If you want to keep the island and you paint the cabinets white I would paint the island a contrasting color, slate blue ,  cranberry or black just on the outside would probably be good.

@Rhonda Blue without knowing the laws of your state, I would advise to go through the eviction process.

In my affordable blue collar rental homes the answer is "no" on both.  

If most of your renters are blue collar, they are not going to pay $3000 a month to rent your house.  

I did buy a house with a bedroom with dark blue walls that I was just was too tired to paint (after covering the hot pink).

Good thing we check ourselves rather than calling a repairman and reprimanded them for their sloppiness.Then, I tend to rent to older blue collar guys who can take care of things themselves, and charged them cheaper rent.

This may work for a single family house but in an apartment complex it creates a perverse incentive not to pay rent especially in a low income blue collar small community rental properties.I have a 21 unit apartment complex where the previous owners offered generously cash-for-keys.

I didn't hear anything for 6 years and he contacted me one day out of the blue. 

CC has about 5,000 residents in town, and it's basically a blue collar tourist town. 

Sold properties are blue, properties for sale are green.