All
Members
Companies
Blog
Forums
Podcast
Webinars
    User Log in  /  Sign up
  • Start here
  • Education
    Forums

    Learn from and contribute to 658K+ real estate discussions

    BiggerPockets Podcast

    Listen to weekly interviews with investors & entrepreneurs

    BiggerPockets Blog

    Delve into 8,800+ articles by experienced investors

    Member Blogs

    Read original articles by BiggerPockets members

    Guides

    Master the ins and outs of fundamental real estate topics

    The Money Show

    Listen to weekly interviews that will help get your financial house in order

    Webinars

    Sign up for this week's free webinars hosted by experienced investors or view previously-held webinar recordings in the Archives

    Videos

    Browse our library of real estate related video content

    Free Course

    Experience The Financial Independence Blueprint video series - a free four-part video series

    Topics
    Property Management Property Types Finance Strategy Finding Deals Business Operations
  • Network
    Members

    Search over 1,270,000 members across BiggerPockets

    Companies

    Explore over 31,000 real estate-related companies

    Real Estate Agents

    Find an investor-friendly agent near you

    Hard Money Lenders

    Pinpoint lenders near you with our nationwide database

    Events

    Find upcoming real estate events and meetups near you

    Jobs

    Browse real estate job opportunities in your area

  • Tools

    Calculators

    • Fix and Flip
    • Rental Property
    • BRRRR
    • Rehab Estimator
    • Wholesaling
    • Mortgage Payment
    • 70% Rule
    • Airbnb Calculator

    Services

    Find a Contractor Get a Mortgage Loan Tenant Screening External Link

    Additional Tools

    FilePlace

    Download presentations, spreadsheets, contracts & more

    REI Resources

    Dig into thousands of curated real estate tools & resources

    Calculators
  • Marketplace
    Properties For Sale

    Buy and sell real estate deals or seek out partners, financing, etc.

    Find Foreclosures External Link

    Search this comprehensive database of nationwide foreclosures

    Ads, Jobs, and Other

    Advertise your real estate business, deals, financing & more

  • Bookstore

    Featured Book

    Recession-Proof Real Estate Investing book cover

    Recession-Proof Real Estate Investing

    This easy-to-follow guide will show you how to make money during all of the market’s twists and turns! Accomplished investor J Scott dives into the theory of economic cycles and the real-world strategies for harnessing them to your advantage.

    Get the book now

    Real Estate Books

    • Flipping and Estimating Bundle
    • How to Invest in Real Estate
    • How to Sell Your Home
    • See All Books
    Real Estate Books

    Shop books covering real estate investing and personal finance.

    Lease Agreement Package New

    Don't spend $1,000 on a lawyer!

    Real Estate Forms

    Lease Agreement Package New

    Don't spend $1,000 on a lawyer!

  • Plans
Log In Sign up
User
Quick search links
Podcast Hard Money Lenders Books Washington
ForumsArrowHousing News & Real Estate Market DiscussionsArrowWhy appreciation matters in the SF/Bay Area
  • Newest Posts Arrow Down Light
    • Newest Posts
    • Unanswered Discussions
  • Trending Arrow Down Light
    • Top Discussions
    • Trending Discussions
  • Off Topic Arrow Down Light
    • Local Real Estate Forums

      Real Estate Forums near you

      • New York City Real Estate Forum 1.3K Posts 191 Discussions
      • Norfolk Real Estate Forum 350 Posts 35 Discussions
      • Baltimore Real Estate Forum 1.8K Posts 223 Discussions
      • Norwalk Real Estate Forum 7 Posts -1 Discussions

