Should I Keep my Property as Rental? 3 Questions You Should be Considering

by |

Many beginner or speculator-type real estate investors think that the crux of real estate investing is finding a distressed property, fixing it up, and selling for top profit. Keeping it as a rental ends up being a mistake, a backup plan, or a last resort for many people. But is keeping a property as a rental aways a bad thing?

Regardless of how you come about owning a piece of property, there are a few things to keep in mind when considering whether you should keep it as a rental or not…

Download Your FREE guide to evicting a tenant!

We hope you never have to evict a tenant, but know it’s always wise to prepare for the worst. Navigating the legal and financial considerations of an eviction can be tricky, even for the most experienced landlords. Lucky for you, the experts at BiggerPockets have put together a FREE Guide to Evicting Tenants so you can protect your property and investments.

Click Here For Your Free Tenant Eviction Guide

1. Is it in a Good Area?

There will be parts of your town that are known to be more desirable, are within a working class budget, and are close to important amenities like schools, grocery stores, and developed shopping centers.

Although there is the ongoing appeal and debate of buying cheap properties in war zones, the higher profit percentages may not be worth the management and maintenance headache for you. If you have no experience landlording, you typically want to avoid these areas all together.

If you’ve bought it at enough of a profit margin (or created forced equity through a rehab, additional square footage, etc), you may decide that the home could cash flow after you pay a monthly mortgage payment, taxes, insurance, and HOA (if there is one).

Check the rental rates in the area, how long it looks like it takes to rent a home of your mix (meaning, bedrooms and bathrooms). If you have the available credit, or a partner does, it looks like it would cash flow, it has equity, and it’s in a good area, you may have a winner.

Related: Newbies Take Note: Why You Shouldn’t Buy Houses for $30,000

2. Is it a Cash Cow?

If you’ve become an accidental landlord, cash flow may have never crossed your mind. But if your property has been sitting there and it looks like refinance may be the only option, the first thing to see is how much, potentially, you could rent it out every month at.

If its a marginal deal, (ie, less than $100 cash flow for every bedroom in the property), it may not make sense to you, and it would be time to move on to plan C. If you’re OK with breaking even, it could be a potential hold, but dealing with tenants every month just to cover a bill could quickly become a drain. Many a speculator found themselves in this position when the market tanked, with most letting the properties go to foreclosure or short sale. Prevention is the best medicine nowadays; buy at steeper margins.

If you’ve been specifically targeting properties to buy as a keeper, it will be important to review what the current leases are for, how long they are for, and if they reflect market rent. If not, why? Did the old owner keep them down just to keep the place occupied? Did he refuse to do needed updating and keep tenants at reduced rates? Either of these gives you the opportunity to do the updating needed and “clean house,” literally and figuratively. Just pencil out how long it would take you to get your cash investment back (through raised rents), and if it fits your criteria.

Every once in awhile you’ll find a deal that looked underwhelming at quick glance, but upon closer inspection could be reconfigured to be a gold mine. If it’s in a good area, and can be a cash cow, it might just be a keeper.

Related: Tenant Turnover: The Biggest Killer of Your Rental Cash Flow

3.  Would it be a Good Lease Option?

Perhaps it’s not a cash cow, but it’s a desirable property in a decent neighborhood. With the population of displaced homeowners that went through a foreclosure, you’ve widened the pool of people who want to own but don’t have the credit…just yet.

A lease option is when an occupant has a lease/rental in place, but also has an “Option” to purchase the house at a future date at a set price. You can collect a larger upfront payment for the option, whether it ends up being exercised by the tenant or not. They also tend the treat the house as they’re own, and be more hands off renters.

If you haven’t done or aren’t familiar with Lease Option (or this style of re-sale), don’t approach them ignorantly. Do your due diligence and have an attorney review your paperwork, as setting up the deal incorrectly can open a can of worms you could have easily avoided.

As the market shifts, you may notice your rehabs taking longer to sell, leaving you considering plan B. If keeping it as a rental is a possibility, these three examples can help you narrow down if the property will be an adaptable investment into your portfolio.

What do you think? What other criteria do you use when considering if a home is good to keep as a rental?

About Author

Tracy Royce

Tracy (G+) is an Arizona Short Sale Realtor, Investor, Rehabber, and Foreclosure Expert.
She also is an avid blogger, vlogger and consultant on all things Arizona Foreclosures.


  1. Nice article and timely for me as I’m looking at a flip possibility tonight but my exit strategy is to keep it as a rental if I had to as it would definitely cash flow and is also in a good area.

Leave A Reply

Pair a profile with your post!

Create a Free Account


Log In Here