I’ve Been Self-Managing for 10 Years: Here’s How I’m Interviewing My 1st Property Management Company [Video!]


Hey there, BP! So believe it or not, I’ve been in business for 10 years and never had to hire a property manager. We have been able to do that by keeping it close to home with investments inside of a 30-minute radius of our office. We’ve made a strategic decision to move forward this way and have done well with it. As a result, we have learned firsthand what works and what doesn’t, mostly because we did what doesn’t work in the beginning!

Related: 80 Smart Questions to Ask BEFORE Hiring Your Next Property Management Company

That being said, we are expanding our portfolio to areas where managing ourselves is not possible. We currently have a 49-unit building under contract located two hours from our office. We are really excited about the opportunity, but it puts a task on our plate for the first time — having to hire a property manager. As we’ve done it for so long ourselves, we have a pretty good idea what it takes to manage real estate.

In today’s video, I talk about an interview I had with a potential property manager for our new purchase. I share some important questions I asked and what I learned from their answers.

So we are still interviewing, and I’d love some feedback on this. What did I miss? What are YOUR most important factors to consider from a property manager? For those of you out there that have a successful management company running your rentals, what do they do well? Any management horror stories?

I look forward to your comments!

About Author

Matt Faircloth

In 2005, Matt founded The DeRosa Group along with his wife, Elizabeth. At the time, the two person company owned and managed two assets – a single family home and a duplex. Over the last nine years, they have grown the company to a 12 person team owning and managing over five million dollars in residential and commercial assets throughout the central NJ and Philadelphia area. One of DeRosa’s mantras is “to make money while making a difference.”


  1. Don Johnston

    Great video for a newbie like me. I’ve been around the block a few times but just never the REI block. Good list of questions that I would never have thought to ask…well, I would have asked how much they charge.

    Thank you for sharing your knowledge.

  2. Chet Snyder


    Great video. A couple things I would have liked you to have addressed. One is the typical fees these property management companies charge ( Is it standard in the industry for 10% of the rents going toward fees?) Second… In line with preventative maintenance. I would like a walk property inspection once a month. Is this too much to ask? You mentioned 3-4 employees per 240 units as the right amount…. it seems not enough to thoroughly watch out for ones property. Tenants do all sorts of things like rebuild VW engines in living room (had this happen) and have unauthorized guests or pets. Great job… and very generous of you to share. Thank you…


    • Matt Faircloth

      Hey Chetan,
      Great questions! Let me take a stab at it…

      Fees – for smaller projects like SFH’s and duplexes expect to pay 10% or more for management. This particular PM normally charages 8% and we are going to try and get the work for less, hopefully between 5 and 6%. Any property manager is going to charge additional for leasing, evictions and maintenance which should be in your negotiations also.

      Preventative maintenance inspections- once a month is heavy, I don’t think any manager will agree to that and in my experience it’s not necessary. We do pm walks at least once every 9 months. You will also find that your maintenance tech will be on site for some reason at least once a quarter like to change the furnace filter. If they see a rebuilt VW engine in the living room I’m sure you will find out links!

      I thought the same thing about this particular managers number of employees to units. On further inspection he told me that the 3 staff was only leasing agents and office staff. He outsources all the maintenance work to sub contractors.

      Thanks for the comment!


  3. Donna Wendell

    Thank you for taking the time to post this. I have an offer acceptable on my first investment property, one single-family home and even if I don’t hire a PM, the notes you provided will help me to know some of the many things I should consider when managing it myself.

    • Matt Faircloth

      Hey Donna,
      First off, congrats on your offer being accepted! You must be excited and probably nervous at the same time! Know that if you ran your numbers well, the deal will work out!

      Of you can swing it, I highly recommend that you do the management yourself on your first deal. You will get to know what it takes to manage the asset first and and won’t get dupped by a manager in the future.

      Good luck!!


    • Matt Faircloth

      Hey Jerry,
      Thanks for the comment. I think that’s a good blend. I have not met that many good managers of single families but there are plenty that will handle a complex. If I can ask, what are you paying your apartment complex management company? This came up on a prior comment so I thought it would be a good point of discussion.

  4. Levi Thornton

    Good point on the maintenance market up. What was the agent’s lease renewal fee, if any? I’v found most companies will try and collect $200 or 50% of one months rents just to renew leases, which I’ve never liked, and normally try to take out of the agreement. Did you also work on the leasing fee? I’ve seen managers double their money with that alone.

    Personally I would never pay a manager for doing court summons, that’s why I pay them to be a property manager, it’s part of management, minus court cost.

    Totally agree on the late fees, let them charge an admin fee for giving notice to the tenant to pay rent, you keep the late fee, they get the admin fee.

    Good video BTW!

    • Matt Faircloth

      Thanks for the comment Levi!
      Their contract calls for 25% of the rent for a lease renewal, which I don’t like. I can pay a fee for leasing a vacancy, no problem. For our renewals that we manage, it’s very little time investment – we just print a one-page renewal and mail it to the tenants. They mail it back, off we go.
      I made them a counter-offer – 5% management fee of collected rents, but an increase to 6.5% if the building is fully leased and all rents are collected inside of 30 days. I am hoping we can work something out like that because it will incentivise to run the building at a high standard. Also if we can beat our proforma vacancy rate of 5% we make more money and are happy to pass some of this along to the manager.

Leave A Reply

Pair a profile with your post!

Create a Free Account


Log In Here