Refinance, Pay Down, or Buy, or Other.....

3 Replies

I have owned a house, not my primary residence for 12 years. 

Purchase Price = $108,250

Zillow Value - $130,000

Rate = 5.75%

Payment = $822/month

My disabled father has rented it from me for the last 7 years. He is on a fixed income, so he only pays $600 per month. Yes - I am subsidizing his house, which I am fine with and I can afford.

Chase is offering to refinance my mortgage, no cost to me, 4.5%, so my payment will be <$700/month.

Options :

1. Only refinance the balance of 75k and almost break even with rent.

2. Pay 25k on mortgage and refinance 50k. Have a small cash flow.

3. Take 25k, and purchase another property ( if I can find one ).

Thoughts on cash flow, taxes, etc... will be appreciated!

My thinking is this:

1. Pay 25k to reduce mortgage from $800 to $400 ( 20 years @ 4.5%). This is pure cash flow of $200/month, ( or $200 reduction + $200 I have been paying = $400 ).

2. Use 25k to buy another property (if I can find one ), fight with tenants, for the same cash flow.

3rd is good option so you can have another investment  from this equity. 

@Alan Hicks - What are you looking for? If you're looking for effortless cash flow, then paying down the mortgage makes sense. 

If you're looking for a high return on your investment, appreciation, and cash flow with a little bit more work then the rental property makes sense. 

Create Lasting Wealth Through Real Estate

Join the millions of people achieving financial freedom through the power of real estate investing

Start here