Business Page
Superior Property Group
Property Manager
4.3 stars
66 Reviews
Markets served
Madison, WI
About us
With over 20 years of experience as investors and property managers in Southern Wisconsin, we have the expertise to maximize your property's profit potential. If you value transparency, you'll appreciate our detailed and candid pricing. With no hidden fees and expenses, you'll know exactly what you're paying for. At Superior Property Group, we specialize in aiding small investors in managing their long-term rentals. Join us today and see how our professional, transparent approach can transform your real estate investment experience and maximize your rental income returns.
Specialties
Long-term rental: 12+ months
Single-family/Townhouse/Condo
Small multi-family: 2-4 units
Large multi-family: 5-19 units
Large multi-family: 20-49 units
Other Property Management Services
HOA/Associations
Reviews (66)
4.3 stars
66 Reviews
4.3 stars
66 Reviews
0.0 star
0 Reviews
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Jon Pfeiffer
Property Meld guys did a great job fixing things in my apartment. They replaced the leaking plumbing in my kitchen sink, fixed my clogged bathroom sink and quieted a noisy kitchen fan I had to live with for almost a year. On top of all those things, they replaced all my windows in the middle of January. When they were done with their work, they cleaned up my apartment and outside as well. Nice job.
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Susan Koch
Hi! I reported low water pressure in one sink in the afternoon yesterday, I think. Maintenance came at 8 this morning, had to go get a part, came back and fixed it fast so the resident got to work on time. Thank you for the fast response and concern .
1.0 star
a month ago
Reviewed by
Zachary Brimmer
What an absolute group of clowns they keep changing the condo fee portal every few months and only notify you once. Don’t except check payments and never email back when that’s the only form of communication. Would not live anywhere they own.
5.0 stars
4 months ago
Reviewed by
Valerie Rich
Have had a Condo there for several years and have been very happy. Just sold the Condo due to personal circumstances and Jared took care of everything and was smooth sailing. The Association is very attentive and sincerely care about the property and their (our) community. Do NOT hesitate to live here!! Absolutely wonderful .
1.0 star
4 months ago
Reviewed by
anon ymous
Superior is 1 of those management companies who's happy to take the money but provides the absolute bare minimum (or less). Very few things are handled proactively. After they're contacted, the maintenance issues are addressed promptly about half the time. The other half, it doesn't matter how many times you call or email; they're going to ignore you indefinitely. Via email, questions are usually answered in a partial, roundabout way. To request maintenance, you have to file it in a system called Meld which forces you to go through an AI chat. After that's submitted, multiple automated emails are sent that list their hourly prices and say things like "Thank you for submitting this meld for in-unit service" which is confusing when it's an exterior thing (not in-unit) that's covered by the HOA fee (so the hourly fees don't apply). It's not the end of the world, but that process adds to the frustration that comes from the overall way that they communicate. They said they were going to enter my unit on a particular day to do some work, but they never showed up. I emailed to ask about it, and I got no response. On another occasion, they entered my unit without any notice. There's a long list of issues with Superior, and as much as they'd like you to believe that these are isolated incidents, I've talked to multiple neighbors who have also had multiple issues. I know a lot of management companies aren't great, but I'm certain that there are some who are better than this. Frankly I'm surprised that they have as many 5 star reviews as they do.
1.0 star
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Rhamel Lloyd
Was booked for a showing that was confirmed via phone and I arrived 15 minutes early and no one ever showered up. I stood outside for 15 minutes at 600 S Brearly Apt. I reached out to the company via phone 3 times and kept getting forwarded to voicemail. I left work early to make it to this showing and no one had the decency to let me know they either couldn’t show up or that the showing would no longer be taking place.
5.0 stars
Edited 4 months ago
Reviewed by
Kathy Bultman
Recommend Superior properties painting services performed by Tony very highly! Tony did a great job and was very professional. Also very speedy. Can’t recommend him highly enough.
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Matthew Poster
I cannot recommend Jared Pinkus of Superior Property Group highly enough! From start to finish, Jared made the entire real estate process seamless, efficient, and even enjoyable. His professionalism, attention to detail, and deep understanding of the market set him apart from other realtors I’ve worked with.
Jared's communication skills are truly unmatched. He kept me informed every step of the way, always making sure I understood all my options and was comfortable with each decision. Whether it was answering my questions, negotiating on my behalf, or simply providing reassurance during stressful moments, Jared always went above and beyond.
What impressed me the most was Jared’s commitment to finding the right property. He listened carefully to my preferences, understood my goals, and tailored his approach to match. I never felt rushed or pressured. Instead, Jared demonstrated incredible patience and a genuine passion for ensuring I found the perfect home.
