Skip to content
Two investors reviewing resources on a laptop

Get industry-leading resources — for free

Unlock resources for every investing strategy and stage with a free account.

By continuing, you agree to BiggerPockets LLC's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Posted 7 days ago

Four Buckets, and the One That's Always Too Small

Contain 800x800

Every property insurance policy sorts everything you own at that address into four separate buckets. That sorting happens when the policy actually gets written, not when the loss happens. By the time an adjuster is standing in your driveway, the buckets are already set and the limits inside them are already locked in.

On a house somebody actually lives in full time, the default allocations work fine. On a rental with real amenities, they don't, and the reason is simple. The defaults were designed around a suburban house with a shed out back, not a lake property with a dock and a bunkhouse.

Coverage A, the dwelling


The structure itself, anything attached to it, and building materials sitting on site for construction or repair.

Attached is the word doing all the actual work here. An attached deck is Coverage A. An attached garage is Coverage A. A screened porch off the back of the house is Coverage A. Built in appliances, cabinetry, and permanently installed fixtures are all Coverage A too.

The limit here should equal what it actually costs to rebuild. Owners routinely set it against one of three wrong numbers instead. Market value, which includes land and location on top of the structure. The loan balance, which is really just a bank's number. Or the county assessment, which is a tax number, not a construction number. None of those three actually describe what a contractor would charge to put the building back.

Rebuild cost also moves a lot faster than most owners ever check it. A limit set at a 2019 closing is describing a construction market that simply doesn't exist anymore, and after a regional catastrophe hits, local labor and material costs spike even further on top of that.

Coverage B, other structures


Everything on the property that isn't attached to the dwelling. Detached garage, shed, bunkhouse, sauna, gazebo, dock, boathouse, fence, retaining wall, flagpole.

This limit usually gets generated automatically at ten percent of Coverage A. Nobody actually chose that number. The software just produced it.

Two problems follow from that, and both are considerably worse at a rental than at a regular house.

The first is basic arithmetic. At a lake property, the detached structures are often the entire reason people book the place. A $600,000 cabin gets a $60,000 Coverage B limit by default. Now go price out the detached structures. Dock and boat lift, $48,000. Detached bunkhouse, $85,000. Sauna, $22,000. Fencing and a retaining wall, $18,000. That's $173,000 of real exposure sitting inside a $60,000 bucket.

The second problem is a provision almost nobody's ever actually read. Homeowners forms commonly exclude coverage for other structures rented or held for rental to anybody who isn't a tenant of the dwelling, with an exception carved out for use as a private garage. Read that language against a listing that's actively advertising a detached bunkhouse as sleeping space for guests. The exact structure that helps you sell the booking is the structure that exclusion reaches right into.

A few individual items behave differently on their own too. Docks and boat lifts are frequently excluded or sublimited outright, and damage from ice, freezing, and wave action is commonly excluded even when the dock is otherwise sitting there covered. Fences often settle on actual cash value even under an otherwise solid replacement cost policy.

The deck question


An ember from a fire pit lands on some decking and the deck catches fire. What happens next depends entirely on where exactly that deck is physically attached.

If it's built off the back of the house, it's Coverage A, and the claim draws against your full $600,000. If it's a freestanding platform down by the water instead, it's Coverage B, and the claim draws against just $60,000, a bucket that's already carrying the bunkhouse, the sauna, and the retaining wall too.

Same lumber. Same fire. Same builder doing the work. Different bucket, different limit, and sometimes even a different valuation basis entirely.

The hot tub is the version of this question that comes up the most often. A hot tub sunk directly into an attached deck usually reads as part of the dwelling itself. One sitting on a pad twenty feet away from the house is an other structure instead. One delivered on skids that could technically be moved tomorrow can even get argued as personal property. One single item, three completely possible answers, and whichever answer wins determines which limit responds and how it actually gets valued.

Nobody resolves this well in the middle of an actual claim. It's a five minute conversation to have well before one.

Coverage C, personal property


This is your contents. On a homeowners form, the limit defaults to a percentage of Coverage A, commonly fifty percent. On a dwelling form, it's limited strictly to property the owner keeps on site to service the premises, and that default is pretty small.

Two defaults are worth knowing here. Personal property usually runs on named perils even when the dwelling itself runs on open perils. And it usually settles at actual cash value unless replacement cost has been specifically added by endorsement.

There's a third issue specific to rentals too. Furniture you bought specifically to serve paying guests is business personal property, and a lot of homeowners forms cap that at a pretty low on premises sublimit.

Coverage C also carries internal sublimits that have nothing to do with your overall limit. Cash, jewelry, firearms, and tools each have their own individual caps. At a rental, the ones that actually bite are usually electronics, e-bikes, kayaks and paddleboards, and grills.

Coverage D, loss of use


Three separate things live inside this bucket, and only one of them really matters much on a rental property.

Additional living expense pays for you personally to live somewhere else while your home is uninhabitable. On a property nobody actually lives in, this does almost nothing for you.

Fair rental value pays for lost rental income while the property can't be occupied by anyone. This is the one that actually matters, and the measurement basis is the whole conversation worth having. Most forms calculate this against what the property would rent for on a standard lease rather than what it actually earns on a nightly basis.

Civil authority coverage is the one almost nobody knows exists. It pays lost income when a government order prevents anyone from reaching the property, even though the property itself is completely undamaged. Wildfire evacuation zones, hurricane closures, road closures after a landslide. This coverage is usually capped at a pretty short period, commonly around two weeks, and it's exactly why you should read this section carefully if you're operating anywhere with seasonal evacuation risk.

The exercise worth doing this week


Walk the entire property with a notepad and assign every single structure to a bucket. Attached goes in column A. Detached goes in column B.

Then write a real rebuild cost next to each item sitting in column B and total the whole thing up. Compare that total directly against the Coverage B limit sitting on your declarations page.

Most owners with amenity heavy properties find out they're underinsured on other structures by a factor of two or three once they actually do this math. It takes about twenty minutes total.

What I'd actually ask my agent


Ask whether Coverage B can actually be increased beyond that default percentage, and what it would cost to raise it. It usually can be raised, and it's usually pretty inexpensive relative to the real exposure sitting there.

Ask specifically how the policy treats a dock, a detached bunkhouse, and a hot tub at your particular property. Get the answer item by item, not just a general reassurance.

Ask whether any structure exclusion applies to buildings used in connection with renting out the property. That provision is completely standard on homeowners forms, and it's exactly the one that reaches right into an advertised amenity you're using to sell bookings.



Comments