Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here

Join Over 3 Million Real Estate Investors

Create a free BiggerPockets account to comment, participate, and connect with over 3 million real estate investors.
Use your real name
By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.
The community here is like my own little personal real estate army that I can depend upon to help me through ANY problems I come across.
Ask About A Real Estate Company
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

User Stats

2
Posts
4
Votes
Austin B.
4
Votes |
2
Posts

Thoughts About New Western?

Austin B.
Posted

Has anyone purchased a property from New Western? If so, how was the experience? Did you feel like their comps were relatively accurate?

User Stats

4,870
Posts
4,235
Votes
Bruce Lynn#2 Real Estate Agent Contributor
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Coppell, TX
4,235
Votes |
4,870
Posts
Bruce Lynn#2 Real Estate Agent Contributor
  • Real Estate Broker
  • Coppell, TX
Replied

Run your own comps when buying from any wholesaler and know your rehab costs. Don't depend on others to do it for you. It is pretty typical for many wholesalers to overstate ARV and underestimate rehab costs. Maybe this is intentional and maybe it isn't, maybe what they would do is different than what you would do or envision.

Also be aware that some deals are just recycled off MLS, so potentially you could have bought the same property for less, with less risk off MLS. Don't be fooled by the term "wholesale" deal. Just a marketing term. Some people are repeat buyers, and some would never buy again. You have plenty of options in DFW.

User Stats

58
Posts
79
Votes
Terra Padgett
Professional Services
  • Investor
  • Houston, Tx
79
Votes |
58
Posts
Terra Padgett
Professional Services
  • Investor
  • Houston, Tx
Replied

I've purchased one property with them before. Definitely inflated ARVs and I have no clue where they get their repair costs from. My estimates were much higher. This property in particular had some additional unforeseen costs (main water line damage, sewer line damage, etc.) that certainly caused us to go way over budget. Selling after the rehab was not an option. We were able to refi and pay private lender back, but no cash was able to be pulled out. So we are still holding the property and renting out for a few years and we'll see when the right time to exit will be. I'd say they have a consistent deal flow for you to look at, but certainly don't take the data they provide as your basis for buying/rehabbing/selling. Do your research independently to see if the deal pencils. Go walk the property yourself. 

BiggerPockets logo
BiggerPockets
|
Sponsored
Find an investor-friendly agent in your market TODAY Get matched with our network of trusted, local, investor friendly agents in under 2 minutes

User Stats

41,789
Posts
61,555
Votes
Jay Hinrichs
Professional Services
Pro Member
#4 All Forums Contributor
  • Lender
  • Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV
61,555
Votes |
41,789
Posts
Jay Hinrichs
Professional Services
Pro Member
#4 All Forums Contributor
  • Lender
  • Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV
Replied
Quote from @Bruce Lynn:

Run your own comps when buying from any wholesaler and know your rehab costs. Don't depend on others to do it for you. It is pretty typical for many wholesalers to overstate ARV and underestimate rehab costs. Maybe this is intentional and maybe it isn't, maybe what they would do is different than what you would do or envision.

Also be aware that some deals are just recycled off MLS, so potentially you could have bought the same property for less, with less risk off MLS. Don't be fooled by the term "wholesale" deal. Just a marketing term. Some people are repeat buyers, and some would never buy again. You have plenty of options in DFW.


Buyer beware these guys  I would personally never fund a deal that comes from them and for sure buy one.. Hard sell preying on newbie investors.

User Stats

41,789
Posts
61,555
Votes
Jay Hinrichs
Professional Services
Pro Member
#4 All Forums Contributor
  • Lender
  • Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV
61,555
Votes |
41,789
Posts
Jay Hinrichs
Professional Services
Pro Member
#4 All Forums Contributor
  • Lender
  • Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV
Replied
Quote from @Terra Padgett:

I've purchased one property with them before. Definitely inflated ARVs and I have no clue where they get their repair costs from. My estimates were much higher. This property in particular had some additional unforeseen costs (main water line damage, sewer line damage, etc.) that certainly caused us to go way over budget. Selling after the rehab was not an option. We were able to refi and pay private lender back, but no cash was able to be pulled out. So we are still holding the property and renting out for a few years and we'll see when the right time to exit will be. I'd say they have a consistent deal flow for you to look at, but certainly don't take the data they provide as your basis for buying/rehabbing/selling. Do your research independently to see if the deal pencils. Go walk the property yourself. 