      View all Local Real Estate forums

    • General Info
      • BiggerPockets Exclusive PRO Area 16K Posts 3.0K Discussions
      • Real Estate Not-So-Successful Stories 523 Posts 41 Discussions
      • BiggerPockets Summer Reading List 92 Posts 14 Discussions
      • Real Estate Quizzes 696 Posts 21 Discussions
      • BiggerPockets Money Podcast 675 Posts 50 Discussions
      • New Member Introductions 488K Posts 56K Discussions
      • FAQ Forum 132 Posts 9 Discussions
      • BiggerPockets Webinar Discussion Forum 459 Posts 15 Discussions
      • Questions About BiggerPockets and Official Site Announcements 42K Posts 4.1K Discussions
      • Real Estate Success Stories 77K Posts 3.7K Discussions
    • General Real Estate
      • Investor Deal Diaries 17K Posts 864 Discussions
      • Completed Deal Diaries 5.6K Posts 1.9K Discussions
      • Renters Discussion 44K Posts 5.1K Discussions
      • Military Investing 5.4K Posts 530 Discussions
      • Buying & Selling Real Estate Discussion 423K Posts 58K Discussions
      • Construction & Remodeling Diaries 6.1K Posts 1.0K Discussions
      • Do it Yourself 32K Posts 3.5K Discussions
      • Get Foreclosure Help - Stop Foreclosure Forum 6.6K Posts 910 Discussions
      • Home Owner Association (HOA) Issues & Problems Forum 6.2K Posts 910 Discussions
    • Reviews & Feedback
      • Real Estate Deal Analysis and Advice 131K Posts 18K Discussions
      • Ask About A Real Estate Company 24K Posts 2.7K Discussions
      • Real Estate Guru, Book & Course Reviews and Discussions 28K Posts 2.9K Discussions
    • Investor Basics
      • General Real Estate Investing 144K Posts 19K Discussions
      • Real Estate Investor Marketing Help & Advice 46K Posts 6.5K Discussions
      • Starting Out 290K Posts 41K Discussions
      • Investor Psychology 21K Posts 1.6K Discussions
    • Landlord & Tenant Forums
      • Mobile Homes & Mobile Home Park Investing 19K Posts 2.3K Discussions
      • Landlord Forums & Rental Property Questions 358K Posts 39K Discussions
    • Foreclosures
      • General Foreclosure & Pre-Foreclosure Forums 33K Posts 5.2K Discussions
      • REOs 17K Posts 2.2K Discussions
      • Short Sales Questions 17K Posts 2.1K Discussions
      • HUD, VA, and Tax Sales 10K Posts 1.5K Discussions
    • Real Estate Strategies
      • Real Estate Development & New Home Construction 19K Posts 2.6K Discussions
      • Rent to Own a.k.a. Lease Purchase, Lease Options 15K Posts 2.3K Discussions
      • Rehabbing and House Flipping 110K Posts 13K Discussions
      • Short-Term and Vacation Rental Discussion 22K Posts 2.0K Discussions
      • Tax Liens, Notes, Paper, & Cash Flows Discussion 34K Posts 3.9K Discussions
      • Real Estate Wholesaling Questions & Answers 137K Posts 18K Discussions
      • Innovative Strategies 27K Posts 3.4K Discussions
      • 1031 Exchanges 8.7K Posts 1.4K Discussions
    • Commercial Real Estate
      • Commercial Real Estate Investing Forum 36K Posts 4.8K Discussions
      • Multi-Family and Apartment Investing Forums 96K Posts 10K Discussions
    • Business Basics
      • Goals, Business Plans & Entities 25K Posts 3.5K Discussions
    • Real Estate Technology and the Internet
      • Real Estate Technology, Social Media & Blogging 16K Posts 2.3K Discussions
    • Loans, Mortgages, Credit Lines
      • Creative Real Estate Financing Forum 50K Posts 7.5K Discussions
      • Private Lending & Conventional Mortgage Advice 105K Posts 14K Discussions
      • Real Estate Crowdfunding Forums 5.6K Posts 384 Discussions
    • Financial, Tax, and Legal
      • Tax, Legal Issues, Contracts, Self-Directed IRA 100K Posts 15K Discussions
      • Personal Finance Forum 18K Posts 2.0K Discussions
      • Property Insurance Questions & Discussions 11K Posts 1.8K Discussions
    • Real Estate Professionals
      • Contractors 18K Posts 3.7K Discussions
      • Bankers, Lenders, and Mortgage Brokers 12K Posts 1.9K Discussions
      • Real Estate Agent Forums 47K Posts 7.0K Discussions
    • Real Estate Marketplace
      • Marketplace 227K Posts 88K Discussions
      • Real Estate Events and Happenings 57K Posts 12K Discussions
    • Off Topic
      • BiggerPockets Real Estate Investing Summit 2.0K Posts 107 Discussions
      • Off-Topic 43K Posts 5.3K Discussions
      • Housing News & Real Estate Market Discussions 15K Posts 1.8K Discussions
Start a Discussion

Why appreciation matters in the SF/Bay Area

168 Replies

  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
Rotate Log in or sign up to reply
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
Minh Le
  • 2.0K posts
  • 3.0K votes

Minh Le
Investor from San Jose, CA

replied over 4 years ago
Originally posted by @Amit M.:

no, @Ben Leybovich   is right. There are a lot of stupid, wealthy people in the Bay Area.  Unlike the mid west, where there are a lot of stupid, poor people.  

