Business Page
Bartomeo Property Management
Property Manager
4.7 stars
167 Reviews
Markets served
Estero, FL
Lehigh Acres, FL
North Fort Myers, FL
Matlacha, FL
Punta Gorda, FL
Matlacha Isles-Matlacha Shores, FL
Buckingham, FL
Fort Myers Shores, FL
Pine Island Center, FL
Bokeelia, FL
Saint James City, FL
Fort Myers Beach, FL
Sanibel, FL
Fort Myers Villas, FL
Bonita Springs, FL
Winter Springs, FL
Winter Haven, FL
San Carlos Park, FL
Fort Myers, FL
Cape Coral, FL
Licenses, Designations or Certificates
NARPM Member (National Association of Residential Property Managers) NAR (National Association of Realtors) Real Estate Broker Florida Real Estate Broker License: BK3467477 Florida License No.: CQ1060458
About us
What sets us apart? We were Full Time Investors before we became Property Managers and learned how to manage properties by making mistakes with our properties, so, we don't make mistakes on yours. We are a full-service property management company that utilizes our proven systems, strategies, and experience to provide the highest levels of customer service while ensuring the maximum profitability for our owners. Our company culture revolves around continuous improvement and striving to increase value and reduce costs.
Specialties
HUD/Section 8
Single-family/Townhouse/Condo
Small multi-family: 2-4 units
Large multi-family: 5-19 units
Large multi-family: 20-49 units
Large multi-family: 50-99 units
Large multi-family: 100+ units
Long-term rental: 12+ months
Single-family/Townhouse/Condo
Small multi-family: 2-4 units
Large multi-family: 5-19 units
Large multi-family: 20-49 units
Large multi-family: 50-99 units
Large multi-family: 100+ units
Reviews (167)
4.7 stars
167 Reviews
4.7 stars
167 Reviews
0.0 star
0 Reviews
1.0 star
Edited 4 days ago
Reviewed by
Mary Hodges
They seemed good at first. I believe the owner wants to have a good company that is reliable and worth while. So I hate doing this. We took good care of the property. Left the property in way better condition than we recieved it in- from the yard to the fixtures and the walls. We repaired and upgraded and fixed up so much. But we had to fight to get anything fixed that we couldn’t afford. Then we cleaned and paid a professional cleaner and changed the filter etc. They want to keep almost $300 of the deposit saying it wasn’t cleaned when we know they didn’t even look at it for a while after we moved out. Most of the issue was the dust blown in from the house we tried to get fixed and done over and over. When we moved in there were heroine needles in the toilet and it was so nasty.
Edit. Out move out date was the end of September. I called back per the comment on this review. I was told someone would call me back. No one ever reached out. I just got an email that I should get the deposit back in 3/5 days. For the wrong amount still. They didn’t fix it attempt to fix anything.
5.0 stars
a week ago
Reviewed by
Cynthia Sadler
Joel is awesome. We also love Cynthia & Kevin so much. They’ve always been more than helpful & kind to my husband & I.
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Juan Leon
Bartomeo Property Management has provided us with truly good service, distinguished by its high level of professionalism, integrity, commitment, and punctuality. Their reports are clear, thorough, and precise, allowing us to stay fully informed and enjoy complete peace of mind regarding the condition and management of our property.
Furthermore, their willingness to address any questions or concerns, combined with the promptness and quality of their responses, reflects an efficient and reliable approach that further strengthens our confidence in and satisfaction with their services.
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Andrea Young
I switched to Bartomeo and couldn't be happier. They are professional and reliable. They were able to find me a great tenant. I would absolutely recommend Bartomeo for your property management needs.
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Kimberly Ritter
We started wth Bartomeo Property Management a few years ago and it has been the BEST decision we have made.
We previously had another management company for our rental property that was so disappointing and frustrating. Since going to Bartomeo we don’t even think to worry. They are professional, reliable and just generally a pleasure to deal with.
They are prompt in answering all our emails and they are always updating us on what going on in the Florida area.
It was and is the best decision we have made !!!
We highly recommend them !!!!
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Rashid Coates
Adam, Jessica, and the team at Bartomeo Property Management have been a blessing to work with. They’ve managed my property for several years, with no vacancies or payment collection issues, and the tenants they’ve placed have taken good care of my home. Their hands on approach and attention to detail have made the Property Management experience seamless. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable property management company that handles every aspect of the process.
5.0 stars
2 months ago
Reviewed by
Joe Rosinski
Adam and His Team are extremely professional and easy to work with. They communicates clearly with both tenants and owners, so nothing falls through the cracks. They also know the Cape Coral market well and use that insight in a practical way, not just as talking points. Competent, responsive, and straightforward from start to finish. Highly recommend them as a property management vendor.
5.0 stars
3 months ago
Reviewed by
Shelly Bostick
I had a wonderful experience with this company. Adam and everyone on his team were absolutely wonderful to work with. They were professional and responsive and genuinely helpful. Any concerns or questions I had were handled quickly. I would absolutely recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable trustworthy rental management company.