Yup just a lead source  nothing more.. hard sell  FOMO high pressure tactics

User Stats

771
Posts
1,194
Votes
Stuart Udis
Pro Member
#2 Buying & Selling Real Estate Contributor
  • Attorney
  • Philadelphia
1,194
Votes |
771
Posts
Stuart Udis
Pro Member
#2 Buying & Selling Real Estate Contributor
  • Attorney
  • Philadelphia
Replied

Agree with what others have shared. They put a lot of money behind their marketing and have large buyer lists consisting of the most unsophisticated buyers imaginable which should give you immediate pause because you have to beat out hundreds of suckers to land a deal. One of my favorite building tour stories involved a New Western assignment. It was a stalled renovation. The seller dug out the basement to increase the ceiling height which required  underpinning. The 3 ft  chalk markers were still visible  on the walls and one of the prospective buyers asked what the chalk marks signified. The New Western assignment agent said it was art work left behind by the last owners children. There were at least 6 or 7 prospective buyers in the basement at the time and not one corrected him. I believe that paints the picture of who you are competing against and who you are dealing with. 

  • Stuart Udis
  • [email protected]
  • User Stats

    112
    Posts
    58
    Votes
    David C.
    • Lender
    • Los Angeles, CA
    58
    Votes |
    112
    Posts
    David C.
    • Lender
    • Los Angeles, CA
    Replied

    I lent money to a flipper that bought from them.  The deal worked out okay but the agent my borrower worked with wouldn't release the keys, even after escrow closed, until his commission hit his bank account, that among other small issues.  Low class outfit ...

    User Stats

    42
    Posts
    14
    Votes
    Replied

    I purchased a property from them in 2019 before the market went crazy.  In my area, they appear to have more realistic prices than other wholesalers I follow.  I had no issues with my experience with them.

    User Stats

    1,157
    Posts
    627
    Votes
    Nate Marshall
    • Financial Advisor
    • Evergreen, CO
    627
    Votes |
    1,157
    Posts
    Nate Marshall
    • Financial Advisor
    • Evergreen, CO
    Replied

    They are the Hamas of the real estate industry IMO. Overpriced. They are pure greed!!! They are Madoff. They are SBF. Don't do business with them. 

    User Stats

    41,789
    Posts
    61,555
    Votes
    Jay Hinrichs
    Professional Services
    Pro Member
    #4 All Forums Contributor
    • Lender
    • Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV
    61,555
    Votes |
    41,789
    Posts
    Jay Hinrichs
    Professional Services
    Pro Member
    #4 All Forums Contributor
    • Lender
    • Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV
    Replied
    Quote from @David C.:

    I lent money to a flipper that bought from them.  The deal worked out okay but the agent my borrower worked with wouldn't release the keys, even after escrow closed, until his commission hit his bank account, that among other small issues.  Low class outfit ...


    one of my borrower/ clients went into escrow with them last week and  put up the non refundable money getting ready to close and well  the title needs to be probated.. so these guys dont run title until they have your deposit.. will see if and how easy they give my client back his money since it did not close on the closing date and no extension was given or signed..

    User Stats

    1,157
    Posts
    627
    Votes
    Nate Marshall
    • Financial Advisor
    • Evergreen, CO
    627
    Votes |
    1,157
    Posts
    Nate Marshall
    • Financial Advisor
    • Evergreen, CO
    Replied
    Quote from @Jay Hinrichs:
    Quote from @David C.:

    I lent money to a flipper that bought from them.  The deal worked out okay but the agent my borrower worked with wouldn't release the keys, even after escrow closed, until his commission hit his bank account, that among other small issues.  Low class outfit ...


    one of my borrower/ clients went into escrow with them last week and  put up the non refundable money getting ready to close and well  the title needs to be probated.. so these guys dont run title until they have your deposit.. will see if and how easy they give my client back his money since it did not close on the closing date and no extension was given or signed..

     That is what we call FRAUD! 

    User Stats

    41,789
    Posts
    61,555
    Votes
    Jay Hinrichs
    Professional Services
    Pro Member
    #4 All Forums Contributor
    • Lender
    • Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV
    61,555
    Votes |
    41,789
    Posts
    Jay Hinrichs
    Professional Services
    Pro Member
    #4 All Forums Contributor
    • Lender
    • Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV
    Replied
    Quote from @Nate Marshall:
    Quote from @Jay Hinrichs:
    Quote from @David C.:

    I lent money to a flipper that bought from them.  The deal worked out okay but the agent my borrower worked with wouldn't release the keys, even after escrow closed, until his commission hit his bank account, that among other small issues.  Low class outfit ...


    one of my borrower/ clients went into escrow with them last week and  put up the non refundable money getting ready to close and well  the title needs to be probated.. so these guys dont run title until they have your deposit.. will see if and how easy they give my client back his money since it did not close on the closing date and no extension was given or signed..

