Business Page
Residential Renters
Property Manager
4.8 stars
217 Reviews
Markets served
Wauwatosa, WI
Kenosha, WI
Milwaukee, WI
Whitefish Bay, WI
Grafton, WI
Cedarburg, WI
Greenfield, WI
Greendale, WI
Pewaukee, WI
Hartland, WI
Sheboygan, WI
Port Washington, WI
Saint Francis, WI
West Allis, WI
Fox Point, WI
Glendale, WI
Mequon, WI
Wales, WI
Racine, WI
Delafield, WI
New Berlin, WI
Licenses, Designations or Certificates
Property Management Consultants, Leasing Agents, Real Estate Investment Specialists
About us
Residential Renters helps Milwaukee-Area rental property owners secure ready, willing, and able renters through a dedicated leasing agent network and proven tenant placement systems. We specialize in connecting independent landlords, real estate investors, and property managers with qualified residents while reducing vacancy and protecting rental income. Unlike traditional property management models that rely on a single office leasing pipeline, Residential Renters operates through a collaborative network of experienced leasing agents and local housing professionals across Southeast Wisconsin. This network approach dramatically expands exposure for available rentals and helps match properties with qualified applicants faster and more effectively. Over the years, working alongside many landlords and property management companies throughout the Milwaukee market has given us a unique perspective on what works—and what doesn’t—when it comes to property management success. Our systems are designed to identify renters who are not only interested, but financially qualified and prepared to move forward. We typically work with independent landlords, growing investors, and property managers who want a more strategic approach to leasing. Some need help filling a vacancy quickly with a well-qualified tenant. Others want a trusted local resource that understands the Milwaukee rental market and can connect them with reliable leasing and management solutions. Our philosophy is simple: strong systems, qualified renters, and clear communication create better outcomes for everyone involved. Best rental practices. Best rental results.
Specialties
HUD/Section 8
Single-family/Townhouse/Condo
Small multi-family: 2-4 units
Large multi-family: 5-19 units
Long-term rental: 12+ months
Single-family/Townhouse/Condo
Small multi-family: 2-4 units
Large multi-family: 5-19 units
Other Property Management Services
Mid-term rental: 1-12 months
Reviews (217)
4.8 stars
217 Reviews
4.8 stars
217 Reviews
0.0 star
0 Reviews
5.0 stars
a month ago
Reviewed by
Sam Morris
Ben Jacobs was great to work with. Although didn’t go with one of his properties he was the most attentive and timely. Highly recommend.
5.0 stars
2 months ago
Reviewed by
Sydney Kratochwill
Working with this team is helpful and they are super responsive when making these big decisions to live within their properties & work with them. It may be normal to receive a few reoccurring text messages upon tour verification. These are real people, who do great business!
5.0 stars
2 months ago
Reviewed by
Monique Stevens
I met with Ben for a showing. I had called him and he called back me before. He was very nice and helpful! Once I got the showing, he gave a lot of information on the place, did a nice walk through and answered any questions. I went alone and was nervous and everything was very comfortable and informative. Thanks Ben!
3.0 stars
4 months ago
Reviewed by
Dale Pautzke
I am a condo owner having done business with Residential Renters for 11 years on a lease only basis. They used to be great. Now they pressure you to use their management services. If you don’t they treat you like they don’t want your business! They ask you to provide information such as details of previous lease agreements which they have created. Their comment is that they have no records of previous contacts since you are not paying them for management services. The inappropriate communication is totally from them due to their refusal to provide any cooperation if you do not hire them for management services!
5.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Courtney Munster
Worked with Ben to rent out my property and had a great experience! He was quick to answer any questions that I had, found tenants for me rather quickly and has been a continued source of valuable information with any questions after the initial rental process. Would definitely work with Ben again, and would definitely recommend him and Residental Renters to anyone looking for assistance with their properties.
4.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Jennifer Robinson
Initial experience with this management company was not ideal. I had sent out a request on a property one week ago and have not been able to get in contact with anyone. I had scheduled multiple showings, and had had three different showings canceled within hours of the appointment. It was a mess
I was finally able to get in contact with the owner of the company, Ben, who was an absolute doll and was able to smooth and iron everything out for us! We are even able to go check out the unit the same day with Faysal!! After the first initial technology hiccup, it was smooth sailing and I absolutely loved the way that they were willing to walk me through the propert, and be open about expectations and current processes.
