Investor-friendly real estate agents in Fishers, IN

8 agents in the BiggerPockets network work with investors in Fishers, Indiana and the towns around it: Carmel, Indianapolis, Noblesville, and Zionsville. Between them they hold 76 reviews from BiggerPockets members. If you are looking for a real estate agent for investors in Hamilton County, start with the list below.

Updated November 2026 · Strategies these agents work: fix & flip, land, long-term rental, mid-term rental, mobile home parks, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, primary residence, self-storage, short-term rental, single-family rental, townhouse/condo

Free to use, no obligation to sign.

The agents

1PS
Peter Stewart
Peter Stewart Realty · Fishers, IN
5.0(54 reviews)·160 forum posts
View profile
- Residential
- Fix & flip
- Land
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- New Construction
- Primary Residence
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
- Townhouse/Condo
Peter Stewart is a Fishers, IN agent rated 5.0 from 54 BiggerPockets member reviews, who specializes in fix & flip, land, multi-family (2-4 units), new construction, primary residence, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.
Indianapolis native and full-time real estate broker since 2009, I specialize in helping out-of-state investors navigate smooth and successful transactions in the Indianapolis metro area. As an active investor since 2011, with properties in multiple states, I bring a unique perspective from both sides of the deal—offering practical insights as both an agent and investor. Whether you’re buying or selling, I leverage extensive experience across diverse strategies, including buy-and-hold, short- to long-term rentals, flips, value-add projects, land development, 1031 exchanges, and BRRRR. Let’s connect and strategize how we can maximize your next investment!
“Peter was fantastic to work with on our investment property purchase in the Butler-Tarkington area of Indianapolis.”
Kristopher Rooney, BiggerPockets member · reviewed September 2026
Serves Anderson, Avon, Brownsburg, Carmel, Cicero, Danville, Fortville, Franklin, Greenfield, Greenwood, Indianapolis, Lebanon, Noblesville, Pendleton, Pittsboro, Shelbyville, Sheridan, Speedway, Westfield, Whitestown, ZionsvilleAlso listed for Indianapolis, IN
View full profile
2GN
Gloria N Gear
Gear Realty Group · Fishers, IN
5.0(1 review)·464 forum posts
View profile
- Residential
- Fix & flip
- Land
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- New Construction
- Primary Residence
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
- Townhouse/Condo
Gloria N Gear is a Fishers, IN agent rated 5.0 from 1 BiggerPockets member review, who specializes in fix & flip, land, multi-family (2-4 units), new construction, primary residence, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.
I am the pink-haired investor realtor in the Indianapolis area. I have been working with out-of-state investors since 2016. I have built up a "boots on the ground" team to help investors evaluate and purchase properties. Not only do we run comps and rental stats, we also video properties giving you honest opinions of the condition of the property and surrounding neighborhood. After we are under contract, we will assist you with scheduling inspectors, contractors and communicating with your lender, title company and property manager. In addition to all of these services, we also have an extensive network of local vendors, including investor-friendly lenders, title companies, contractors, insurance companies, property managers and much more. Featured on the Bigger Pockets Meet the Investor Series https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BrY6jgxbWIA My calendly link (best way to sync our calendars) to schedule phone appointments is https://calendly.com/geargroup
“Being a first time out of state investor.”
Hiromi Braun, BiggerPockets member · reviewed November 2024
Serves Avon, Brownsburg, Carmel, Greenwood, Indianapolis, Noblesville, Plainfield, Westfield, ZionsvilleAlso listed for Indianapolis, IN
View full profile
3TL
Tyler Lingle
Roots Realty Co. · Fishers, IN
5.0(13 reviews)·440 forum posts
View profile
- Commercial
- Residential
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Multi-Family (5+ units)
- New Construction
- Office/Retail
- Primary Residence
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
- Townhouse/Condo
Tyler Lingle is a Fishers, IN agent rated 5.0 from 13 BiggerPockets member reviews, who specializes in multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, primary residence, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.
At Roots Realty Co., we are agents, but also investors ourselves. We will help you source on & off-market deals, navigate the transaction and inspection process, obtain a financing / property management partner, and scale as fast as you want to go. As investor-agents, we analyze deal with our investor-hat on. Personally, we own & operate both long-term rentals and short-term rentals in Indianapolis. This role allows us to have a vantage point into the market as true stakeholders. We are hunting for deals for you, the investor, that actually make sense in real life, not just on a pro forma spreadsheet. Reach out today, and we will follow up with a Calendly link to set up a call, gather information, and chart out a clear plan of execution. ~cheers~
“Tyler is absolutely wonderful to work with and you need to give him a call for anything property-related in the Indianapolis area.”
Jarek Chu, BiggerPockets member · reviewed July 2024
Serves Avon, Carmel, Danville, Indianapolis, Lebanon, ZionsvilleAlso listed for Indianapolis, IN
View full profile
4DM
Darin Moon
Darin-Moon Sycamore Realtors · Fishers, IN
5.0(1 review)·18 forum posts
View profile
- Residential
- Land
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Primary Residence
- Single-Family Rental
Darin Moon is a Fishers, IN agent rated 5.0 from 1 BiggerPockets member review, who specializes in land, multi-family (2-4 units), primary residence, and single-family rental.
Darin is known for his off the charts work ethic and his drive to succeed. He is an entrepreneur and business owner with a strong desire to help those around him also achieve their goals. In addition to owning and investing in his own real estate endeavors he owns ThriveFit Gym in Westfield. He has been personally involved with real estate for about 8 years through buying, renovating, and reselling. He has resided in Hamilton Co. ever since graduating from Indiana Wesleyan with his degree in Business Administration. He loves being active, and has a passion for helping others. Darin Moon is a husband and father of 3 little girls.
