5/25/12 IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT: MAJOR BP Update Next Week!

Hide this

Jump to Category View All

Click a category below to view different forum categories.

BiggerPockets

General Info

Rss10 BiggerPockets Q&A, Site Questions, & Announcements

1001 topics, 8196 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 03:10PM

Rss10 BiggerPockets Exclusive PRO Area

12 topics, 81 posts — Last Post 03/23/12, 03:25PM

Rss10 New Member Introductions

4596 topics, 26506 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 04:49AM

Rss10 BiggerPockets Success Stories

152 topics, 1813 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 10:22AM

Rss10 BiggerPockets Real Estate Investing Summit

87 topics, 1549 posts — Last Post 05/07/12, 02:13PM

General Real Estate

General Real Estate

Rss10 Buying Real Estate

1318 topics, 10387 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 02:33PM

Rss10 Selling Real Estate

320 topics, 2544 posts — Last Post 05/08/12, 07:34PM

Rss10 Renters

202 topics, 1618 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 11:34AM

Rss10 Get Foreclosure Help - Help Stop Foreclosure Forum

221 topics, 1747 posts — Last Post 05/18/12, 08:38PM

Rss10 Home Owner Association (HOA) Issues & Problems Forum

111 topics, 719 posts — Last Post 05/08/12, 06:37AM

Rss10 Do it Yourself

328 topics, 2841 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 09:10AM

Reviews & Feedback

Rss10 Real Estate Deal Analysis and Advice

1625 topics, 12975 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 05:44PM

Rss10 Real Estate Guru, Book & Course Reviews and Discussions

700 topics, 7128 posts — Last Post 05/23/12, 02:16PM

Rss10 Ask About A Real Estate Company

330 topics, 4781 posts — Last Post 05/10/12, 10:31PM

Real Estate Investing

Real Estate Strategies

Rss10 Wholesaling

2588 topics, 19948 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 12:14PM

Rss10 Rehabbing and House Flipping

1622 topics, 14297 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 03:24PM

Rss10 Real Estate Development

202 topics, 1123 posts — Last Post 05/19/12, 07:40AM

Rss10 Pre-Construction & New Home Construction

90 topics, 600 posts — Last Post 05/05/12, 11:02AM

Rss10 Innovative Strategies

377 topics, 2935 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 02:00PM

Rss10 Tax Liens, Notes, Paper, & Cash Flows Discussion

477 topics, 2850 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 02:54PM

Rss10 Rent to Own a.k.a. Lease Purchase, Lease Options

355 topics, 2229 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 03:12PM

Rss10 1031 Exchanges

62 topics, 342 posts — Last Post 04/29/12, 08:09PM

Foreclosure Investing

Rss10 General Foreclosure & Pre-Foreclosure Forums

1156 topics, 7084 posts — Last Post 05/24/12, 06:30PM

Rss10 HUD, VA, and Tax Sales

216 topics, 1327 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 01:59PM

Rss10 REOs

948 topics, 7884 posts — Last Post 05/23/12, 05:04PM

Rss10 Short Sales

1254 topics, 10440 posts — Last Post 05/23/12, 01:58PM

Landlord & Tenant Forums

Rss10 Rental Property Questions & Landlording Issues

3183 topics, 28801 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 04:53PM

Rss10 Land & Farm Investing

118 topics, 736 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 01:27PM

Rss10 Mobile Homes & Mobile Home Park Investing

416 topics, 3071 posts — Last Post 05/24/12, 05:40PM

Real Estate Dealmaking

Rss10 Make Deals, Find Partners, Mentors & BirdDogs, etc.

