Always have good experiences with them! Shout out to Matthew Hurrle who was very kind and professional when they did our semi- annual property evaluation. Thank you so much!

I was renting a house through this company for 2 years, when I received the house the vertical blind in the kitchen was missing 2 or 3 slats (sitting on the floor) and I took a picture of it the same day I moved in, when I left the property 2 years later they charged me $66 for that and also the garbage disposal was working just fine with no problem when I left the property, and they charged me $190 to replace it, on top of that they charged me another $170 for their commute to the property to do these stuff, I filed a dispute for my security deposit and sent them my pictures and it’s almost 2 months now and they keep telling me at the end of this week we will let you know the result and they haven’t done anything about it. It looks like they’re just looking for any way to charge you, Don’t recommend this property management to anyone.

I'm a new T&H customer, and I have been so impressed by the team at T&H Realty (in particular, Kristina Swatts and Nathan White). They each have taken ownership of so many things for me, they have stepped up to guide me through acquisition and transitioning my properties for rent, they are each so responsive to me when I reach out or have questions, and they've gone above and beyond in so many other ways more than I could have asked for or expected. As a remote investor in the area, this is the dream setup. The T&H team really "get it". Excited to continue on this journey with them!

Corbin Whitney came to my house I rent through T&H Realty for a lease renewal inspection. He was friendly and personable. I felt comfortable having him in my home. He told me what to expect from the inspection and helped me identify repairs and safety issues that should be addressed and what time frame to expect them to be addressed. I was very impressed with his help!

I would NOT recommend renting from this company. We rented from them for 4 years and passed every annual inspection with no issues — including on the carpets and the "dog smell" they later claimed. When we moved in, the carpets were already so thin and worn that we didn't even bother complaining, especially since we had a dog and figured some wear was inevitable. Four years later, they 100% needed replacing anyway — but when we asked for proof of the carpets' age (since they clearly weren't new when we moved in), they refused to provide it. Some of the other charges were clearly the same pattern repeating — our own move-in report proves it. The garage light and the damaged bottom of the stove were both documented as pre-existing damage when we moved in, yet we were still charged for them at move-out. In the stove's case, it's worse than just re-charging us: instead of actually repairing it, the repair company simply screwed the damaged bottom panel back into the warmer drawer and charged us for a full replacement — meaning the next tenant will likely get charged for the same "repair" again, while the actual homeowner is still stuck with a broken stove. I've seen the new listing photos advertising this home after we moved out, and the same stove damage is visible in them. This proves the company isn't just scamming tenants — they're scamming the property owners too, pocketing repair charges while doing little or nothing. After they withheld a large chunk of our deposit, we filed a dispute. It took them months to respond, and even after we provided our move-in report proving the damage was pre-existing, they still refused to refund us — telling us six months after we moved out that they "couldn't provide proof" but weren't giving the money back anyway. So the move-in inspection, the dispute process, all of it, was essentially pointless. We were good tenants. I even went back to clean the unit when I should have been recovering from emergency surgery. If this is how they treat tenants who did everything right, I can only imagine what they charge people who actually leave damage and a mess behind. If you want to actually get your deposit back, don't bother with their dispute process — they will string you along for months and still refuse to pay. Go straight to small claims court, and bring your move-in and move-out inspection reports with you. That documentation is the only leverage you'll have.

Do not recommend renting through this company. Save your time and your security deposit because you will not be getting it back. Communication has always been lackluster and they will charge you for every single little spec of dust they find after you move out. We have paid rent on time every single month for the entire duration of the lease and only needed one repair. The repair was for a damaged sink that they also decided to charge over 500$ for. They dont schedule a time for maintenance and they told the plumbers that the property was vacant at the time and it was not. They decided to charge us a $350 cleaning fee at move out after spending multiple hours cleaning and following their provided checklist . Most of the charges they decided was our fault was absolutely ridiculous like aged paint and a lightbulb that wasnt the same color as the rest of the house. They claim to provide you with a move in evaluation that they conduct at move in and we never got ours and yet were still charged a ludicrous amount of money. They say they take security deposits seriously but they just end up taking them all together! Dont waste your time or money

Terri has been an amazing asset! I am investing from out of state and she made the process seamless. The market has been challenging to find a property to meet my criteria. It took months. Terri did not check out on me. She stayed consistent and get me to the finish line. I am now an owner in IN!

