Business Page
Bartomeo Property Management
Property Manager
4.7 stars
146 Reviews
Markets served
Estero, FL
Buckingham, FL
Fort Myers Shores, FL
Bonita Springs, FL
North Fort Myers, FL
Pine Island Center, FL
Bokeelia, FL
Saint James City, FL
Fort Myers Beach, FL
San Carlos Park, FL
Fort Myers, FL
Sanibel, FL
Cape Coral, FL
Matlacha, FL
Punta Gorda, FL
Lehigh Acres, FL
Matlacha Isles-Matlacha Shores, FL
Fort Myers Villas, FL
Licenses, Designations or Certificates
NARPM Member (National Association of Residential Property Managers) NAR (National Association of Realtors) Real Estate Broker Florida Real Estate Broker License: BK3467477 Florida License No.: CQ1060458
About us
What sets us apart? We were Full Time Investors before we became Property Managers and learned how to manage properties by making mistakes with our properties, so, we don't make mistakes on yours. We are a full-service property management company that utilizes our proven systems, strategies, and experience to provide the highest levels of customer service while ensuring the maximum profitability for our owners. Our company culture revolves around continuous improvement and striving to increase value and reduce costs.
Specialties
HUD/Section 8
Single-family/Townhouse/Condo
Small multi-family: 2-4 units
Large multi-family: 5-19 units
Large multi-family: 20-49 units
Large multi-family: 50-99 units
Large multi-family: 100+ units
Long-term rental: 12+ months
Single-family/Townhouse/Condo
Small multi-family: 2-4 units
Large multi-family: 5-19 units
Large multi-family: 20-49 units
Large multi-family: 50-99 units
Large multi-family: 100+ units
Reviews (146)
4.7 stars
146 Reviews
4.7 stars
146 Reviews
0.0 star
0 Reviews
5.0 stars
3 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Annie Quimby
I’ve had a great experience working with Bartomeo Property Management. They are truly a top-notch operator. One of the biggest advantages is that they often already have qualified tenants ready before a property is even listed, which keeps occupancy high and minimizes vacancy time. They’ve consistently helped place good tenants quickly and efficiently. Adam, Jessica, and Cindy are all wonderful to work with — professional, honest, responsive, and easy to reach by email or phone. They genuinely care about both landlords and tenants, and they take great care of the properties. They also provide access to a qualified handyman at a very reasonable hourly rate, which has been extremely helpful. I’ve had Amazon and Home Depot items shipped directly for installation and everything was scheduled and handled smoothly. I highly recommend Bartomeo Property Management to any landlord looking for a reliable, professional property management team.
1.0 star
a month ago
Reviewed by
Joshua De los reyes
I am a currently living at one of the properties this company has taking over. I second my neighbors review on this page. We to are also breaking our lease and not paying due to having multiple repairs not being fixed. Takes over a month for RDG to get someone out to help fix with maintenance issues and they still have yet to (actually fix it). We have had over 7 other neighbors break their lease in less the a year at this property.Ontop of the large late fees they dont tell you about when you sign you lease. This new company is very unprofessional aswell.We have already packed up our entire unit and are leaving the state after our eviction. Dont trust these people.
1.0 star
a month ago
Reviewed by
Kasidy Chapman
Went into check out there units available, all of them were full of dead german cockroaches all over the floors and inside cabnets, and this was over four units i toured, all full of dead roaches . They did not bother to clean before showing units. This place will also charge a 300$ late fee everytime you are late on rent. Highly recommend you find a different professional company to rent from. Very rude people.
5.0 stars
a month ago
Reviewed by
Craig
The team at Bartomeo Property Management and Realty has been great to work with. They handle everything for our two local rentals, get them rented fast, and are quick to take care of any tenant issues. I’d definitely recommend them if you’re looking for a solid property management company.
5.0 stars
2 months ago
Reviewed by
Chintan Sheth
I switched to Bartomeo from another PM and have had an amazing experience so far! They’re truly professionals and experts in their fields. I had issues with a tenant from the previous PM and Bartomeo got everything sorted out for me. Their communication is excellent and it’s so refreshing to get a response to questions in just a couple of minutes. Adam and Jess are an awesome team! Highly recommend them!
5.0 stars
2 months ago
Reviewed by
Prudence Meads
After a difficult experience with my previous property management company, hiring Bartomeo Property Management has been a significant upgrade. They are attentive, communicative, and honest—no sugarcoating, just clear information and practical solutions, which I truly value as an owner. Jessica, my primary contact, has been outstanding. I have a particularly challenging tenant, and she has gone to great lengths to manage the situation professionally, patiently, and thoroughly while keeping me well informed every step of the way. It is clear she genuinely cares about doing things the right way. I’m very grateful for her efforts and for a management company that follows through! Highly recommend.