Amit,

That was hilarious.  I guess you have a point based on this "where millionaires live in America" article.  

http://www.kiplinger.com/slideshow/real-estate/T01...


Minh Le
  • 2.0K posts
  • 3.0K votes

Minh Le
Investor from San Jose, CA

replied over 4 years ago
Originally posted by @Manch Hon:

I must be dense. Why is it stupid?

Manch,

Based on my experience, the people, that acknowledge they are dense, are not dense at all.  However, the ones, that believe they know it all, actually don't know much.  It's what you don't know will likely hurt you the most.  

So, I'll stay humble and keep investing right here in SJ, where it has treated me best.  Like they say in tennis....there is no right way; there is no wrong way; there is always a better way.  So keep searching.  Don't forget me when you found it.

   

Manch Hon
  • 160 posts
  • 163 votes

Manch Hon
from San Jose, California

replied over 4 years ago

@Minh L. Very true and wise words. I actually learned a lot from you, @Amit M.  and @Bob Bowling 

I am now a believer in investing in local markets. As I told you guys half of my portfolio is outside of the Bay Area. Had I known you guys earlier I would have put every cent I have in local markets. :)

And I will never call other people stupid.

Minh Le
  • 2.0K posts
  • 3.0K votes

Minh Le
Investor from San Jose, CA

replied over 4 years ago
Originally posted by @Christian Carson:

One more note -- California does not have a monopoly on price appreciation markets. There are plenty of them out here in Ohio.

I don't believe anyone is saying CA has a monopoly on appreciation.  CA just happens to be an appreciation market.  That's it.  Therefore, when one is investing in CA and doesn't factor in an average appreciation rate, the analysis is incomplete.  Also, our market is known to be cyclical.  Knowing where we are in the cycle of the market plays an important role in inputting the appropriate parameters into our analysis.

Weren't you the one that has a property appraised for $90k, but you couldn't sell it for $82k?  To scale it up to our market, a $900k house would have sold yesterday for all cash had it listed at $820k.  In fact, there's a good probability that $900k house would have sold for $925k - $950k with multiple offer within 2 weeks being on the market.  That's how liquid our market compared to some other markets.  

With respect to who is smarter than whom, it typically comes down to net worth.  Should an individual take advice from someone who is not doing as well as s/he does financially? People are where they are in life for a reason.  They are successful for a reason, or they are poor for a reason.  When someone says they're lucky, it's just a nice way of being humble IMO.  As Benjamin Graham said "Due diligence is the mother of all luck."

Amit M.
  • 1.0K posts
  • 1.1K votes

Amit M.
Rental Property Investor from San Francisco, CA

replied over 4 years ago

this is getting to be a rather entertaining thread :)

Christian Carson
  • 394 posts
  • 208 votes

Christian Carson
from Cleveland, Ohio

replied over 4 years ago
Originally posted by @Minh L.:

With respect to who is smarter than whom, it typically comes down to net worth.  Should an individual take advice from someone who is not doing as well as s/he does financially? People are where they are in life for a reason.

Show me a well-educated bootstrapping entrepreneur and I'll show you a thousand trust-fund Wall Street bankster multimillionaires who couldn't complete a Monday New York Times crossword if their lives depended on it.

Matt R.
  • 3.5K posts
  • 2.2K votes

Matt R.
from Sherman Oaks, California

replied over 4 years ago

I think Ben is very smart. His 10 unit for 19k is just one example. Ben adds value with his management skills and that is brilliant. That kind of accumulation would not be possible in SF. An additional skill set would be required. I am sure he possesses as is. 

Thanks,

Matt

Sam M.
  • 6 posts
  • 4 votes

Sam M.
from San Francisco, California

replied over 4 years ago

Education and entertainment .. all in one spot - Love it! 

