Skip to content
General Landlording & Rental Properties

User Stats

26
Posts
4
Votes
Shawn M.
  • Coral Springs, FL
4
Votes |
26
Posts

Renting Condo - Should I Use An Agent?

Shawn M.
  • Coral Springs, FL
Posted Sep 16 2013, 14:18

What has been your best source for locating a tenant for a unit you have for rent? Debating whether I should try to find on my own or use the service of an agent. I believe most agents charge what would amount to first month's rent for their service.

User Stats

111
Posts
16
Votes
Richard Vang
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Carmichael, CA
16
Votes |
111
Posts
Richard Vang
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Carmichael, CA
Replied Sep 17 2013, 13:00

use craigslist. It's free. Very good response.

User Stats

26
Posts
4
Votes
Shawn M.
  • Coral Springs, FL
4
Votes |
26
Posts
Shawn M.
  • Coral Springs, FL
Replied Sep 17 2013, 15:11

@Richard Vang Thank you!

BiggerPockets logo
BiggerPockets
|
Sponsored
Find an investor-friendly agent in your market TODAY Get matched with our network of trusted, local, investor friendly agents in under 2 minutes

User Stats

2,498
Posts
280
Votes
Bienes Raices
  • Orlando, FL
280
Votes |
2,498
Posts
Bienes Raices
  • Orlando, FL
Replied Sep 17 2013, 15:17

I would never trust an agent to do the proper screening.

User Stats

26
Posts
4
Votes
Shawn M.
  • Coral Springs, FL
4
Votes |
26
Posts
Shawn M.
  • Coral Springs, FL
Replied Sep 17 2013, 17:40

@Richard Vang Thank you!

@Bienes Raices I was only considering an agent to locate prospective tenants based on criteria I provided. I would also screen before accepting any applications.

User Stats

812
Posts
177
Votes
Joe Delia
  • Involved In Real Estate
  • Rochester Hills, MI
177
Votes |
812
Posts
Joe Delia
  • Involved In Real Estate
  • Rochester Hills, MI
Replied Sep 17 2013, 17:55

This is really a question of what your time is worth, and how competent you are in real estate law.

Saying you don't trust an agent to screen a client is crazy. If an agent specializes in rentals in your area, thats insane to say. Yes, i wouldn't trust a random agent off the street, but if you screen your agent, you should end up in good hands.

User Stats

27
Posts
4
Votes
Michael Hable
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Naperville, IL
4
Votes |
27
Posts
Michael Hable
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Naperville, IL
Replied Sep 17 2013, 18:50

I've used an agent and found it to be convenient. It can eliminate some of the hassle despite the fee.

Good Luck!

User Stats

2,498
Posts
280
Votes
Bienes Raices
  • Orlando, FL
280
Votes |
2,498
Posts
Bienes Raices
  • Orlando, FL
Replied Sep 18 2013, 16:52

@Joe delia

I certainly didn't mean you, but I've heard too many stories of agents just sticking any warm body in there to collect their fee. Letting the agent take the calls and show the place might be okay, but I would want total control over the screening process.

User Stats

812
Posts
177
Votes
Joe Delia
  • Involved In Real Estate
  • Rochester Hills, MI
177
Votes |
812
Posts
Joe Delia
  • Involved In Real Estate
  • Rochester Hills, MI
Replied Sep 18 2013, 18:59
Originally posted by Bienes Raices:
@Joe delia

I certainly didn't mean you, but I've heard too many stories of agents just sticking any warm body in there to collect their fee. Letting the agent take the calls and show the place might be okay, but I would want total control over the screening process.

I know. The problem with hearing "agents" is that is a very broad stroke. That's like saying "I've heard investors are unethical".

Find someone who specializes in rentals, not someone doing it for the first time.

User Stats

798
Posts
213
Votes
Jon K.
213
Votes |
798
Posts
Replied Sep 18 2013, 22:54
Originally posted by Bienes Raices:
I would never trust an agent to do the proper screening.