On top of his stellar work ethic, Jared has a knack for anticipating challenges and solving problems before they arise. His knowledge of the local market and his network of professionals (inspectors, contractors, etc.) were invaluable. He also made navigating the paperwork and legalities surprisingly straightforward.
If you’re looking for a realtor who will advocate for you, work tirelessly, and ensure your real estate experience is nothing short of exceptional, Jared Pinkus at Superior Property Group is the one to call. He truly exceeded all my expectations, and I wouldn’t hesitate to work with him again in the future!
5/5 Stars
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Jon Pfeiffer
Property Meld guys did a great job fixing things in my apartment. They replaced the leaking plumbing in my kitchen sink, fixed my clogged bathroom sink and quieted a noisy kitchen fan I had to live with for almost a year. On top of all those things, they replaced all my windows in the middle of January. When they were done with their work, they cleaned up my apartment and outside as well. Nice job.
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Susan Koch
Hi! I reported low water pressure in one sink in the afternoon yesterday, I think. Maintenance came at 8 this morning, had to go get a part, came back and fixed it fast so the resident got to work on time. Thank you for the fast response and concern .
1.0 star
a month ago
Reviewed by
Zachary Brimmer
What an absolute group of clowns they keep changing the condo fee portal every few months and only notify you once. Don’t except check payments and never email back when that’s the only form of communication. Would not live anywhere they own.
5.0 stars
4 months ago
Reviewed by
Valerie Rich
Have had a Condo there for several years and have been very happy. Just sold the Condo due to personal circumstances and Jared took care of everything and was smooth sailing. The Association is very attentive and sincerely care about the property and their (our) community. Do NOT hesitate to live here!! Absolutely wonderful .
1.0 star
4 months ago
Reviewed by
anon ymous
Superior is 1 of those management companies who's happy to take the money but provides the absolute bare minimum (or less). Very few things are handled proactively. After they're contacted, the maintenance issues are addressed promptly about half the time. The other half, it doesn't matter how many times you call or email; they're going to ignore you indefinitely. Via email, questions are usually answered in a partial, roundabout way. To request maintenance, you have to file it in a system called Meld which forces you to go through an AI chat. After that's submitted, multiple automated emails are sent that list their hourly prices and say things like "Thank you for submitting this meld for in-unit service" which is confusing when it's an exterior thing (not in-unit) that's covered by the HOA fee (so the hourly fees don't apply). It's not the end of the world, but that process adds to the frustration that comes from the overall way that they communicate. They said they were going to enter my unit on a particular day to do some work, but they never showed up. I emailed to ask about it, and I got no response. On another occasion, they entered my unit without any notice. There's a long list of issues with Superior, and as much as they'd like you to believe that these are isolated incidents, I've talked to multiple neighbors who have also had multiple issues. I know a lot of management companies aren't great, but I'm certain that there are some who are better than this. Frankly I'm surprised that they have as many 5 star reviews as they do.
1.0 star
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Rhamel Lloyd
Was booked for a showing that was confirmed via phone and I arrived 15 minutes early and no one ever showered up. I stood outside for 15 minutes at 600 S Brearly Apt. I reached out to the company via phone 3 times and kept getting forwarded to voicemail. I left work early to make it to this showing and no one had the decency to let me know they either couldn’t show up or that the showing would no longer be taking place.
5.0 stars
Edited 4 months ago
Reviewed by
Kathy Bultman
Recommend Superior properties painting services performed by Tony very highly! Tony did a great job and was very professional. Also very speedy. Can’t recommend him highly enough.
5.0 stars
a year ago
Reviewed by
Matthew Poster
I cannot recommend Jared Pinkus of Superior Property Group highly enough! From start to finish, Jared made the entire real estate process seamless, efficient, and even enjoyable. His professionalism, attention to detail, and deep understanding of the market set him apart from other realtors I’ve worked with.
Jared's communication skills are truly unmatched. He kept me informed every step of the way, always making sure I understood all my options and was comfortable with each decision. Whether it was answering my questions, negotiating on my behalf, or simply providing reassurance during stressful moments, Jared always went above and beyond.
What impressed me the most was Jared’s commitment to finding the right property. He listened carefully to my preferences, understood my goals, and tailored his approach to match. I never felt rushed or pressured. Instead, Jared demonstrated incredible patience and a genuine passion for ensuring I found the perfect home.
On top of his stellar work ethic, Jared has a knack for anticipating challenges and solving problems before they arise. His knowledge of the local market and his network of professionals (inspectors, contractors, etc.) were invaluable. He also made navigating the paperwork and legalities surprisingly straightforward.
If you’re looking for a realtor who will advocate for you, work tirelessly, and ensure your real estate experience is nothing short of exceptional, Jared Pinkus at Superior Property Group is the one to call. He truly exceeded all my expectations, and I wouldn’t hesitate to work with him again in the future!
5/5 Stars