Bob E.
  • 2.0K posts
  • 777 votes

Bob E.
from Queen Creek, Arizona

replied over 4 years ago

Interesting thread.  I would suggest that appreciation of net worth is what matters.  In CA that can be done by purchasing and holding and individual property.  In other markets your property won't go up in value as much but you get a lot more cash-flow.  

If you rivets the cash-flow over time you get a form of appreciation.  Instead of having one property that goes from 300 to 600k in value you might have 10 properties worth 300k that turn into 20 properties worth 600k.  

You just have to adjust your strategy for the market you are in and you can make money.  Apply the wrong strategy to any market and you can lose money.  Making good management decisions can force appreciation in any market.

Sandeep S.
  • 104 posts
  • 103 votes

Sandeep S.
Investor from Cupertino, California

replied over 4 years ago

We shouldn't be so harsh on Ben.  Poor guy already is so upset about all the real estate wealth we Californians are enjoying.  

And I absolutely agree with Ben's analysis - especially looking at myself accumulating ton of wealth in the last 5 years. Although one wonders that when it is a "fact" that even brainless people can make easy money in the SF market, wouldn't one be even more stupid to know this fact and still not come and invest in the SF market?

Brian Tremaine
  • 64 posts
  • 17 votes

Brian Tremaine
Investor from San Jose, California

replied over 3 years ago

The Schiller Index does look good and I can attest to buying my first SFR in 1985 for $97k and today the market value is $670k (yes, I still own it). What troubles me is the affordability index in the BA is only 21% for Q12015. I know most my friends kids cannot afford to rent or buy in the BA. For a long time we have been seeing larger extended families living in homes together in order to afford the rents. This has to be putting some eventual limit on the appreciation growth. The modest 3/2 house for $670k rents for $2800/mo. It wouldn't make sense to but it today as a rental, even at $2800/mo, but as a buy & hold from 1985 its doing okay.

Personally I would be happy with 4-5% appreciation. 

Jay Hinrichs
  • 26K posts
  • 31K votes

Jay Hinrichs
Developer, Real Estate Broker, from Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV

replied over 3 years ago

@Brian Tremaine

  I grew up in Cupertino and by the time I went into the housing market 1977 houses in Cupertino had surpassed 100k.. and as a new RE Agent I could not buy were I was raised neither could any of my friends.  of course not many of my friends were buying houses at 20 years old either. I ended up going WAY out of town all the Way to Milpitas to buy my first home for 80k  a brand new Shapel home.. I think this is just a trend that will stay

And why place like Portland Oregon has some serious legs... My daughter works for intel. she started in santa clara and they were looking for their first home a starter home in Campbell for 850k.. I told her to get up here and check it out... only a 10% pay cut to work in Oregon they bought a beautiful 5 and 3  2700 sq ft home for less than 300k in the best school districts in the area.. and I think you will continue to see the brain drain from Silicon valley to silicon forest.

Johnson H.
  • 840 posts
  • 751 votes

Johnson H.
Investor from San Francisco, California

replied over 3 years ago
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs :

@Brian Tremaine

  I grew up in Cupertino and by the time I went into the housing market 1977 houses in Cupertino had surpassed 100k.. and as a new RE Agent I could not buy were I was raised neither could any of my friends.  of course not many of my friends were buying houses at 20 years old either. I ended up going WAY out of town all the Way to Milpitas to buy my first home for 80k  a brand new Shapel home.. I think this is just a trend that will stay

And why place like Portland Oregon has some serious legs... My daughter works for intel. she started in santa clara and they were looking for their first home a starter home in Campbell for 850k.. I told her to get up here and check it out... only a 10% pay cut to work in Oregon they bought a beautiful 5 and 3  2700 sq ft home for less than 300k in the best school districts in the area.. and I think you will continue to see the brain drain from Silicon valley to silicon forest.

 Hi Jay, what area of Portland is this? I think the Portland market is a great long term play. Great standard of living in the area and its still relatively affordable, especially at less than $300k. 

Sandeep S.
  • 104 posts
  • 103 votes

Sandeep S.
Investor from Cupertino, California

replied over 3 years ago
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs :

@Brian Tremaine

  I grew up in Cupertino and by the time I went into the housing market 1977 houses in Cupertino had surpassed 100k.. and as a new RE Agent I could not buy were I was raised neither could any of my friends.  of course not many of my friends were buying houses at 20 years old either. I ended up going WAY out of town all the Way to Milpitas to buy my first home for 80k  a brand new Shapel home.. I think this is just a trend that will stay

And why place like Portland Oregon has some serious legs... My daughter works for intel. she started in santa clara and they were looking for their first home a starter home in Campbell for 850k.. I told her to get up here and check it out... only a 10% pay cut to work in Oregon they bought a beautiful 5 and 3  2700 sq ft home for less than 300k in the best school districts in the area.. and I think you will continue to see the brain drain from Silicon valley to silicon forest.

