook IRA structure.

User Stats

324
Posts
62
Votes
Frank Greg
  • Lender
  • rate.bid
62
Votes |
324
Posts
Frank Greg
  • Lender
  • rate.bid
Replied Dec 5 2022, 12:45
@Caroline Gerardo:

 First, I don't do personal loans and don't need an NMLS license which by the way has nothing to do with the discussion. Lets put it this way, not only can most banks establish an account for an out of state entity, they legally can establish an account for an individual or business located in and from a different country. Read the directives!

Know your customer is not a badge or authorization to play detective or law enforecement. Many banks go crazy with this. The IRS does not issue the same EIN or Tax identification number to unrelated persons/entities nor is the same SSN issued to different persons.

The fact simply is, most banks either don't quite comprehend what their duty is when it comes to customer identification or just decide to go crazy with it. I don't wish to promote any bank on here but know many (including in California) where you can establish a foreign LLC account (and do so completely remotely if you choose to) . This is only a problem if the customer is just naive.

Where in the documentation your posted, does it say a bank can only open an account for a domestic incorporated entity?

User Stats

2,830
Posts
2,280
Votes
Caroline Gerardo
  • Lender
  • Laguna Niguel, CA
2,280
Votes |
2,830
Posts
Caroline Gerardo
  • Lender
  • Laguna Niguel, CA
Replied Dec 5 2022, 13:17

He doesn't own the foreign LLC, his IRA does, and that is managed by another entity. I know of zero banks or credit union in San Diego. He wants a local bank to transact in person. An online "bank" might accept his ID but it won't match the IRA name. Difficult to cash a check or get cash, only can ACH or Zelle funds when he finds one. I know of two online banks that will do it but I would NOT recommend them, like recommending FTX today.

This type of LLC cannot get a conventional mortgage loan as the IRA entity is not a real person, maybe hard money will with a personal guarantee but that threatens the non taxable structure chosen for using IRA.