3703 topics, 13610 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 01:07PM

Rss10 Promote Your Real Estate Buyer's List

160 topics, 689 posts — Last Post 05/02/12, 05:54AM

Rss10 Property Wanted

635 topics, 3041 posts — Last Post 05/19/12, 07:44AM

Rss10 Seeking Financing, Money, or Loans

1245 topics, 7437 posts — Last Post 05/21/12, 10:41AM

Rss10 Tax Liens, Notes, Paper, & Cash Flows Dealmaking

277 topics, 1909 posts — Last Post 05/23/12, 06:40PM

Rss10 Bulk REO Discussion and REO Dealmaking

843 topics, 5906 posts — Last Post 02/02/12, 04:20PM

Investor Basics

Rss10 Starting Out

4197 topics, 30898 posts — Last Post 05/24/12, 03:17PM

Rss10 Investor Psychology

298 topics, 4486 posts — Last Post 05/04/12, 09:01PM

Rss10 General Real Estate Investing

3145 topics, 21840 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 03:22PM

Rss10 Real Estate Investor Marketing

910 topics, 7482 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 10:26AM

Commercial Real Estate

Rss10 Commercial Real Estate Investing Forum

743 topics, 3995 posts — Last Post 05/23/12, 08:46AM

Rss10 Multi-Family and Apartment Investing

219 topics, 2013 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 11:11AM

Rss10 Office Investing

3 topics, 36 posts — Last Post 11/15/11, 02:42PM

Rss10 Industrial Property Investing

4 topics, 14 posts — Last Post 05/04/12, 06:44AM

Rss10 Retail Property Investing

10 topics, 77 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 10:15AM

Rss10 CRE Financing and Lending

26 topics, 247 posts — Last Post 05/23/12, 05:27AM

Rss10 CRE Syndication and Fundraising

26 topics, 236 posts — Last Post 05/20/12, 04:52PM

Rss10 CRE Property Management & Leasing

2 topics, 12 posts — Last Post 05/18/12, 12:34PM

The Business of Real Estate

Real Estate Technology and the Internet

Rss10 Technology, Social Media, Real Estate & The Web

269 topics, 2277 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 07:40AM

Rss10 Real Estate Blogs & Blogging

24 topics, 293 posts — Last Post 05/16/12, 09:29PM

Business Basics

Rss10 Goals, Business Plans & Entities

428 topics, 4273 posts — Last Post 05/24/12, 09:08PM

Real Estate Finance & Legal

Financial, Tax, and Legal

Rss10 Tax, Legal Issues, Contracts, Self-Directed IRA

1349 topics, 9465 posts — Last Post 05/24/12, 07:35AM

Rss10 Credit & Credit Repair

182 topics, 1484 posts — Last Post 05/22/12, 06:06PM

Rss10 Property Insurance

135 topics, 850 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 03:36PM

Rss10 Bankruptcy

21 topics, 113 posts — Last Post 05/21/12, 08:25PM

Loans, Mortgages, Credit Lines

Rss10 Private & Conventional Lending Discussion

1346 topics, 8087 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 02:20PM

Rss10 Creative Real Estate Financing

659 topics, 4285 posts — Last Post 05/24/12, 10:58AM

Real Estate Professionals

Real Estate Professionals

Rss10 Real Estate Agents

639 topics, 3562 posts — Last Post 05/24/12, 07:47PM

Rss10 Bankers, Lenders, and Mortgage Brokers

355 topics, 1268 posts — Last Post 05/04/12, 01:18AM

Rss10 Contractors

122 topics, 667 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 04:37PM

Local Real Estate

International Real Estate

Local Real Estate

Rss10 Local Real Estate Networking

612 topics, 3434 posts — Last Post 05/24/12, 02:08PM

Rss10 Americans & International Real Estate

139 topics, 505 posts — Last Post 05/20/12, 02:00PM

Rss10 Foreigners Buying in the USA

56 topics, 288 posts — Last Post 05/02/12, 07:54PM

Rss10 Canadian Real Estate

26 topics, 130 posts — Last Post 03/19/12, 05:58PM

Marketplace

Real Estate Marketplace

Rss10 Mortgages & Lending

392 topics, 1757 posts — Last Post 05/20/12, 03:10AM

Rss10 Residential Property, Land, & Farms For Sale

760 topics, 1463 posts — Last Post 05/24/12, 06:58PM

Rss10 Real Estate Events & Happenings

118 topics, 505 posts — Last Post 05/07/12, 10:07PM

Rss10 Commercial Properties for Sale or Lease

224 topics, 671 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 08:42AM

Rss10 Domains & Website Reviews

48 topics, 391 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 07:07AM

Rss10 Classifieds - Promote your Website, Newsletter, or Product

595 topics, 2801 posts — Last Post 05/23/12, 06:42PM

Off-Topic

Off Topic

Rss10 Off-Topic

1866 topics, 19997 posts — Last Post 05/25/12, 08:12AM

Rss10 Housing News & Real Estate Market

666 topics, 6615 posts — Last Post 05/09/12, 03:11PM

BiggerPockets Resources

Forums » Tax, Legal Issues, Contracts, Self-Directed IRA » Self Directed IRA issues/questions

Self Directed IRA issues/questions Subscribe to Self Directed IRA issues/questions

24 posts by 12 users

Signup

Real Estate Investor · Littleton, Colorado


I'm trying to put together my first deal using our Self Directed IRA.