I would.

People who search for high-end rentals through realtors often have better qualifications than some fly-by-night reply off craigslist.

I obviously screen the person myself, not just let someone else approve tenants.

Account Closed
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Raleigh, NC
1
Votes |
27
Posts
Account Closed
  • Real Estate Investor
  • Raleigh, NC
Replied Sep 19 2013, 01:04

I prefer to screen tenants myself, as my peace of mind makes up for the work/time required. I've had my unit managed by a PM before who took care of locating and screening tenants and got screwed over (horrible tenants who trashed the unit and the PM didn't get a security deposit). I've found that both me and the tenants are happier with this situation -- I feel better knowing I vetted them personally, and they are happier because I obviously am more flexible and understanding as a landlord since I am more comfortable with them as my tenants.

However, not to say all RE agents will do a poor job (I'm an RE agent myself). But instead of choosing blindly, I would ask around and get a feel for who in the area has a good reputation - usually good reputations are backed up by good people (cause people talk). I'd certainly do this myself were I in the same position, rather than choosing a realtor blindly.

User Stats

2,195
Posts
1,021
Votes
Aly W.
  • Investor
  • Middletown, NJ
1,021
Votes |
2,195
Posts
Aly W.
  • Investor
  • Middletown, NJ
Replied Sep 19 2013, 06:20

I've always used craigslist for our rental properties. I do the screening myself, and my contractor will show the units (some are in another state, some are over an hour away).

Our most recent tenant was being relocated to FL and had been using a realtor to find a condo. The tenant and her husband saw my craigslist ad, loved the condo, it was slightly less rent than what their realtor was showing them, and it was a much nicer unit. They already had credit reports run by the realtor, which they provided. If you're diligent, you can find good tenants yourself.

Unless I'm mistaken, realtors will only show units that are listed for rent on the MLS, so there is a lot of inventory they don't know about.

User Stats

66
Posts
8
Votes
Chris M.
  • Investor
  • Miramar, FL
8
Votes |
66
Posts
Chris M.
  • Investor
  • Miramar, FL
Replied Sep 19 2013, 19:20

I tried going the craigs route early on in the rental game, showed the unit a lot when it was freshly renovated with no real luck. It was also a pain to drive 30-45 mins in traffic to show the place as well.

I called an agent that specialized in rentals and she has kept that place and all my others rented. I use her till this day and she's been invaluable with her advice and references. She's moved up to high end condo sales but still works with me on my rentals and target properties even though I'm not in her target area anymore. She does background checks and advises me based on anything that would seem 'off' from dealing with potential tenants. I meet the new tenants when we are doing the walkthrough.

If you can find a good realtor, then hold on to them and use their services/expertise to grow your business.

User Stats

289
Posts
117
Votes
Christopher Leon
  • Realtor
  • Schaumburg, IL
117
Votes |
289
Posts
Christopher Leon
  • Realtor
  • Schaumburg, IL
Replied Sep 19 2013, 19:49

as a agent myself that focuses on rentals and working specifically with landlords I think you most definitely want to use an agent, ESPECIALLY, if your not familiar with fair housing and such things. Now, could you do it yourself? Absolutely, you can save the months rent and feel proud; but, like Joe Delia said above, what is your time worth? How quickly can you get it rented? If you work with a broker that specializes In rentals, they may already have a prospective tenant lined up, it's just a mater of having them fill out the app and pay the app fee. When I help landlords rent units, I screen them accordingly so as to not waste the prospect/suspects time. If I feel they won't get approved, I tell them. Now, if they screen properly them I schedule an appointment get the app and turn it in. I run credit and then submit the prospect to you but YOU make the ultimate decision. I help my clients understand the strengths and weaknesses of the prospective tenant. You should never let someone else make the decision for you if your hands on in your business, just use your agent like a tool to help you make an informed decision. It is a preference though. Good luck.