I know a few people that were in those shoes.

Based on the numbers you provided and assuming a purchase price of $200,000,this deal PASSED the 1% Rule.Assuming you are getting a mortgage( I know you are considering cash) of $150,000 on a $200,000 purchase with interest rate at 4.5%,annual taxes at $4560 and insurance at $1680 .Your PITI(monthly mortgage) will be around $1280.With a monthly rent income of $2000,you will have a gross income of $720.This is before reserves for CAPEX ,maintenance etc I think you should cashflow $500/month.If I was in your shoes,I will go for it

I expected a bit more - maybe the other shoe hasn't dropped yet and they're still coming...Interesting, perhaps it's a different crowd of travelers..