Skip to content
Insurance

User Stats

4
Posts
1
Votes
Tyler Smith
1
Votes |
4
Posts

Considering insurance switch (NREIG to CinFin)

Tyler Smith
Posted Mar 1 2023, 09:55

Hi All, 

We have a small/growing portfolio (10ish units, some flips) and I recently had to take over insurance responsibility.

We had started coverage with NREIG on a couple properties - reading a lot of mixed reviews on BP and elsewhere about those guys. Contacted a local agent who recommended Cincinnati Financial for coverage. Looks like rates will be a bit higher vs. NREIG but have heard good things about the company in general. 

Know insurance recommendations are tough (everyone has a horror story about everyone) but wondering if anyone has any advice in this area before I continue to expand with NREIG. 

Thanks! 

User Stats

206
Posts
98
Votes
Kevin Hoag
Pro Member
  • Insurance Agent
  • Cleveland, OH
98
Votes |
206
Posts
Kevin Hoag
Pro Member
  • Insurance Agent
  • Cleveland, OH
Replied Mar 1 2023, 10:20

@Tyler Smith if you are looking to quote out your business there are many carriers that can offer you an insurance quote for all of your properties on 1 policy. In Cleveland there are a lot of carrier options. The trick is to find a carrier that does not have any age of home restrictions. Often times a carrier will not offer full replacement cost for a home that is older than 80 or 100 years. To save yourself time and energy I suggest working with a local agent who can quote your business with multiple carriers to put you in the best insurance position. 

  • Insurance Agent Florida (#W926465), California (#4254212), Arizona (#17305721), Alabama (#3000533059), Arkansas (#17305721), Indiana (#3433967), Kansas (#17305721), Louisiana (#832520), Michigan (#17305721), Missouri (#8478592), Ohio (#1090522), Pennsylvania (#899635), Tennessee (#2437182), Virginia (#1127377), and West Virginia (#17305721)

  • 216-505-4677
  • https://agents.farmers.com/oh/parma/kevin-hoag
  • [email protected]

User Stats

2,476
Posts
1,409
Votes
Jason Bott
Pro Member
#2 Insurance Contributor
  • Insurance Agent
  • Nationwide
1,409
Votes |
2,476
Posts
Jason Bott
Pro Member
#2 Insurance Contributor
  • Insurance Agent
  • Nationwide
Replied Mar 1 2023, 17:58

@Tyler Smith we work with both companies.

 NREIG is set up better to handle the flips while CinFin will may have a better product on the buy and holds.

Your main difference is in the claims service.  CinFin claims people are CinFin employees.  NREIG (and most national programs) hire independent claims adjusters.  This is not to say your claims will get paid any differently, but the communication may be better with CinFin.

BiggerPockets logo
BiggerPockets
|
Sponsored
Find an investor-friendly agent in your market TODAY Get matched with our network of trusted, local, investor friendly agents in under 2 minutes