Still going to remove a star though;
This is because I had reached out about this property -before- it had been signed by another prospect. I do feel that, had they reached out to me when I first initially inquired, I would have had a chance to rent the property.. I know how volatile the market is which is why I'm browsing for houses 3 to 5 hours everyday. Kind of sucks, but it is what it is. I really appreciate Ben and Faysal taking time out of their day though to help at least let us see the unit, and experience what could have been
5.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Lisa Brylow
I am so glad the property I applied for was being handled by Residential Renters! They took what can be a very stressful and time-consuming task and made it a smooth process. They are straightforward, honest and communicate in a timely manner. Great job Faysal!!
5.0 stars
8 months ago
Reviewed by
Erica Brown
As a mom with kids, I really appreciated working with Tommy at Residential Renters. He was knowledgeable, patient, and made sure we felt comfortable every step of the way. He took the time to understand our situation and helped accommodate our needs, which meant a lot to us.
It’s refreshing to work with someone who actually knows what they’re doing and genuinely cares. I’m grateful for the support and would absolutely recommend Tommy and the Residential Renters team.
5.0 stars
a month ago
Reviewed by
Sam Morris
Ben Jacobs was great to work with. Although didn’t go with one of his properties he was the most attentive and timely. Highly recommend.
5.0 stars
2 months ago
Reviewed by
Sydney Kratochwill
Working with this team is helpful and they are super responsive when making these big decisions to live within their properties & work with them. It may be normal to receive a few reoccurring text messages upon tour verification. These are real people, who do great business!
5.0 stars
2 months ago
Reviewed by
Monique Stevens
I met with Ben for a showing. I had called him and he called back me before. He was very nice and helpful! Once I got the showing, he gave a lot of information on the place, did a nice walk through and answered any questions. I went alone and was nervous and everything was very comfortable and informative. Thanks Ben!
3.0 stars
4 months ago
Reviewed by
Dale Pautzke
I am a condo owner having done business with Residential Renters for 11 years on a lease only basis. They used to be great. Now they pressure you to use their management services. If you don’t they treat you like they don’t want your business! They ask you to provide information such as details of previous lease agreements which they have created. Their comment is that they have no records of previous contacts since you are not paying them for management services. The inappropriate communication is totally from them due to their refusal to provide any cooperation if you do not hire them for management services!
5.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Courtney Munster
Worked with Ben to rent out my property and had a great experience! He was quick to answer any questions that I had, found tenants for me rather quickly and has been a continued source of valuable information with any questions after the initial rental process. Would definitely work with Ben again, and would definitely recommend him and Residental Renters to anyone looking for assistance with their properties.
4.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Jennifer Robinson
Initial experience with this management company was not ideal. I had sent out a request on a property one week ago and have not been able to get in contact with anyone. I had scheduled multiple showings, and had had three different showings canceled within hours of the appointment. It was a mess
I was finally able to get in contact with the owner of the company, Ben, who was an absolute doll and was able to smooth and iron everything out for us! We are even able to go check out the unit the same day with Faysal!! After the first initial technology hiccup, it was smooth sailing and I absolutely loved the way that they were willing to walk me through the propert, and be open about expectations and current processes.
Still going to remove a star though;
This is because I had reached out about this property -before- it had been signed by another prospect. I do feel that, had they reached out to me when I first initially inquired, I would have had a chance to rent the property.. I know how volatile the market is which is why I'm browsing for houses 3 to 5 hours everyday. Kind of sucks, but it is what it is. I really appreciate Ben and Faysal taking time out of their day though to help at least let us see the unit, and experience what could have been
5.0 stars
5 months ago
Reviewed by
Lisa Brylow
I am so glad the property I applied for was being handled by Residential Renters! They took what can be a very stressful and time-consuming task and made it a smooth process. They are straightforward, honest and communicate in a timely manner. Great job Faysal!!
5.0 stars
8 months ago
Reviewed by
Erica Brown
As a mom with kids, I really appreciated working with Tommy at Residential Renters. He was knowledgeable, patient, and made sure we felt comfortable every step of the way. He took the time to understand our situation and helped accommodate our needs, which meant a lot to us.
It’s refreshing to work with someone who actually knows what they’re doing and genuinely cares. I’m grateful for the support and would absolutely recommend Tommy and the Residential Renters team.