5.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Bill Johnson
Hi, this is Billy Johnson. I got this company to help me with a rental property that I have. They’ve been on point on everything everything they promised they achieve. It was wonderful working with Adam and Jess. They are perfect. Management company , the whole team is excellent so don’t hesitate. Contact them if you need anything in this field they are truly five stars thanks
😊
5.0 stars
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Sri Venuguntla
I had a great experience with Bartomeo Property Management. The team was highly committed and worked diligently to help me find a tenant very quickly. Their constant follow-ups and clear communication made the process smooth and stress-free. I truly appreciate their dedication and professionalism. Highly recommend their services!
5.0 stars
3 weeks ago
Reviewed by
Annie Quimby
I’ve had a great experience working with Bartomeo Property Management. They are truly a top-notch operator. One of the biggest advantages is that they often already have qualified tenants ready before a property is even listed, which keeps occupancy high and minimizes vacancy time. They’ve consistently helped place good tenants quickly and efficiently. Adam, Jessica, and Cindy are all wonderful to work with — professional, honest, responsive, and easy to reach by email or phone. They genuinely care about both landlords and tenants, and they take great care of the properties. They also provide access to a qualified handyman at a very reasonable hourly rate, which has been extremely helpful. I’ve had Amazon and Home Depot items shipped directly for installation and everything was scheduled and handled smoothly. I highly recommend Bartomeo Property Management to any landlord looking for a reliable, professional property management team.
1.0 star
a month ago
Reviewed by
Joshua De los reyes
I am a currently living at one of the properties this company has taking over. I second my neighbors review on this page. We to are also breaking our lease and not paying due to having multiple repairs not being fixed. Takes over a month for RDG to get someone out to help fix with maintenance issues and they still have yet to (actually fix it). We have had over 7 other neighbors break their lease in less the a year at this property.Ontop of the large late fees they dont tell you about when you sign you lease. This new company is very unprofessional aswell.We have already packed up our entire unit and are leaving the state after our eviction. Dont trust these people.
1.0 star
a month ago
Reviewed by
Kasidy Chapman
Went into check out there units available, all of them were full of dead german cockroaches all over the floors and inside cabnets, and this was over four units i toured, all full of dead roaches . They did not bother to clean before showing units. This place will also charge a 300$ late fee everytime you are late on rent. Highly recommend you find a different professional company to rent from. Very rude people.
5.0 stars
a month ago
Reviewed by
Craig
The team at Bartomeo Property Management and Realty has been great to work with. They handle everything for our two local rentals, get them rented fast, and are quick to take care of any tenant issues. I’d definitely recommend them if you’re looking for a solid property management company.
5.0 stars
2 months ago
Reviewed by
Chintan Sheth
I switched to Bartomeo from another PM and have had an amazing experience so far! They’re truly professionals and experts in their fields. I had issues with a tenant from the previous PM and Bartomeo got everything sorted out for me. Their communication is excellent and it’s so refreshing to get a response to questions in just a couple of minutes. Adam and Jess are an awesome team! Highly recommend them!
5.0 stars
2 months ago
Reviewed by
Prudence Meads
After a difficult experience with my previous property management company, hiring Bartomeo Property Management has been a significant upgrade. They are attentive, communicative, and honest—no sugarcoating, just clear information and practical solutions, which I truly value as an owner. Jessica, my primary contact, has been outstanding. I have a particularly challenging tenant, and she has gone to great lengths to manage the situation professionally, patiently, and thoroughly while keeping me well informed every step of the way. It is clear she genuinely cares about doing things the right way. I’m very grateful for her efforts and for a management company that follows through! Highly recommend.
5.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Bill Johnson
Hi, this is Billy Johnson. I got this company to help me with a rental property that I have. They’ve been on point on everything everything they promised they achieve. It was wonderful working with Adam and Jess. They are perfect. Management company , the whole team is excellent so don’t hesitate. Contact them if you need anything in this field they are truly five stars thanks
😊
5.0 stars
6 months ago
Reviewed by
Sri Venuguntla
I had a great experience with Bartomeo Property Management. The team was highly committed and worked diligently to help me find a tenant very quickly. Their constant follow-ups and clear communication made the process smooth and stress-free. I truly appreciate their dedication and professionalism. Highly recommend their services!