Unfortunately, I can't give them zero star, which they don't even deserve. I would never trust Bartomeo Property Management with another property. During the time they managed my duplex, no routine inspections were ever conducted even I asked them several time to conduct inspections, and after one of the tenants moved out I discovered damage to the refrigerator, vinyl plank flooring, microwave, and other parts of the property that should have been identified much earlier. Instead of repairing this mess, they decided to move out and created a bunch of false charges after having decided to terminate the contract. Throughout the process, I had to repeatedly request financial records and question charges instead of receiving a transparent final accounting. As an owner, I expected professionalism, accountability, and protection of my investment. Unfortunately, I received the opposite. Based on my experience, I have filed a complaint with the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation and cannot recommend Bartomeo Property Management to any property owner.

If I could give Bartomeo Property Management more than 5 stars, I absolutely would. I have owned my condo for a few short years, and let me tell you... I have seen both sides of property management. Before finding Bartomeo, I went through two back-to-back tenant nightmares that left me completely exhausted, discouraged, in financial distress, and honestly questioning whether being a landlord was even worth it anymore. By the time I found them, I was pretty jaded and probably a bit of a pain in the butt (sorry, y'all! 😅). But after everything I had been through, I just wanted someone I could actually trust. From day one, Adam and the team never made me feel like "just another property owner." They listened, answered my endless questions, kept me informed, and genuinely cared about protecting my investment as if it were their own. No matter what came up, I always felt comfortable reaching out. They were patient, responsive, and always willing to explain things along the way. That level of communication and transparency meant more to me than I can put into words. Over the last year especially, something incredible happened...I stopped worrying! That may not sound like much to someone who has never owned a rental property, but to a landlord, that peace of mind is priceless. I didn't have to constantly wonder what was happening with my property, chase people down for updates, or brace myself for the next disaster. I could actually breathe knowing my condo was in capable hands. Their communication has been exceptional, they have handled situations professionally, and every interaction has reminded me why I chose them in the first place. One thing I also want prospective clients to keep in mind when reading reviews: every management company eventually has to make difficult decisions that not everyone likes. Enforcing leases, collecting rent, issuing notices, or holding tenants accountable isn't always popular. Unfortunately, that can sometimes lead to emotional or even misleading reviews from people who were never actual clients of the management company or who simply didn't get the outcome they wanted. I encourage you to look beyond those and focus on the experiences of owners who have actually entrusted them with one of their biggest investments. Property management isn't just collecting rent. It's communication, integrity, professionalism, problem-solving, and protecting someone else's home and financial future. Adam and the Bartomeo Team understand that. Thank you for giving me something I didn't realize I had been missing for so long: confidence and peace of mind! You took an incredibly stressful chapter of my life and turned it into one where I could finally sleep at night knowing my property was being cared for properly! I recommend Bartomeo Property Management without hesitation, and I am incredibly grateful for everything you've done!

I am highly displeased with our three-year experience with this management company. We moved into a dirty home that was already infested with rats and littered with dead roaches in the cabinets. Despite the fact that pest control was involved for two and a half years of our tenancy, management failed to ever actually resolve the rodent issue. Dealing with an ongoing pest problem for years while paying rent is entirely unacceptable. Now that we have moved out, the company is attempting to enforce a standard cleaning fee and charging us for items we never had. We documented the initial filth with photos and videos, which we provided as proof. Shockingly, management has admitted they have no records or documentation proving the home was cleaned before we arrived, yet they still refuse to drop the charges or reimburse us. This company expects tenants to pay for their lack of oversight and preparation. I strongly advise prospective renters to look elsewhere if they value cleanliness, honesty, and professional communication.

I have been renting with Bartomeo for the last 5 years. Due to my family expanding I am now moving! I could go on and on about this company and how great it’s truly been to rent with them. During Hurricane Ian they made sure I was taken care of and I will always be thankful for that! It’s very bittersweet leaving this place I’ve made home but I just want to say thank you to everyone at Bartomeo !!! Thank you so much for a great 5 years !

I cannot recommend Bartomeo Property Management and Realty highly enough! After dealing with other property management companies that left our property sitting vacant for months without a single result, switching to Bartomeo was the best decision we ever made. From the very beginning, Adam and Jessica have been absolutely incredible to work with. They are hands-down the best in the business! They are extremely responsive and take the time to answer every single one of my questions, no matter how small. I highly recommend Bartomeo!

