Skip to content

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions

Business Page


business profile image

Bullet Property Management LLC

Property Manager
4.9 stars
158 Reviews

Markets served


Columbus, IN
Hope, IN
Edinburgh, IN
Taylorsville, IN
Elizabethtown, IN
Jonesville, IN
Clifford, IN
Ogilville, IN
Gnaw Bone, IN
Seymour, IN
North Vernon, IN

Licenses, Designations or Certificates


Indiana Real Estate License Holder

More ways to connect


(812) 565-2682

About us


We offer full service property management services to the southern part of the Indiana market primarily focusing on the Columbus, Hope, Edinburgh, and Seymour areas. We have been in business for four years and currently manage over 250 doors. We are licensed real estate agents in the state of Indiana so we help many investors in the state close deals are grow their portfolios while managing it throughout the process. 

Specialties


Commercial

Offices
Retail
Mixed Use

HUD/Section 8

Single-family/Townhouse/Condo
Small multi-family: 2-4 units
Large multi-family: 5-19 units
Large multi-family: 20-49 units
Large multi-family: 50-99 units
Large multi-family: 100+ units

Long-term rental: 12+ months

Single-family/Townhouse/Condo
Small multi-family: 2-4 units
Large multi-family: 5-19 units
Large multi-family: 20-49 units
Large multi-family: 50-99 units
Large multi-family: 100+ units

Other Property Management Services

Mid-term rental: 1-12 months
Student Housing

Reviews (158)


