Skip to content

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions
BPCON2026 Orlando

October 2 - 4 Early Bird tickets are now ON SALE. Purchase your tickets today and save $100!

Get tickets
BPCON2026 Orlando

October 2 - 4 Early Bird tickets are now ON SALE. Purchase your tickets today and save $100!

Get tickets
For sale 5 days ago

$59,990

3 bd 1 ba 936 sqft

2609 Brookway St, Indianapolis, IN 46218

Residential SFR

Current Rent **

$1,387

Projected Rent **

$1,387

Estimated Cap Rate *

Pro Only

Estimated Cash on Cash ROI *

Pro Only

Posted By:

Andrew Griffin

Investor
Contact Seller
Get pre-approved by a lender
Be Ready to Buy, Find the Right Loan

Reduced Brookside Fixer on a Slab! Indianapolis

LINK TO ALL INFO AND PHOTOS: https://www.investbelowmarket.com/property/2609-Brookway-St

2609 Brookway St, Indianapolis, IN 46218
WALKTHROUGH WEDNESDAY, 06/10/26
MUST TEXT 317-751-2308 FOR ACCESS AND TIME

CASH ASKING PRICE
$ 59,990 CASH OR BEST OFFER

AFTER REPAIR VALUE
$ 160,000
Brookside Fixer on a Slab!

RENTAL ESTIMATE
$ 1,387 (Not Currently Rented)
Rent-O-Meter 3-Bed Avarage

PROPERTY DETAILS

- SFH
- Bed: 3
- Bath: 1
- Sqft: 936
- Lot Size: 3,703 Sqft
- Garage: 1-Car Detached Garage
- Built Year: 1960
- Basement: Slab Foundation
- Electrical: 100-Amp Breaker Panel
- Flooring: Leveled Flooring
- Garage: Detached Garage
- Current Occupancy: Owner Occupied
- Occupancy at Close: Vacant at Close
- Close of Escrow: 07/01/26
- Best Offer Due By: 06/11/26 12:00 PM
- Non-Refundable Earnest Money Deposit: $ 5,000

MARKET ACTIVITY
SUBJECT PROPERTY : 2609 Brookway St / 3 Beds / 1 Bath / 936 Sqft / 1 Detached Garage

COMPARABLES / RECENT ACTIVITY

SOLD $205,000 – 2818 E 17th St / 2 Bed / 2 Bath / 975 Sqft / 1 Detached Garage
- One less bedroom
- One additional bathroom

SOLD $177,000 – 2433 E 16th St / 2 Bed / 1 Bath / 726 Sqft / No Garage
- One less bedroom
- No Garage

SOLD $157,000 – 2838 E 19th St / 2 Bed / 1 Bath / 868 Sqft / 1 Detached Garage
- One less bedroom

SOLD $145,000 – 2018 N Dearborn St / 3 Bed / 1 Bath / 1,168 Sqft / No Garage Mentioned
- No Garage
- Basic rental grade

!! JOIN OUR BUYER LIST: https://www.investbelowmarket.com/ !!

Location:

2609 Brookway St, Indianapolis, IN 46218

Looking for an agent?

Become a featured agent on Agent Finder

Need a Contractor? Get help finding local and reliable contractors. From handyman to roof install, we can help.

Find a Contractor

Start a rental property calculator report
Use the rental calculator to determine this property's potential profit.
Analyze this property

* The cap rate and cash on cash return calculations found on BiggerPockets Listings are estimated and designed to be used for informational and educational purposes only, and when used alone, do not constitute investment advice. They assume 3 months worth of expenses and estimate taxes and insurance. BiggerPockets recommends that you seek the advice of a real estate professional before making any type of investment. The results presented may not reflect the actual return of your own investments. BiggerPockets is not responsible for the consequences of any decisions or actions taken in reliance upon or as a result of the information provided by these tools. Furthermore, BiggerPockets is not responsible for any human or mechanical errors or omissions.

** Current rent and projected rent are provided by the lister.

† Rental comps are pulled by looking at property characteristics (beds, baths, structure type), date the rent listing was captured, and proximity to the searched location.

‡ Confidence levels range from low to very high. Confidence is determined by the number of recent and relevant comparable properties for any given search. A very high confidence level indicates a high number of recent and similar rental listings.