We have been with Bartomeo Property Management for approximately 2 years now. As an out-of-state property owner, it is always challenging to make a change to a new property manager as you need to rely on phone conversations and reviews. During our first call with Adam, we felt very confident that we had found our new property management company. Jessica made the process seamless in working with our prior management company to transition historical data and has been prompt in responding to any of our questions that we have had since onboarding. Since they have taken over the management, they have provided prompt service to reported maintenance issues and have been proactive on repairs found during the inspections. The last couple of years has had significant changes in the rental market and we have appreciated the market reports sent periodically.

I have been with Bartomeo property management for a few years now and Adam, Jessica, and everyone else have been fantastic. I own 6 properties across the country and Bartomeo operates the best. Every fix needed has an accompanying picture, explanation, and receipt. The team is responsive and have always found a tenant quickly. I will continue to use them for years to come

My company transferred me from Colorado to Cape Coral for work, I was put in a position where I need to find a place to rent site unseen. Luckily I came across Bartomeo Property Management. I called in and explained my situation after finding an apartment I liked on their website. I was assured they would be able to take care of me. Shortly after I received a call from their agent, Haley. She again reassured me that my situation was not a problem, and immediately scheduled a video call to show me the apartment on a walk through. It's hard to explain in text, but she was looking through the apartment the way I would. She was opening closets, looking through cabinets, and commenting on different things she noticed in the place. Not just positive things, but ways I could make it better. She even filled me in on what the neighborhood was like. After the virtual walk through, I was sold because it was exactly what I was looking for: Comfortable, clean, safe and affordable. Haley stayed engaged, following up as necessary and making herself available as the process was taken over by Jamie. Jamie helped me by clearly letting me know what needed to happen on my end to secure the place: taking over water and utilities, deposit, and first months rent. They have an app that made the process as easy as it can be to upload documents and paystubs. My arrival date ended up falling on a Sunday. Jamie even gave me her personal number, just in case there was an issue on moving day (there wasn't). I have been in the apartment now nearly a month. Everything works as it should, it's clean, it's safe, it's quiet, there are no bugs or pests, it's not haunted (inside joke), and I couldn't be happier with the place. Thank you Haley, Jamie, and the team at Bartomeo for making a daunting task as painless and easy as possible!

Unfortunately, I can't give them zero star, which they don't even deserve. I would never trust Bartomeo Property Management with another property. During the time they managed my duplex, no routine inspections were ever conducted even I asked them several time to conduct inspections, and after one of the tenants moved out I discovered damage to the refrigerator, vinyl plank flooring, microwave, and other parts of the property that should have been identified much earlier. Instead of repairing this mess, they decided to move out and created a bunch of false charges after having decided to terminate the contract. Throughout the process, I had to repeatedly request financial records and question charges instead of receiving a transparent final accounting. As an owner, I expected professionalism, accountability, and protection of my investment. Unfortunately, I received the opposite. Based on my experience, I have filed a complaint with the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation and cannot recommend Bartomeo Property Management to any property owner.

If I could give Bartomeo Property Management more than 5 stars, I absolutely would. I have owned my condo for a few short years, and let me tell you... I have seen both sides of property management. Before finding Bartomeo, I went through two back-to-back tenant nightmares that left me completely exhausted, discouraged, in financial distress, and honestly questioning whether being a landlord was even worth it anymore. By the time I found them, I was pretty jaded and probably a bit of a pain in the butt (sorry, y'all! 😅). But after everything I had been through, I just wanted someone I could actually trust. From day one, Adam and the team never made me feel like "just another property owner." They listened, answered my endless questions, kept me informed, and genuinely cared about protecting my investment as if it were their own. No matter what came up, I always felt comfortable reaching out. They were patient, responsive, and always willing to explain things along the way. That level of communication and transparency meant more to me than I can put into words. Over the last year especially, something incredible happened...I stopped worrying! That may not sound like much to someone who has never owned a rental property, but to a landlord, that peace of mind is priceless. I didn't have to constantly wonder what was happening with my property, chase people down for updates, or brace myself for the next disaster. I could actually breathe knowing my condo was in capable hands. Their communication has been exceptional, they have handled situations professionally, and every interaction has reminded me why I chose them in the first place. One thing I also want prospective clients to keep in mind when reading reviews: every management company eventually has to make difficult decisions that not everyone likes. Enforcing leases, collecting rent, issuing notices, or holding tenants accountable isn't always popular. Unfortunately, that can sometimes lead to emotional or even misleading reviews from people who were never actual clients of the management company or who simply didn't get the outcome they wanted. I encourage you to look beyond those and focus on the experiences of owners who have actually entrusted them with one of their biggest investments. Property management isn't just collecting rent. It's communication, integrity, professionalism, problem-solving, and protecting someone else's home and financial future. Adam and the Bartomeo Team understand that. Thank you for giving me something I didn't realize I had been missing for so long: confidence and peace of mind! You took an incredibly stressful chapter of my life and turned it into one where I could finally sleep at night knowing my property was being cared for properly! I recommend Bartomeo Property Management without hesitation, and I am incredibly grateful for everything you've done!