Our problem is we have no money for investing except what is in our SD IRA. I'm trying to find a way to use the SD IRA and be involved in a deal to receive part of the profits...we need to build up cash outside the SD IRA for future purchases. Is there a way to do this?

First, I get a loan and use the SD IRA for the down payment and fix. Won't work because the banks do not do non-recourse loans so the SD IRA requirements are not met.

Second, I understand that I can loan the money to anybody as long as they are non-disqualified (not a spouse, up line or down line)...using a promisary note. But how do I get a share of the profits?

Third, I also understand that I can loan the SD IRA to a business I'm affiliated with as long as it is 49% or less ownership...and the partner has to be a non-qualified individual and the managing member in the LLC. The SD IRA can NOT be used as collateral.

I feel like the stick man hitting his head on the wall over and over.

If anyone has information regarding investing with the SD IRA...I would greatly appreciate your input.

thx!


Real Estate Lender · Chicago, Illinois


Stopping hitting your head because this is not going to happen for you, legally.

SD IRA rules are very strict and the trustees who operate them are typically very vigilant. Bottom line, you cannot personally see any benefit from the IRA investment.
If the IRA is involved in the transaction there is much paperwork involved to keep the money going where it should go. For example, if the IRA partners with you on a rental, you cannot even receive the rent checks. The IRA has to get their portion before you even touch the money.

Equity trust's website has lots of info on it about this.


Real Estate Investor · Wheat Ridge, Colorado


I'm trying to find a way to use the SD IRA and be involved in a deal to receive part of the profits

Stop right there. There's just no way to legitimately do this. If you receive any benefit as a result of a transaction your IRA does, its, by definition, a prohibited transaction. Performing a prohibited transaction will result in the entire IRA account being immediately and irrevocably distributed. You immediately owe all taxes and penalties due on the full amount.

You can get a loan in your SDIRA. Last I checked, 1st Bank is doing them. 65% max LTV. Keep in mind, though, that debt financed rental income is subject to tax even if its inside your IRA.

Small_flying-phoenixJon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC


Real Estate Consultant · yucaipa, California


I agree! Legally you cannot derive any personal gain/profit from your investment. Strict rules apply. With that said; In my opinion, A Solo 401K Self Directed plan is much better. Some restrictions remain the same but the flexibility for the owners of the plan is far superior to a SD Ira. The reason why you don't see them advertised by the big custodians is because the Solo K plan is not only self directed but also self managed. No third party custodian required. Also you don't need to set up a separate LLC.


Real Estate Lender · Chicago, Illinois


Matt,

Thanks for the tip. I'll have to look into that!


Real Estate Consultant · Austin, Texas


Penny,

What you need is a self-directed 401k, IRA no. This will give you the opportunity to do business both inside and outside the retirement fund since you can borrow from the 401k. The 401k also has another advantage in that there is no Unrelated Debt Financing tax which may be imposed with an IRA if debt is used.

If you use a 401k it is best to use a compliant LLC to protect the 401k against litigation.
Dan


Real Estate Investor · Littleton, Colorado


Thank you for all the great feedback and tips.

It looks like what I need at this point is an elephant!


Real Estate Consultant · Austin, Texas


Wehave a client that is in your area. Would you like to talk with someone who has gaone through the process and may be able to give you a user's perspective?


Real Estate Investor · Littleton, Colorado


Dan,

Yes...please. I would love to talk to someone that is using their SD IRA.

THANK YOU!


Real Estate Consultant · Austin, Texas


You'll need to send me contact info. I don't know if this is against the rules but you can reach me at [PHONE NUMBER REMOVED]


Real Estate Consultant · Austin, Texas


Peggy can you please follow me so I can send you info looks like the system does not allow for numbers on the posts


Real Estate Investor · Wheat Ridge, Colorado


If you have additional questions, Peggy, post them here. There are a number of us using SDIRAs for real estate related investments.