     That is what we call FRAUD! 


    follow up on my transaction..  to be fair and balance like Fox news.. my client negotiated to leave 1k with them and extend the close until probate is done and get refunded 6500.00 so assuming they actually send him a check .. I did want folks to know. that but I can tell you johnny wholesaler that might have got your deposit. very good chance something like this they would ghost yuo and you would never get it back.. they already spent it and dont have it to give back.

    User Stats

    1,157
    Posts
    627
    Votes
    Nate Marshall
    • Financial Advisor
    • Evergreen, CO
    627
    Votes |
    1,157
    Posts
    Nate Marshall
    • Financial Advisor
    • Evergreen, CO
    Replied
    Quote from @Jay Hinrichs:
    Quote from @Nate Marshall:
    Quote from @Jay Hinrichs:
    Quote from @David C.:

    I lent money to a flipper that bought from them.  The deal worked out okay but the agent my borrower worked with wouldn't release the keys, even after escrow closed, until his commission hit his bank account, that among other small issues.  Low class outfit ...


    one of my borrower/ clients went into escrow with them last week and  put up the non refundable money getting ready to close and well  the title needs to be probated.. so these guys dont run title until they have your deposit.. will see if and how easy they give my client back his money since it did not close on the closing date and no extension was given or signed..

     That is what we call FRAUD! 


    follow up on my transaction..  to be fair and balance like Fox news.. my client negotiated to leave 1k with them and extend the close until probate is done and get refunded 6500.00 so assuming they actually send him a check .. I did want folks to know. that but I can tell you johnny wholesaler that might have got your deposit. very good chance something like this they would ghost yuo and you would never get it back.. they already spent it and dont have it to give back.

     People still send money direct to people and not to escrow or title to hold. That is a huge problem. Then we have Gators. New Western and Gators are kind of like Hamas and Hezbollah getting together. A lot of destruction!!! 

    BiggerPockets logo
    PassivePockets is here!
    |
    BiggerPockets
    Find sponsors, evaluate deals, and learn how to invest with confidence.

    User Stats

    53
    Posts
    40
    Votes
    Kristin Flores-Brockman
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Fort Worth, TX
    40
    Votes |
    53
    Posts
    Kristin Flores-Brockman
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Fort Worth, TX
    Replied
    Quote from @Austin B.:

    Has anyone purchased a property from New Western? If so, how was the experience? Did you feel like their comps were relatively accurate?


     So many great responses here! Hopefully you got your question answered! :) 

    There are more reputable people and companies to work with... Personally, I stay away from them!

    User Stats

    1,157
    Posts
    627
    Votes
    Nate Marshall
    • Financial Advisor
    • Evergreen, CO
    627
    Votes |
    1,157
    Posts
    Nate Marshall
    • Financial Advisor
    • Evergreen, CO
    Replied
    Quote from @Kristin Flores-Brockman:
    Quote from @Austin B.:

    Has anyone purchased a property from New Western? If so, how was the experience? Did you feel like their comps were relatively accurate?


     So many great responses here! Hopefully you got your question answered! :) 

    There are more reputable people and companies to work with... Personally, I stay away from them!


     Good for you. More people should. I wish they did. I hear from so many taken advantage of by New Western. 

    User Stats

    100
    Posts
    46
    Votes
    Diego A.
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Flower Mound, TX
    46
    Votes |
    100
    Posts
    Diego A.
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Flower Mound, TX
    Replied
    Quote from @Bruce Lynn:

    Run your own comps when buying from any wholesaler and know your rehab costs. Don't depend on others to do it for you. It is pretty typical for many wholesalers to overstate ARV and underestimate rehab costs. Maybe this is intentional and maybe it isn't, maybe what they would do is different than what you would do or envision.

    Also be aware that some deals are just recycled off MLS, so potentially you could have bought the same property for less, with less risk off MLS. Don't be fooled by the term "wholesale" deal. Just a marketing term. Some people are repeat buyers, and some would never buy again. You have plenty of options in DFW.