I am highly displeased with our three-year experience with this management company. We moved into a dirty home that was already infested with rats and littered with dead roaches in the cabinets. Despite the fact that pest control was involved for two and a half years of our tenancy, management failed to ever actually resolve the rodent issue. Dealing with an ongoing pest problem for years while paying rent is entirely unacceptable. Now that we have moved out, the company is attempting to enforce a standard cleaning fee and charging us for items we never had. We documented the initial filth with photos and videos, which we provided as proof. Shockingly, management has admitted they have no records or documentation proving the home was cleaned before we arrived, yet they still refuse to drop the charges or reimburse us. This company expects tenants to pay for their lack of oversight and preparation. I strongly advise prospective renters to look elsewhere if they value cleanliness, honesty, and professional communication.

I have been renting with Bartomeo for the last 5 years. Due to my family expanding I am now moving! I could go on and on about this company and how great it’s truly been to rent with them. During Hurricane Ian they made sure I was taken care of and I will always be thankful for that! It’s very bittersweet leaving this place I’ve made home but I just want to say thank you to everyone at Bartomeo !!! Thank you so much for a great 5 years !

I cannot recommend Bartomeo Property Management and Realty highly enough! After dealing with other property management companies that left our property sitting vacant for months without a single result, switching to Bartomeo was the best decision we ever made. From the very beginning, Adam and Jessica have been absolutely incredible to work with. They are hands-down the best in the business! They are extremely responsive and take the time to answer every single one of my questions, no matter how small. I highly recommend Bartomeo!

We have been with Bartomeo Property Management for approximately 2 years now. As an out-of-state property owner, it is always challenging to make a change to a new property manager as you need to rely on phone conversations and reviews. During our first call with Adam, we felt very confident that we had found our new property management company. Jessica made the process seamless in working with our prior management company to transition historical data and has been prompt in responding to any of our questions that we have had since onboarding. Since they have taken over the management, they have provided prompt service to reported maintenance issues and have been proactive on repairs found during the inspections. The last couple of years has had significant changes in the rental market and we have appreciated the market reports sent periodically.

I have been with Bartomeo property management for a few years now and Adam, Jessica, and everyone else have been fantastic. I own 6 properties across the country and Bartomeo operates the best. Every fix needed has an accompanying picture, explanation, and receipt. The team is responsive and have always found a tenant quickly. I will continue to use them for years to come

My company transferred me from Colorado to Cape Coral for work, I was put in a position where I need to find a place to rent site unseen. Luckily I came across Bartomeo Property Management. I called in and explained my situation after finding an apartment I liked on their website. I was assured they would be able to take care of me. Shortly after I received a call from their agent, Haley. She again reassured me that my situation was not a problem, and immediately scheduled a video call to show me the apartment on a walk through. It's hard to explain in text, but she was looking through the apartment the way I would. She was opening closets, looking through cabinets, and commenting on different things she noticed in the place. Not just positive things, but ways I could make it better. She even filled me in on what the neighborhood was like. After the virtual walk through, I was sold because it was exactly what I was looking for: Comfortable, clean, safe and affordable. Haley stayed engaged, following up as necessary and making herself available as the process was taken over by Jamie. Jamie helped me by clearly letting me know what needed to happen on my end to secure the place: taking over water and utilities, deposit, and first months rent. They have an app that made the process as easy as it can be to upload documents and paystubs. My arrival date ended up falling on a Sunday. Jamie even gave me her personal number, just in case there was an issue on moving day (there wasn't). I have been in the apartment now nearly a month. Everything works as it should, it's clean, it's safe, it's quiet, there are no bugs or pests, it's not haunted (inside joke), and I couldn't be happier with the place. Thank you Haley, Jamie, and the team at Bartomeo for making a daunting task as painless and easy as possible!