5.0 stars
3 months ago
Reviewed by
Angel Gual
Adam and his team have been the easiest to work with. They are professional and worked quickly at getting our house rented out. They are easy to contact and answer all questions we had as first time renters. Their fees are lower than the others but provide premium service. We needed a few repairs to be done prior to placing the house for rent and their team took care of it for a much lower price than their competitors. If you have a house you want to rent out in the west side of Florida I highly suggest you contact them and see for yourself how great Adam and his team are for yourself.
5.0 stars
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Sharon Nelson
We have been with Bartomeo Property Management for approximately 2 years now. As an out-of-state property owner, it is always challenging to make a change to a new property manager as you need to rely on phone conversations and reviews. During our first call with Adam, we felt very confident that we had found our new property management company. Jessica made the process seamless in working with our prior management company to transition historical data and has been prompt in responding to any of our questions that we have had since onboarding. Since they have taken over the management, they have provided prompt service to reported maintenance issues and have been proactive on repairs found during the inspections. The last couple of years has had significant changes in the rental market and we have appreciated the market reports sent periodically.
1.0 star
Edited 4 days ago
Reviewed by
Mary Hodges
They seemed good at first. I believe the owner wants to have a good company that is reliable and worth while. So I hate doing this. We took good care of the property. Left the property in way better condition than we recieved it in- from the yard to the fixtures and the walls. We repaired and upgraded and fixed up so much. But we had to fight to get anything fixed that we couldn’t afford. Then we cleaned and paid a professional cleaner and changed the filter etc. They want to keep almost $300 of the deposit saying it wasn’t cleaned when we know they didn’t even look at it for a while after we moved out. Most of the issue was the dust blown in from the house we tried to get fixed and done over and over. When we moved in there were heroine needles in the toilet and it was so nasty.
Edit. Out move out date was the end of September. I called back per the comment on this review. I was told someone would call me back. No one ever reached out. I just got an email that I should get the deposit back in 3/5 days. For the wrong amount still. They didn’t fix it attempt to fix anything.
5.0 stars
a week ago
Reviewed by
Cynthia Sadler
Joel is awesome. We also love Cynthia & Kevin so much. They’ve always been more than helpful & kind to my husband & I.
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Juan Leon
Bartomeo Property Management has provided us with truly good service, distinguished by its high level of professionalism, integrity, commitment, and punctuality. Their reports are clear, thorough, and precise, allowing us to stay fully informed and enjoy complete peace of mind regarding the condition and management of our property.
Furthermore, their willingness to address any questions or concerns, combined with the promptness and quality of their responses, reflects an efficient and reliable approach that further strengthens our confidence in and satisfaction with their services.
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Andrea Young
I switched to Bartomeo and couldn't be happier. They are professional and reliable. They were able to find me a great tenant. I would absolutely recommend Bartomeo for your property management needs.
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Kimberly Ritter
We started wth Bartomeo Property Management a few years ago and it has been the BEST decision we have made.
We previously had another management company for our rental property that was so disappointing and frustrating. Since going to Bartomeo we don’t even think to worry. They are professional, reliable and just generally a pleasure to deal with.
They are prompt in answering all our emails and they are always updating us on what going on in the Florida area.
It was and is the best decision we have made !!!
We highly recommend them !!!!
5.0 stars
2 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Rashid Coates
Adam, Jessica, and the team at Bartomeo Property Management have been a blessing to work with. They’ve managed my property for several years, with no vacancies or payment collection issues, and the tenants they’ve placed have taken good care of my home. Their hands on approach and attention to detail have made the Property Management experience seamless. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable property management company that handles every aspect of the process.
5.0 stars
2 months ago
Reviewed by
Joe Rosinski
Adam and His Team are extremely professional and easy to work with. They communicates clearly with both tenants and owners, so nothing falls through the cracks. They also know the Cape Coral market well and use that insight in a practical way, not just as talking points. Competent, responsive, and straightforward from start to finish. Highly recommend them as a property management vendor.
5.0 stars
3 months ago
Reviewed by
Shelly Bostick
I had a wonderful experience with this company. Adam and everyone on his team were absolutely wonderful to work with. They were professional and responsive and genuinely helpful. Any concerns or questions I had were handled quickly. I would absolutely recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable trustworthy rental management company.
5.0 stars
3 months ago
Reviewed by
Angel Gual
Adam and his team have been the easiest to work with. They are professional and worked quickly at getting our house rented out. They are easy to contact and answer all questions we had as first time renters. Their fees are lower than the others but provide premium service. We needed a few repairs to be done prior to placing the house for rent and their team took care of it for a much lower price than their competitors. If you have a house you want to rent out in the west side of Florida I highly suggest you contact them and see for yourself how great Adam and his team are for yourself.
5.0 stars
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Sharon Nelson
We have been with Bartomeo Property Management for approximately 2 years now. As an out-of-state property owner, it is always challenging to make a change to a new property manager as you need to rely on phone conversations and reviews. During our first call with Adam, we felt very confident that we had found our new property management company. Jessica made the process seamless in working with our prior management company to transition historical data and has been prompt in responding to any of our questions that we have had since onboarding. Since they have taken over the management, they have provided prompt service to reported maintenance issues and have been proactive on repairs found during the inspections. The last couple of years has had significant changes in the rental market and we have appreciated the market reports sent periodically.