I tell this short story to new clients when they inevitably ask me about property management. I came into the office one day only to find Dad waitin’ for me with a cuppa coffee. Crap on a cracker, this can’t be good. Know how sometimes your lizard brain screams a warning at ya? I heard it, but it was too late. Dad sat me down and informed me that this time next week, the company would have a property management division, and I was gonna be VP in charge. Also, it was to be in addition to, not instead of all my investment property brokerage duties. Awesome, Dad. VP my . . . .
8½ years later, Dad was retired — again — and I moved our clients to management firms I chose and vetted. Everyone was content, especially me. But for those 20, um, 8½ years I lived the OldSchool of hard knocks. Did I have mentors to help? You bet. In fact, back in those days I couldn’t swing a dead cat without hittin’ at least one of ’em. I hated every minute of it, but learned a ton. Dad’s been gone for almost five years now, and I’ve still not forgiven him. Truth be told, those hellish years have served me well, now that management is such a huge part of what we do. Oops, wrong word. Scratch that — what my team does. Since I closed the doors on the so-called management division that 1988 fall day, I’ve never managed another door. Every time I write or say that an involuntary smile hits my face.
Download Your FREE Tenant Screening Guide!
Hey there! Screening tenants can be a tricky business, and this critical step can be the difference between profits and disaster. To help you with your real estate investing journey, feel free to download BiggerPockets’ complimentary Tenant Screening Guide and get the information you need to find great tenants.
Before I say more, let it be known I don’t in any way consider myself a professional manager of residential income property. I did a solid, credible job back then, but it was never my ‘profession’. The lessons, nevertheless, were learned and apply pretty much everywhere I’ve been.
1. Management companies don’t make enough money.
If the typical rental commands $1,200-1,600 monthly, and you charge 10% of collected rents, well, do the math. A firm with 20 homes in the middle of that range makes $2,800 a month. That’s before expenses, and before taxes. If 1-3 of ’em are for rent at any given time, the labor becomes intensive. Even if everything always goes as agreed, the various vendors must be constantly managed. Then there are the monthly reports. The trouble calls from tenants. The concerned calls from investors unclear about what you may or may not be doing. Blah, blahhdie blah.
2. As mentioned in #1, the labor often gets intensive and becomes a giant time suck.
Using the 80/20 rule, most firms simply don’t last long. (And 80/20, in Dad’s opinion was being kind.) The pattern generally begins with the idea that the monthly fees will slowly but surely multiply through new business. Before long they’ll be able to hire help. They find themselves managing employees. This doesn’t turn out well. Vendors screw up, or don’t do their job. Tenants are late with rent — and the ‘why’ must be found out — and sooner rather than later. Phones must be answered, as voice mail is on the A-List as a cause for losing potential tenants. All the niggling little things that take from 10 minutes to an hour tend to pile up. Before long, they’re thinkin’ mowin’ lawns would be a lot easier.
3. Marketing for new business becomes the straw that breaks the camel’s back.
Again, see #1. More income from new business has a different meaning for most management companies. It’s a lesson they learn during their first successful ‘expansion’. They, and you can definitely include me in this one, almost always believe if only they could significantly increase the number of doors they’re managing, that ultimately they’ll outrun the insatiable TimeSuck Machine. That machine is undefeated, and rarely tied. Successful marketing merely yields more fodder for the machine.
4. The final phase is the false epiphany that either A) Corners must be cut; or B) New services for which they can charge their customers must be added to the menu.
These services often begin as bona fide. In-house handymen. But wait, handymen need parts. We can make a profit on those too. And it begins. There are many reading this who know all to well what I’m talkin’ about here. I’ve seen management firms that became virtual repair/replace services with management on the side. Well, probably not that bad. Pretty close though.
Back to Dad and I and our new ‘Division.’
We had one employee, my stepsister, God bless her. She dealt with the day to day stuff, while I took care of the black widows. Over time we ended up watchin’ over roughly 150 doors. Our fees ranged from 6-10% of collected rents, and averaged a bit under 8% overall. Between basic overhead, my sister’s salary, bookkeeping and monthly reports, our little ‘division’ barely paid for itself. We didn’t undercut the market with our fee schedule. We just did the job we were hired to do — lease and mange residential income property. We only managed property owned by our own investment clients, not the general public.
A job performed well, professionally, and with pride, and it paid operating expenses, and one employee. Me? I got nothin’. But I knew that was the deal goin’ in. It brought in new investment business, and solidified relationships with current clients. Otherwise, and with just one lonesome exception, it was a giant waste of time and effort. Most management firms aren’t created with the strategy of gaining investment clients and/or as a break-even proposition. Worse, they never thought of it as being a loss leader.
The TakeAways for real estate investors.
In every market there are astoundingly good property managers — and they’re good people too. I’d say 10-20% of ’em merit that rating. But then, that’s pretty much true with most service providers, isn’t it? The problem is finding them. One of the lessons Dad taught me over and over was that we can always find folks who’re excellent at something. We can always find people who’re OldSchool honest. What we can’t find are those who possess both attributes. And there’s the rub.
Whenever you find a real pro in property management, pay them what they want. They’re a bargain at retail. Stop hagglin’ over pennies ‘n nickels when it’s dollars you’re really after. You hired them cuz you won’t or can’t do it yourself. Those who’re wise enough and skilled sufficiently to profit from managing property — honestly — are worth their weight in gold. Attach almost literal meaning to that sentence.
The following axiom doesn’t generally apply to them, though there have been a few sad exceptions in my experience. Management is a hugely important part of my operation, and I never do it myself, nor do I ever make a buck from it. All encompassing diligence is what’s required of the investor opting to benefit from hiring professional management. In essence, you manage the manger, regardless of how good they are. After all, it’s your invested capital at risk. Anywho, here’s what I’ve told hundreds of investors to learn and never forget.
BawldGuy Axiom: Property management companies are nearly always wonderfully effective — ‘til they day they’re not.
Regardless of how well you vet them, you’ll make a mistake or three. I speak from humbling, first hand experience. In the last five years I’ve fired four management firms in different markets. I vetted them in person. I know what to look for. Heck I was one of ’em once, even if it was as a virtual hostage.
Management is pivotally important. Don’t hire it and walk away. Nobody cares as much as you do.
Photo: Richard O. Barry