I just recently moved from a property through this company. When I moved in there was a 2,100.00 required deposit along with 1st months rent. I just received what deposit they sent back and they ended up only giving me 410.00 back out of the 2,100.00 1.) I had my usual landscaping company come out the day before I moved to make sure the yard was mowed and in great condition (150.00); they charged me $450.00 for yard maintenance!!! 2.) I hired a cleaning service to do a move out clean the day before I returned the keys. Paying them 350.00 (also leaving a receipt for proof); they charged me $200.00 3.) $45.00 to “reinstall fridge drawers after fridge was cleaned”??? I cleaned the fridge out myself. Removing all drawers and shelves and replacing them. 4.) $95.00 because the bathroom sink “pop up stopper” wasn’t holding water? 5.) $85.00 to replace blinds that were INSIDE of the shower which for obvious reasons collected scale from water, soap, and moisture. Upon other charges. All totaling up to 1,790.00 Had I known despite showing proof of landscaping and move out clean being done, I would still be charged HUNDREDS of dollars for them to “do it again”, I would have saved my money to begin with and just let them take it out of my deposit. I’m furious. No way does replacing blinds cost $85.00. No way did it cost $450 to do what had already been done to the yard! A pop up sink stopper $95?!!? Never will I ever refer this company to anyone! What a complete rip off!!

Corbin Whitney, was excellent in his approach to making me Dana Dobbins feel relax. Corbin was very informative on the importance of keeping my furnace filter change out to a new filter when needing change. He was so courteous and patient with me. Also the repairs perform around gutters between gutters and the roof were done excellently and very quickly, very attentive Contractor and punctural and super polite...

RUN AWAY! LEARN FROM OUR MISTAKE AND TAKE THE BAD REVIEWS SERIOUSLY. Our experience with T&H has been EXTREMLY disappointing. Throughout our tenancy, maintenance requests often went unanswered for weeks or MONTHS. We had requests that have been open since LAST February, including safety concerns like nails sticking out of the flooring. Issues like this should never take months to address. Communication has also been incredibly disorganized. Emails often go unanswered, and when we do receive a response, no one seems to know what anyone else is doing. While trying to coordinate our move-out, we received multiple duplicate emails but no clear answers to basic questions. What has been most concerning is the move-out process. We have been presented with charges for damages and other items that were not caused by us. We had a feeling this was coming due to how horrible the past year has been. The process feels extremely opaque and raises serious concerns about how tenants are being billed. We have been respectful, responsible tenants and expected the same level of professionalism in return. Unfortunately, that has not been our experience. Unless you have a legal team in your corner who is willing to help you fight for maintence requests to be handled and getting your security depsoit back we’d highly encourage to rent elsewhere.

Always have good experiences with them! Shout out to Matthew Hurrle who was very kind and professional when they did our semi- annual property evaluation. Thank you so much!

I was renting a house through this company for 2 years, when I received the house the vertical blind in the kitchen was missing 2 or 3 slats (sitting on the floor) and I took a picture of it the same day I moved in, when I left the property 2 years later they charged me $66 for that and also the garbage disposal was working just fine with no problem when I left the property, and they charged me $190 to replace it, on top of that they charged me another $170 for their commute to the property to do these stuff, I filed a dispute for my security deposit and sent them my pictures and it’s almost 2 months now and they keep telling me at the end of this week we will let you know the result and they haven’t done anything about it. It looks like they’re just looking for any way to charge you, Don’t recommend this property management to anyone.

I'm a new T&H customer, and I have been so impressed by the team at T&H Realty (in particular, Kristina Swatts and Nathan White). They each have taken ownership of so many things for me, they have stepped up to guide me through acquisition and transitioning my properties for rent, they are each so responsive to me when I reach out or have questions, and they've gone above and beyond in so many other ways more than I could have asked for or expected. As a remote investor in the area, this is the dream setup. The T&H team really "get it". Excited to continue on this journey with them!

Corbin Whitney came to my house I rent through T&H Realty for a lease renewal inspection. He was friendly and personable. I felt comfortable having him in my home. He told me what to expect from the inspection and helped me identify repairs and safety issues that should be addressed and what time frame to expect them to be addressed. I was very impressed with his help!