    This week along I have seen 4 MLS recycling lists from them at higher price than if you get it if you went with a realtor. Running my numbers it gave me a much lower number but I still reached out and I was told that my number can't be worked out.
    My story continues, I am currently working in a flip that I got for another wholesaler, but first that same deal was with a New Western agent. I offered to NW the same price that I later got the house from, in which the second wholesaler got a great deal and it was even another agent involved in the transaction.

    Saying this, the agents that I am talking in NW have knowledge and they are open to communicate openly.

    User Stats

    5,714
    Posts
    6,524
    Votes
    Jonathan Greene
    Professional Services
    Pro Member
    #3 All Forums Contributor
    • Real Estate Consultant
    • Mendham, NJ
    6,524
    Votes |
    5,714
    Posts
    Jonathan Greene
    Professional Services
    Pro Member
    #3 All Forums Contributor
    • Real Estate Consultant
    • Mendham, NJ
    Replied

    In Florida, for example, they buy a majority from the MLS, which makes no sense at all for an investor. Why would an investor buy something from them that they could have bought for less on the MLS direct? Here is my conversation with them about it:

    Me: Yeah but why would anyone buy something from you that was on the MLS and they could have bought direct?

    Them: We’re asking under what it was listed for, and this is a marketplace. We found the deal on market and felt the numbers worked for our investors. Why no one scooped it up before we did - I couldn’t tell you.

    People purchase our deals that were on market often. A deal is a deal. A majority of our deals are off market, but we will pick up an on market deal if the numbers work. 

    Me: No investor who knows anything would ever buy a deal that you bought off the MLS. That is ludicrous.

    Them: Why would we continue to source deals from the MLS if no one was buying them? I can provide you with a list of properties I have sold that were on market.

    If you are not interested in these deals, that is okay. I have plenty of other deals that are off market.

    User Stats

    1,157
    Posts
    627
    Votes
    Nate Marshall
    • Financial Advisor
    • Evergreen, CO
    627
    Votes |
    1,157
    Posts
    Nate Marshall
    • Financial Advisor
    • Evergreen, CO
    Replied
    Quote from @Jonathan Greene:

    In Florida, for example, they buy a majority from the MLS, which makes no sense at all for an investor. Why would an investor buy something from them that they could have bought for less on the MLS direct? Here is my conversation with them about it:

    Me: Yeah but why would anyone buy something from you that was on the MLS and they could have bought direct?

    Them: We’re asking under what it was listed for, and this is a marketplace. We found the deal on market and felt the numbers worked for our investors. Why no one scooped it up before we did - I couldn’t tell you.

    People purchase our deals that were on market often. A deal is a deal. A majority of our deals are off market, but we will pick up an on market deal if the numbers work. 

    Me: No investor who knows anything would ever buy a deal that you bought off the MLS. That is ludicrous.

    Them: Why would we continue to source deals from the MLS if no one was buying them? I can provide you with a list of properties I have sold that were on market.

    If you are not interested in these deals, that is okay. I have plenty of other deals that are off market.


     That statement about suckers being born everyday definitely applies to real estate. 

    User Stats

    1,440
    Posts
    907
    Votes
    Jay Hurst
    Lender
    • Lender
    • Dallas, TX
    907
    Votes |
    1,440
    Posts
    Jay Hurst
    Lender
    • Lender
    • Dallas, TX
    Replied
    Quote from @Jay Hinrichs:
    Quote from @Bruce Lynn:

    Run your own comps when buying from any wholesaler and know your rehab costs. Don't depend on others to do it for you. It is pretty typical for many wholesalers to overstate ARV and underestimate rehab costs. Maybe this is intentional and maybe it isn't, maybe what they would do is different than what you would do or envision.

    Also be aware that some deals are just recycled off MLS, so potentially you could have bought the same property for less, with less risk off MLS. Don't be fooled by the term "wholesale" deal. Just a marketing term. Some people are repeat buyers, and some would never buy again. You have plenty of options in DFW.


    Buyer beware these guys  I would personally never fund a deal that comes from them and for sure buy one.. Hard sell preying on newbie investors.

     100%!  First thing I ask my borrowers that come with a wholesaled property: is this a new western deal? 

    • Lender Alabama (#69841), Virginia (#MLO-35815VA), Texas (#323441), Pennsylvania (#64778), Oregon (#323441), Louisiana (#323411), Iowa (#31166), Georgia (#55988), Florida (#LO40080), and Colorado (#100506224)