“Darin has been a tremendous resource for my family and I.”
Stephen Smith, BiggerPockets member · reviewed July 2024
Serves Brownsburg, Carmel, Cicero, Fortville, Indianapolis, McCordsville, Meridian Hills, Noblesville, Pendleton, Sheridan, Speedway, Westfield, Zionsville
View full profile
5FP
Frank Pyle
Frank Pyle at ExP Realty · Fishers, IN
280 forum posts
View profile
- Commercial
- Residential
- Fix & flip
- Land
- Mobile Home Parks
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Multi-Family (5+ units)
- New Construction
- Office/Retail
- Primary Residence
- Self-Storage
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
- Townhouse/Condo
Frank Pyle is a Fishers, IN agent, who specializes in fix & flip, land, mobile home parks, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, primary residence, self-storage, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.
I help real estate investors find, evaluate, finance, purchase, and sell investment properties with greater confidence. By combining hands-on investment experience, investor-focused real estate representation, financing expertise, and in-depth property analysis through Investor’s Edge Concierge, I help clients make better decisions before they commit their capital. I work with new and experienced investors pursuing rental properties, multifamily opportunities, value-add projects, BRRRR strategies, flips, and portfolio growth. My services include property searches, market and comparable-sales analysis, offer strategy, contract negotiation, financing guidance, and coordination with trusted local professionals. Through Investor’s Edge Concierge, or IEC, clients can access deeper property analysis and investment strategy support. IEC helps investors review projected income and expenses, evaluate cash flow and financing options, identify potential risks, and determine whether a property fits their investment goals before moving forward. My goal is to help investors avoid costly surprises and build stronger portfolios through a coordinated approach to property selection, analysis, financing, and execution. Real estate brokerage services are provided through eXp Realty.
Serves Anderson, Beech Grove, Carmel, Danville, Greenfield, Greenwood, Indianapolis, McCordsville, New Palestine, Noblesville, Plainfield, Westfield, WhitestownAlso listed for Indianapolis, IN
View full profile
6RR
Ryan Rominger
Intrigue Real Estate & Property Management · Fishers, IN
4.7(7 reviews)·340 forum posts
View profile
- Commercial
- Residential
- Land
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Multi-Family (5+ units)
- New Construction
- Office/Retail
- Primary Residence
- Self-Storage
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
- Townhouse/Condo
Ryan Rominger is a Fishers, IN agent rated 4.7 from 7 BiggerPockets member reviews, who specializes in land, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, primary residence, self-storage, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.
We specialize in helping investors analyze, purchase, lease, and manage rental properties in Indianapolis. Whether you're a first-time investor, an experienced landlord, or an aspiring house hacker, we provide expert guidance and seamless solutions for all of the Greater Indianapolis area. From buying and selling homes to maximizing rental income by managing properties with expert care, we provide seamless, high-quality services tailored to your real estate needs.
“I'm an out-of-state investor building a rental portfolio in Indianapolis, and Ryan was one of the first agents I spoke with.”
Rory Dowse, BiggerPockets member · reviewed June 2026
Serves Anderson, Avon, Beech Grove, Brownsburg, Carmel, Cicero, Danville, Fortville, Franklin, Greenfield, Greenwood, Indianapolis, Muncie, Noblesville, Pendleton, Plainfield, Southport, Speedway, Westfield, Whitestown, ZionsvilleAlso listed for Lawrence, IN
View full profile
7KC
KiKi Chase
Brentwood Collective · Fishers, IN
184 forum posts
View profile
- Residential
- Long-term rental
- Mid-term rental
- New Construction
- Primary Residence
- Short-term rental
- Single-Family Rental
KiKi Chase is a Fishers, IN agent, who specializes in long-term rental, mid-term rental, new construction, primary residence, short-term rental, and single-family rental.
I work primarily with real estate investors buying short-term and mid-term rental properties in Indianapolis, helping them turn opportunities into profitable, wealth-building ventures. While I handle all types of residential investments, short-term rentals are my specialty, and I absolutely love guiding clients through every step of the process. My husband and I make a dynamic team, pairing real estate acquisitions with full-service property management to give investors a truly seamless, hands-off experience. With 5 years in the business, I’ve seen firsthand how the right investments can change lives, and there’s nothing more exciting than helping people grow their wealth, one smart property at a time. If you’re an investor looking to dive into Indianapolis real estate, I’m here to make it simple, strategic, and even a little fun!
Serves Avon, Beech Grove, Brownsburg, Carmel, Franklin, Greenfield, Greenwood, Indianapolis, Lawrence, Noblesville, Plainfield, Shelbyville, Westfield, Whiteland, Whitestown, ZionsvilleAlso listed for Indianapolis, IN
View full profile
8CH
Carla Hernandez
Fishers, IN
View profile
- Commercial
- Residential
- Fix & flip
- Land
- Multi-Family (2-4 units)
- Multi-Family (5+ units)
- New Construction
- Office/Retail
- Self-Storage
Carla Hernandez is a Fishers, IN agent, who specializes in fix & flip, land, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, and self-storage.
I’m passionate about helping real estate investors discover the right opportunities and grow confidently in the Indiana market. 🏡 From connecting clients with promising deals to sharing local resources and market insight, I focus on making every step of the process more strategic and less overwhelming. 📈 As a bilingual real estate agent fluent in English and Spanish, I work closely with a diverse network of investors and take pride in building lasting relationships rooted in trust, communication, and results. 🤝✨
Serves Avon, Carmel, Greenfield, Greenwood, Indianapolis, Lebanon, Noblesville, Plainfield, ZionsvilleAlso listed for Indianapolis, IN
View full profile