I would NOT recommend renting from this company. We rented from them for 4 years and passed every annual inspection with no issues — including on the carpets and the "dog smell" they later claimed. When we moved in, the carpets were already so thin and worn that we didn't even bother complaining, especially since we had a dog and figured some wear was inevitable. Four years later, they 100% needed replacing anyway — but when we asked for proof of the carpets' age (since they clearly weren't new when we moved in), they refused to provide it. Some of the other charges were clearly the same pattern repeating — our own move-in report proves it. The garage light and the damaged bottom of the stove were both documented as pre-existing damage when we moved in, yet we were still charged for them at move-out. In the stove's case, it's worse than just re-charging us: instead of actually repairing it, the repair company simply screwed the damaged bottom panel back into the warmer drawer and charged us for a full replacement — meaning the next tenant will likely get charged for the same "repair" again, while the actual homeowner is still stuck with a broken stove. I've seen the new listing photos advertising this home after we moved out, and the same stove damage is visible in them. This proves the company isn't just scamming tenants — they're scamming the property owners too, pocketing repair charges while doing little or nothing. After they withheld a large chunk of our deposit, we filed a dispute. It took them months to respond, and even after we provided our move-in report proving the damage was pre-existing, they still refused to refund us — telling us six months after we moved out that they "couldn't provide proof" but weren't giving the money back anyway. So the move-in inspection, the dispute process, all of it, was essentially pointless. We were good tenants. I even went back to clean the unit when I should have been recovering from emergency surgery. If this is how they treat tenants who did everything right, I can only imagine what they charge people who actually leave damage and a mess behind. If you want to actually get your deposit back, don't bother with their dispute process — they will string you along for months and still refuse to pay. Go straight to small claims court, and bring your move-in and move-out inspection reports with you. That documentation is the only leverage you'll have.

Do not recommend renting through this company. Save your time and your security deposit because you will not be getting it back. Communication has always been lackluster and they will charge you for every single little spec of dust they find after you move out. We have paid rent on time every single month for the entire duration of the lease and only needed one repair. The repair was for a damaged sink that they also decided to charge over 500$ for. They dont schedule a time for maintenance and they told the plumbers that the property was vacant at the time and it was not. They decided to charge us a $350 cleaning fee at move out after spending multiple hours cleaning and following their provided checklist . Most of the charges they decided was our fault was absolutely ridiculous like aged paint and a lightbulb that wasnt the same color as the rest of the house. They claim to provide you with a move in evaluation that they conduct at move in and we never got ours and yet were still charged a ludicrous amount of money. They say they take security deposits seriously but they just end up taking them all together! Dont waste your time or money

Terri has been an amazing asset! I am investing from out of state and she made the process seamless. The market has been challenging to find a property to meet my criteria. It took months. Terri did not check out on me. She stayed consistent and get me to the finish line. I am now an owner in IN!

I just recently moved from a property through this company. When I moved in there was a 2,100.00 required deposit along with 1st months rent. I just received what deposit they sent back and they ended up only giving me 410.00 back out of the 2,100.00 1.) I had my usual landscaping company come out the day before I moved to make sure the yard was mowed and in great condition (150.00); they charged me $450.00 for yard maintenance!!! 2.) I hired a cleaning service to do a move out clean the day before I returned the keys. Paying them 350.00 (also leaving a receipt for proof); they charged me $200.00 3.) $45.00 to “reinstall fridge drawers after fridge was cleaned”??? I cleaned the fridge out myself. Removing all drawers and shelves and replacing them. 4.) $95.00 because the bathroom sink “pop up stopper” wasn’t holding water? 5.) $85.00 to replace blinds that were INSIDE of the shower which for obvious reasons collected scale from water, soap, and moisture. Upon other charges. All totaling up to 1,790.00 Had I known despite showing proof of landscaping and move out clean being done, I would still be charged HUNDREDS of dollars for them to “do it again”, I would have saved my money to begin with and just let them take it out of my deposit. I’m furious. No way does replacing blinds cost $85.00. No way did it cost $450 to do what had already been done to the yard! A pop up sink stopper $95?!!? Never will I ever refer this company to anyone! What a complete rip off!!

Corbin Whitney, was excellent in his approach to making me Dana Dobbins feel relax. Corbin was very informative on the importance of keeping my furnace filter change out to a new filter when needing change. He was so courteous and patient with me. Also the repairs perform around gutters between gutters and the roof were done excellently and very quickly, very attentive Contractor and punctural and super polite...

RUN AWAY! LEARN FROM OUR MISTAKE AND TAKE THE BAD REVIEWS SERIOUSLY. Our experience with T&H has been EXTREMLY disappointing. Throughout our tenancy, maintenance requests often went unanswered for weeks or MONTHS. We had requests that have been open since LAST February, including safety concerns like nails sticking out of the flooring. Issues like this should never take months to address. Communication has also been incredibly disorganized. Emails often go unanswered, and when we do receive a response, no one seems to know what anyone else is doing. While trying to coordinate our move-out, we received multiple duplicate emails but no clear answers to basic questions. What has been most concerning is the move-out process. We have been presented with charges for damages and other items that were not caused by us. We had a feeling this was coming due to how horrible the past year has been. The process feels extremely opaque and raises serious concerns about how tenants are being billed. We have been respectful, responsible tenants and expected the same level of professionalism in return. Unfortunately, that has not been our experience. Unless you have a legal team in your corner who is willing to help you fight for maintence requests to be handled and getting your security depsoit back we’d highly encourage to rent elsewhere.