Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here

Join Over 3 Million Real Estate Investors

Create a free BiggerPockets account to comment, participate, and connect with over 3 million real estate investors.
Use your real name
By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.
The community here is like my own little personal real estate army that I can depend upon to help me through ANY problems I come across.
Innovative Strategies
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

User Stats

15
Posts
3
Votes
Dmitry Zbarsky
Pro Member
  • Staten Island, NY
3
Votes |
15
Posts

Should I lease with buy option or sell SubTo

Dmitry Zbarsky
Pro Member
  • Staten Island, NY
Posted
Hi BP Community,

Been watching BP podcasts for a while and learned a whole lot. Joined the community a few months ago and today signed up for one of the bootcamps and got the Pro membership - whoohoo! :)

I have a situation that I hope I can get some advice on. I have a 2b/2b condo I purchased in Feb 0f 2022 in NE Philly for $218K. I'm in the process to sign a a lease with a new tenant and was asked about lease with option to buy. While thinking through that I thought why not do a hybrid of subto and owner finance (my equity is about $70K). I liked the idea of selling as I'm not crazy having to deal with HOA. I initially went for a condo as a safer bet, being this was my first investment, but I realized that comes with strings attached so to say.

I'm about half way through Pace Morby's book Wealth without Cash and really like the creative finance approach, but still totally lost about how to approach it as I haven't done any of that.

Thanks in advance for any help!

Dmitry
  • Dmitry Zbarsky
  • User Stats

    9
    Posts
    6
    Votes
    John Garcia
    • Investor
    • Florida
    6
    Votes |
    9
    Posts
    John Garcia
    • Investor
    • Florida
    Replied

    Hi Dmitry, 

    It is all based on what your exit strategy is on this deal. If doing a lease option, keep in mind you need to charge a premium at the beginning of the term AND the monthly payment needs to be a little higher than the average. The lease option is a maybe disposition strategy vs doing a hybrid ( which IS a disposition strategy unless buyer defaults on payments) because you don't know if the tenant will force the option and he/she is not obligated to do so. I think is better to do the lease option rather than the hybrid route because the benefit in the hybrid scenario is more to the buyer than to you. If the tenant decides to do the buy option lets say in year 2 or 3, that is time that you will have paid down the mortgage and your delta is higher. 

    Hope this helps and congrats on joining! 

    John. 

    User Stats

    15
    Posts
    3
    Votes
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    3
    Votes |
    15
    Posts
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    Replied
    Quote from @John Garcia:

    Hi Dmitry, 

    It is all based on what your exit strategy is on this deal. If doing a lease option, keep in mind you need to charge a premium at the beginning of the term AND the monthly payment needs to be a little higher than the average. The lease option is a maybe disposition strategy vs doing a hybrid ( which IS a disposition strategy unless buyer defaults on payments) because you don't know if the tenant will force the option and he/she is not obligated to do so. I think is better to do the lease option rather than the hybrid route because the benefit in the hybrid scenario is more to the buyer than to you. If the tenant decides to do the buy option lets say in year 2 or 3, that is time that you will have paid down the mortgage and your delta is higher. 

    Hope this helps and congrats on joining! 

    John. 

    Hi John, thank you very much for your input. Yes, I understand that the buy option will have extra payment at the beginning and a higher monthly payments and also being an option, not guaranteed a sale. It seemed that the tenants might have an issue with extra payments at the beginning, which is why I thought if I do a subto, I can forgo cash payment and just structure with mortgage payments and additional monthly payments for my equity.

    If I decide on one or the other, are there any leases w/buy option here I can use? Who would I need to structure my subto, would it be a lawyer or escrow/title company?
  • Dmitry Zbarsky
  • BiggerPockets logo
    PassivePockets is here!
    |
    BiggerPockets
    Find sponsors, evaluate deals, and learn how to invest with confidence.

    User Stats

    9,861
    Posts
    5,542
    Votes
    Eliott Elias#4 BRRRR - Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat Contributor
    • Investor
    • Austin, TX
    5,542
    Votes |
    9,861
    Posts
    Eliott Elias#4 BRRRR - Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat Contributor
    • Investor
    • Austin, TX
    Replied

    Subject to is typically not the best option for sellers, unless they can not keep up with their payments. If your loan is desirable, this is a good option for a buyer.

    User Stats

    15
    Posts
    3
    Votes
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    3
    Votes |
    15
    Posts
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    Replied
    Thank you Eliott!
  • Dmitry Zbarsky
  • User Stats

    613
    Posts
    426
    Votes
    Eric Greenberg
    • Investor
    • Philadelphia, PA
    426
    Votes |
    613
    Posts
    Eric Greenberg
    • Investor
    • Philadelphia, PA
    Replied

    What is the plus side for you other than the potential of not paying 6% to a buyer/seller agent when you sell? 

    To me it makes sense if you feel like the market is going to be going down (Im not sure where you are in NE Philly but id bet that isnt the case).  You are also betting that inflation isnt going to continue which will again erode away your sell price now vs X years from now. 