Investing in Fishers: the numbers

Metro-area figures from BiggerPockets market data, as of November 2026.

$265,900median home price
$1,191median monthly rent
0.45%monthly rent to price
3.4%unemployment rate

Source and definitions: Market Finder.

Nearby markets these agents also cover

Each town below has its own list of investor-friendly agents.

Indiana All markets

Questions investors in Fishers ask

Local answers only. The general ones (what investor-friendly means, what it costs, how vetting works) are on the main finder page.

What do Fishers agents specialize in?

The 8 agents listed here specialize in fix & flip, land, long-term rental, mid-term rental, mobile home parks, multi-family (2-4 units), multi-family (5+ units), new construction, office/retail, primary residence, self-storage, short-term rental, single-family rental, and townhouse/condo.

Do these agents cover Carmel, Indianapolis, and Noblesville too?

Yes. Between them, the agents listed here also serve Carmel, Indianapolis, Noblesville, Zionsville, Avon, Greenwood, Westfield, Brownsburg, Greenfield, Plainfield, Danville, Whitestown, Anderson, Beech Grove, Cicero, Fortville, Franklin, Lebanon, Pendleton, Speedway, McCordsville, Shelbyville, Sheridan, Lawrence, Meridian Hills, Muncie, New Palestine, Pittsboro, Southport, and Whiteland. If your search is really greater Fishers rather than the city itself, start with the agent whose reviews mention the town you are buying in.

How should I choose between them?

Read the investor reviews first, then the agent's own forum posts, which show how they think about a deal before you have spent an hour on the phone. Ask each for the last three investment deals they closed in Hamilton County and how those deals performed. An agent who works with investors will have the numbers ready.

What is an investor-friendly real estate agent?

An investor-friendly real estate agent represents buyers who purchase property to rent, renovate, or resell rather than to live in. They can price a property against rent comps and renovation costs, not just against nearby sales, and they are used to offers written for speed and inspection terms an owner-occupant would not accept. Many are investors themselves.

Are you an agent in Fishers?

Apply to be listed for investors in Indiana.

Agent application

Investor-friendly real estate agents in Fishers, IN

The agents

Peter Stewart

Gloria N Gear

Tyler Lingle

Darin Moon

Frank Pyle

Ryan Rominger

KiKi Chase

Carla Hernandez