4.9 stars
158 Reviews
4.9 stars
158 Reviews
0.0 star
0 Reviews

reviewer image
1.0 star
|
a month ago
Reviewed by Richard Parkison
I rented residence in whiteland Indiana from bullitt properties. From the very beginning there was issues as to the condition of the condo the marks on the walls the mold in the laundry room behind the where the washer goes in the corner the sink faucet in the kitchen handle never pull out hardly the sink in the laundry room missing the button there were bugs in the refrigerator the refrigerator looked Crystal clean but you opened it up and it smelled ungodly I had talked to them about that plus the bugs in the master bathroom not to mention all the marks on the walls all the cobwebs on the ceilings in the corners of the the bedrooms and after I run around with the refrigerator and explaining to them about the paint job that they said was just done that was not just done because all the marks are unbelievable they're still there today if I could get into my old phone or knew how I could pull up all the pictures it's about 40 pictures they said it was my responsibility to get all that stuff turned into them they should not have running the place was like that I hired someone to look at the place and when I talk to them about it they act like that was all my fault bad eyes to the felt something out with apartments.com and they never did come back and fix any of it Then I had a hardship work got very slow and I needed some help and I went to them prior and talked to them and they had no consideration or nothing and I get it that people got to make a living you don't continually pile on $100 late fees on somebody that's trying to pay the rent I had to have my employer pay the rent for me to help me out until I could get out of the hole I was in not only that each time I paid they charged me for using the card I think it was 30 or 40 some bucks I was in a very serious car accident and what's my back was broke three times my ribs broke nine times and four of them broken twice my sternum was smashed my shoulder shifted and my collarbone broke call them and let them know that I was in the hospital I just woke up from a coma and they said I don't remember exactly what they said but I was under the impression that if I did not agree to pay two extra months because they couldn't rent a place out that they were going to sue me tell my lease was up this was the end of April which meant I would have been sued for 6 more months at 1500 a month probably plus late fees they said to they would keep my deposit for early moving out and charge me two more months because they will have to get it ready to clean and we rent I told him I would try to pay once insurance or something got me the money because I can no longer work due to my injury I try once again to get them to work with me instead they said I signed a contract and I owe for two more months that they already rented the place out I tried to talk to them all they say is you sign the contract contract you signed the contract I signed the contract because I thought I would be sued for a whole 6 months because they couldn't rent the place out I was led to believe that I was screwing them out of money because I moved and because I moved they can't bring it or something but they rent it out immediately and when I call them just tell me you sign the contract I gave him the address to where I'm at to send me an email they did me very wrong and then at one time they even send me the homeowners bill with a late fee on it and tried to include that on my rent to the through the app
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by Geoffrey Kowal
I would highly recommend Bullet Property Management. The staff members are always courteous and go the extra mile to make sure the customer is taken care of. Bullet Property Management combines professionalism, prompt service, and a friendly attitude that makes renting a pleasure rather than a hassle. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a stress‑free rental experience!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by Michael Cogdill
I’ve had an outstanding experience with Bullet Property Management. They are professional, responsive, and truly care about both property owners and tenants. Communication is clear and timely, maintenance requests are handled quickly, and everything is managed with integrity and attention to detail. It’s rare to find a company that delivers this level of service consistently. Highly recommend!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
7 months ago
Reviewed by Vinny Avalos
Great people very accommodating and fair with their leases. Nick was fantastic to work with very professional
reviewer image
1.0 star
|
7 months ago
Reviewed by Ruthann Simmons
I recently rented property from Bullet Property MANAGEMENT and from my experience they will do anything to scam you out of your money. Mattie and Shelby are not truthful and are only out to twist things around for their good and make up rules as they go along. I would not recommend doing business with this company. Scammers!! Where in my lease does it say you can charge $50 return fee when you are overpaid?
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 years ago
Reviewed by Diego Banuelos
As a first time owner looking to rent my property, I had many concerns. Soon after meeting the great team behind Bullet Property Management my worries quickly subsided and my confidence in renting out my home could not have been higher. From their great connection with local vendors and service providers to their in-depth connection with property owners and tenants alike, simply put I felt like I couldn’t be in better hands. I look forward to a long lasting and fruitful relationship with the team at Bullet Property Management, I would highly recommend them to any of my family and friends! 🤝
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 years ago
Reviewed by Richa Verma
I contracted with Bullet Property Management a few months back and my experience has been very positive. As a first time land lord, there were many unknowns. Nick and his team did a fantastic job of guiding me through the process and helping with key decisions. They are very professional, providing transparent and clear communication at every step. They secured new tenants quickly and handled the transition smoothly. I would highly recommend their property management services.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 years ago
Reviewed by Ethan Stout
I’ve had a fantastic experience with Bullet Property Management in Columbus, Indiana. Their team is highly professional, responsive, and truly cares about their tenants. From the moment I signed my lease, I knew I was in good hands. Maintenance requests are handled quickly, and they always communicate any updates or important information promptly. The entire process, from application to move-in, was seamless and stress-free. I highly recommend Bullet Property Management to anyone looking for a reliable and trustworthy property management company!