    User Stats

    604
    Posts
    406
    Votes
    Randy Rodenhouse
    Pro Member
    • Investor
    • Charleston, SC
    406
    Votes |
    604
    Posts
    Randy Rodenhouse
    Pro Member
    • Investor
    • Charleston, SC
    Replied

    @Dmitry Zbarsky. If you own a property and you want to sell it, then the 3 options are to sell outright, sell with owner financing (or land contract) or sell with lease option. It depends on the state you're selling the property in. So for example, if you're selling a property in a long foreclosure state, it might be better to do a lease option and if you're selling your property in a deed of trust state, with a fast foreclosure process then I would sell with owner financing. With the seller financing you no longer have to pay the taxes, insurance HOA, ETC however, you do not have any tax write offs like you do with the lease option. Also your relinquishing title, so you have less control when selling with owner finance, so make sure you get a good size down payment.

  • Randy Rodenhouse
  • User Stats

    15
    Posts
    3
    Votes
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    3
    Votes |
    15
    Posts
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    Replied
    Quote from @Eric Greenberg:

    What is the plus side for you other than the potential of not paying 6% to a buyer/seller agent when you sell? 

    To me it makes sense if you feel like the market is going to be going down (Im not sure where you are in NE Philly but id bet that isnt the case).  You are also betting that inflation isnt going to continue which will again erode away your sell price now vs X years from now. 


    Hi Eric, you asking why sell w/seller finance vs conventional sale via RE?

    The only reason to sell this condo was to re-invest the money in a different type of property. No, I don't think the market will do down, at least not much and not for long and I don't see inflation recovering very soon either.
  • Dmitry Zbarsky
  • User Stats

    15
    Posts
    3
    Votes
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    3
    Votes |
    15
    Posts
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    Replied
    Quote from @Randy Rodenhouse:

    @Dmitry Zbarsky. If you own a property and you want to sell it, then the 3 options are to sell outright, sell with owner financing (or land contract) or sell with lease option. It depends on the state you're selling the property in. So for example, if you're selling a property in a long foreclosure state, it might be better to do a lease option and if you're selling your property in a deed of trust state, with a fast foreclosure process then I would sell with owner financing. With the seller financing you no longer have to pay the taxes, insurance HOA, ETC however, you do not have any tax write offs like you do with the lease option. Also your relinquishing title, so you have less control when selling with owner finance, so make sure you get a good size down payment.


    Hi Randy, thanks for your reply. To be honest I'm still rereading your reply to understand :) I'm a fairly new in the RE investing. I'll send you a DM if you don't mind to clarify a few things. Thanks!
  • Dmitry Zbarsky
  • User Stats

    613
    Posts
    426
    Votes
    Eric Greenberg
    • Investor
    • Philadelphia, PA
    426
    Votes |
    613
    Posts
    Eric Greenberg
    • Investor
    • Philadelphia, PA
    Replied
    Quote from @Dmitry Zbarsky:

    The only reason to sell this condo was to re-invest the money in a different type of property. No, I don't think the market will do down, at least not much and not for long and I don't see inflation recovering very soon either.

     Yes, why not just sell on the open market? 

    User Stats

    15
    Posts
    3
    Votes
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    3
    Votes |
    15
    Posts
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    Replied

    I only owned it for a bit longer than a year so not much equity built up. Thinking this whole thing through, makes me re-thing this situation and probably just rent it out.

    Thank you all for your inputs!

  • Dmitry Zbarsky
  • User Stats

    1,195
    Posts
    799
    Votes
    Alan Asriants
    Agent
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Philadelphia, PA
    799
    Votes |
    1,195
    Posts
    Alan Asriants
    Agent
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Philadelphia, PA
    Replied
    Quote from @Eric Greenberg:
    Quote from @Dmitry Zbarsky:

    The only reason to sell this condo was to re-invest the money in a different type of property. No, I don't think the market will do down, at least not much and not for long and I don't see inflation recovering very soon either.

     Yes, why not just sell on the open market? 


     I agree i think you will get the most on the open market. NE philly market is very hot right now and a good condo sells fast. Im not crazy about condos either, but Im sure you locked in a great rate, maybe selling is not the best option

    • Real Estate Agent New Jersey (#2323863) and Pennsylvania (#RS3399189)

    • 267-767-0111
    • [email protected]
    Alan Asriants - New Century Real Estate  Logo

    User Stats

    15
    Posts
    3
    Votes
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    3
    Votes |
    15
    Posts
    Dmitry Zbarsky
    Pro Member
    • Staten Island, NY
    Replied
    Alan, you are right. I do have a good rate locked on this one and after reading all the questions and suggestions above, I realized that I'll keep it for time being. I explained to prospective tenants that I can only do a straight lease for now. They understood and I'm hoping to sign it by end of this week.

    Thanks again to everyone for your inputs!
  • Dmitry Zbarsky
  • BiggerPockets logo
    BiggerPockets
    |
    Sponsored
    Find an investor-friendly agent in your market TODAY Get matched with our network of trusted, local, investor friendly agents in under 2 minutes