Small_flying-phoenixJon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC


Homeowner · Philadelphia, Pennsylvania


I just read old threads on the topic which were very helpful. I wrote out a more detail post which was erased so I'll just ask.

Please tell me who you use as your SDIRA administrator? I'm looking at Entrust.

Thanks in advance!


Real Estate Investor · Austin, Texas


Entrust is a good choice. Dan uses someone different for his clients so they may be a bit cheaper.

Small_bullseye_capital_logoBryan Hancock, Bullseye Capital Real Property Opportunity Fund
E-Mail: b.hancock@bullseyecap.com
Telephone: 1-800-577-0401
Website: http://www.bullseyecapfund.com
I help busy people profit from real estate


SFR Investor · Long Beach, California


Originally posted by Elisha Lowe

Please tell me who you use as your SDIRA administrator? I'm looking at Entrust.

Thanks in advance!

I really only looked at two different companies, Equity Trust and Entrust. I don't want to come across as a shill, but I thought Equity Trust was better across the board. They had lower initial fees than Entrust and they don't charge for check writing and other features that other custodians do. Maybe Entrust has changed things since then (I set mine up two years ago)?



SFR Investor · Long Beach, California


Originally posted by Elisha Lowe

Please tell me who you use as your SDIRA administrator? I'm looking at Entrust.

Thanks in advance!

I really only looked at two different companies, Equity Trust and Entrust. I don't want to come across as a shill, but I thought Equity Trust was better across the board. They had lower initial fees than Entrust and they don't charge for check writing and other features that other custodians do. Maybe Entrust has changed things since then (I set mine up two years ago)?



Homeowner · Philadelphia, Pennsylvania


Thanks for replying. I will check out both companies. At first I thought SDIRAs were overly complicated and a sure way of just tying up funds. I see it differently now. I have (2) 401ks just sitting and I'm thinking of rolling them over for the purpose of investing in deals outside of my own. I plan to sit down with a professional and go over details but it seems like a good way to invest towards retirement.


Real Estate Investor · Littleton, Colorado


The SD IRA company that I'm working with is Equity Trust. They have been very helpful.

Equity Trust does not charge for check writing...in fact, they will handle all the transactions associated with your account.

We do not have enough to buy an investment on our own...that is where the complications come in. The easiest method is to loan to someone for puchasing property...you can not loan to yourself, up and down line of relation or business partners.


Real Estate Consultant · Austin, Texas


Elisha,

Something to keep in mind. Custodians become your IRA Mother. If they don't feel like doing something one day they don't have to let you and they don't have to be accountable to their changes.

And there seems to be some magic about being big. Two "big" IRA custodians have gone into receivership this past year. And in each case there were multiple problems with people that needed to get transactions done. By in large transactions go without a problem but there will come a day when you need to do something and it won't get done because something slipped or it was beyond their policy (not law). Look into being your own manager of your IRA and avoid needless fees and delays; your time is worth something and there is no sense in paying "aggravation" fees. And if the custodian gets into problems then you continue to do business as usual.

I'm sure there will be rebuttals to my comment from those who theoretically know what happens upon problems however, we solve them everyday!


Real Estate Investor · Wheat Ridge, Colorado


I've used Sterling Trust Company in the past and still have an account with them and one asset there. Their fees are less than Entrust or Equity Trust. I also looked at Fiserv, but they were very rude on the phone. Fiserv's fees were the lowest I found.

The issue I had with Sterling was responsiveness. Each loan was a new deal and had to go through their review process. Usually took about two weeks to get the money sent. Usually this wasn't too much of a problem, but did require extra planning to avoid delaying closing. It came to a head when releasing one of the liens. They have to sign off, and Colorado requires the original deed of trust to be returned. It took forever to get this sorted out.

I ended up creating an IRA LLC using Guidant Financial. That's expensive, and has had a bit of a hassle and expense when the custodian/trustee (not sure which it is) jacked up their fees. But much faster to fund. And one of the loans has defaulted and now I'm dealing with finishing a rehab and getting the house sold. No way I could have that with Sterling writing a check for each expense.

Small_flying-phoenixJon Holdman, Flying Phoenix LLC




Sign up