reviewer image
1.0 star
|
a month ago
Reviewed by Richard Parkison
I rented residence in whiteland Indiana from bullitt properties. From the very beginning there was issues as to the condition of the condo the marks on the walls the mold in the laundry room behind the where the washer goes in the corner the sink faucet in the kitchen handle never pull out hardly the sink in the laundry room missing the button there were bugs in the refrigerator the refrigerator looked Crystal clean but you opened it up and it smelled ungodly I had talked to them about that plus the bugs in the master bathroom not to mention all the marks on the walls all the cobwebs on the ceilings in the corners of the the bedrooms and after I run around with the refrigerator and explaining to them about the paint job that they said was just done that was not just done because all the marks are unbelievable they're still there today if I could get into my old phone or knew how I could pull up all the pictures it's about 40 pictures they said it was my responsibility to get all that stuff turned into them they should not have running the place was like that I hired someone to look at the place and when I talk to them about it they act like that was all my fault bad eyes to the felt something out with apartments.com and they never did come back and fix any of it Then I had a hardship work got very slow and I needed some help and I went to them prior and talked to them and they had no consideration or nothing and I get it that people got to make a living you don't continually pile on $100 late fees on somebody that's trying to pay the rent I had to have my employer pay the rent for me to help me out until I could get out of the hole I was in not only that each time I paid they charged me for using the card I think it was 30 or 40 some bucks I was in a very serious car accident and what's my back was broke three times my ribs broke nine times and four of them broken twice my sternum was smashed my shoulder shifted and my collarbone broke call them and let them know that I was in the hospital I just woke up from a coma and they said I don't remember exactly what they said but I was under the impression that if I did not agree to pay two extra months because they couldn't rent a place out that they were going to sue me tell my lease was up this was the end of April which meant I would have been sued for 6 more months at 1500 a month probably plus late fees they said to they would keep my deposit for early moving out and charge me two more months because they will have to get it ready to clean and we rent I told him I would try to pay once insurance or something got me the money because I can no longer work due to my injury I try once again to get them to work with me instead they said I signed a contract and I owe for two more months that they already rented the place out I tried to talk to them all they say is you sign the contract contract you signed the contract I signed the contract because I thought I would be sued for a whole 6 months because they couldn't rent the place out I was led to believe that I was screwing them out of money because I moved and because I moved they can't bring it or something but they rent it out immediately and when I call them just tell me you sign the contract I gave him the address to where I'm at to send me an email they did me very wrong and then at one time they even send me the homeowners bill with a late fee on it and tried to include that on my rent to the through the app
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by Geoffrey Kowal
I would highly recommend Bullet Property Management. The staff members are always courteous and go the extra mile to make sure the customer is taken care of. Bullet Property Management combines professionalism, prompt service, and a friendly attitude that makes renting a pleasure rather than a hassle. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a stress‑free rental experience!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by Michael Cogdill
I’ve had an outstanding experience with Bullet Property Management. They are professional, responsive, and truly care about both property owners and tenants. Communication is clear and timely, maintenance requests are handled quickly, and everything is managed with integrity and attention to detail. It’s rare to find a company that delivers this level of service consistently. Highly recommend!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
7 months ago
Reviewed by Vinny Avalos
Great people very accommodating and fair with their leases. Nick was fantastic to work with very professional
reviewer image
1.0 star
|
7 months ago
Reviewed by Ruthann Simmons
I recently rented property from Bullet Property MANAGEMENT and from my experience they will do anything to scam you out of your money. Mattie and Shelby are not truthful and are only out to twist things around for their good and make up rules as they go along. I would not recommend doing business with this company. Scammers!! Where in my lease does it say you can charge $50 return fee when you are overpaid?
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 years ago
Reviewed by Diego Banuelos
As a first time owner looking to rent my property, I had many concerns. Soon after meeting the great team behind Bullet Property Management my worries quickly subsided and my confidence in renting out my home could not have been higher. From their great connection with local vendors and service providers to their in-depth connection with property owners and tenants alike, simply put I felt like I couldn’t be in better hands. I look forward to a long lasting and fruitful relationship with the team at Bullet Property Management, I would highly recommend them to any of my family and friends! 🤝
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 years ago
Reviewed by Richa Verma
I contracted with Bullet Property Management a few months back and my experience has been very positive. As a first time land lord, there were many unknowns. Nick and his team did a fantastic job of guiding me through the process and helping with key decisions. They are very professional, providing transparent and clear communication at every step. They secured new tenants quickly and handled the transition smoothly. I would highly recommend their property management services.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 years ago
Reviewed by Ethan Stout
I’ve had a fantastic experience with Bullet Property Management in Columbus, Indiana. Their team is highly professional, responsive, and truly cares about their tenants. From the moment I signed my lease, I knew I was in good hands. Maintenance requests are handled quickly, and they always communicate any updates or important information promptly. The entire process, from application to move-in, was seamless and stress-free. I highly recommend Bullet Property Management to anyone looking for a reliable and trustworthy property management company!

Our Team


Nick Rosenberg