How interesting Jay!  I now live in Cupertino, and moved here from Milpitas 4 years ago!  And I agree the trend you mentioned  (I only know how we stretched to get into Cupertino from Milpitas)!  Of course, once you are somehow in Cupertino - things work out as the market here is incredibly strong (for last several decades!)

Joe Bertolino
  • 1.0K posts
  • 881 votes

Joe Bertolino
Developer from El Dorado Hills, CA

replied over 3 years ago
The definition of a "normal salary" is different in the Bay than everywhere else. I was talking to an insurance agency owner in SF and he could not hold onto a competent receptionist/assistant for $45hr. They would get trained and hired away almost immediately. Almost anybody who can speak and write clearly in English and presents remotely well can command 6 figures in SF with a little networking.
Jay Hinrichs
  • 26K posts
  • 31K votes

Jay Hinrichs
Developer, Real Estate Broker, from Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV

replied over 3 years ago

@Johnson H.

  Beaverton is where my daughter ended up.. 15 minute commute to intel.

My son also owns his own place in Beaverton.. 

I do believe this market will continue to be strong.. but not like the bay area there is only one of those in the world

Tom V.
  • 330 posts
  • 240 votes

Tom V.
from San Francisco, California

replied over 3 years ago

Houzz was valued at a Billion dollars.  SF bay area is getting frothy.

Account Closed
  • 3.9K posts
  • 1.7K votes

Account Closed

replied almost 3 years ago

http://www.marketwatch.com/story/could-the-san-fra...

So $670,000 median price in 2012 to $1,120,000 in 2016!  Six years to gain $220,000 to get the customary doubling. 

Account Closed
  • 3.9K posts
  • 1.7K votes

Account Closed

replied almost 3 years ago

So that'd be about $9,375 in appreciation each and every month for 48 months!  And I've been predicting this on the internet's since at least 2006! And personally since 1980.   And some fools still call me crazy.  Crazy akamai!

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7

Top Contributors

Russell Brazil
Russell Brazil
Rockville, MD
7.38
Score
Cecile Poyet
Cecile Poyet
San Francisco, CA
4.97
Score
Jay Hinrichs
Jay Hinrichs
Lake Oswego OR Summerlin, NV
3.23
Score
Mike M.
Mike M.
Paradise Valley, AZ
1.29
Score
Karl B.
Karl B.
Los Angeles, CA
1.25
Score

Trending Discussions

  • Should I report this agent to the Board of Realtors or?
    108 Replies
  • California to make "Solar "mandatory for new Homes!!!!!!
    62 Replies
  • Does Number of Days on MLS affect your buying decisions?
    82 Replies
  • Should we wait or go for it?
    39 Replies
  • How many of you have bought a note this year ?
    29 Replies
Close Thin

Create Lasting Wealth Through Real Estate

Join the millions of people achieving financial freedom through the power of real estate investing

Start here

Already have an account? Click here to log in

Log in Sign up

Log in

Forgot password?

If you signed up for BiggerPockets via Facebook, you can log in with just one click!

Log in with Facebook

Let's get started

We just need a few details to get you set up and ready to go!

Use your real name

Use at least 8 characters. Using a phrase of random words (like: paper Dog team blue) is secure and easy to remember.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.

Why create an account?

Receive a free digital download of The Ultimate Beginner's Guide to Real Estate Investing.

Connect with 1,000,000+ real estate investors!

Find local real estate meetups and events in your area.

Start analyzing real estate properties, we do the math for you.

It's free!

Explore

  • Membership
  • Community
  • Education
  • Marketplace
  • Tools
  • Perks
  • iOS App
  • Android App

Company

  • About Us
  • Press
  • Advertising
  • Careers
  • Stats
  • Contact Us

Important

  • Terms of Use
  • Rules
  • Privacy
  • FAQ

Social

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
© 2004-2019 BiggerPockets, LLC. All Rights Reserved.