The Memphis turn nobody budgets: what an eviction actually leaves behind

The Memphis turn nobody budgets: what an eviction actually leaves behind

Josh HandlerPro Member
Contractor · Memphis, TN · Member since 2026 · 61 posts · 62 votes

There are three different turns and almost everybody budgets the first one.

A normal move-out, where somebody gives notice, cleans a little, and hands you keys. An abandonment, where they leave on their own schedule and you find out later. And a set-out after a writ, which is what happens at the end of an eviction.

Those are not three versions of the same scope. They're three different jobs, and the gap between the first and the third is the number that surprises people.

I'm seeing this come up a lot right now, so here's what's actually in it.

THE TRASH-OUT IS THE PREDICTABLE PART

Everybody worries about the debris and it's the piece you can price most accurately. After a writ, belongings frequently get left, sometimes on the lawn, sometimes still inside. It's unpleasant, it's a dumpster and labor, and it's a number somebody can quote you from photos.

The trash-out is not what gets people. What gets people is everything the trash-out is hiding.

THE REAL COST IS THE BLIND PERIOD

Here's the part almost nobody accounts for. A tenant who stops paying usually stops reporting problems first, typically a month or two before the money stops. Same instinct: they don't want a call, a visit, or attention on the unit.

So if somebody is three months behind, you're looking at four or five months where nobody told you anything was wrong. That's not a rent problem, it's a blind period. Whatever failed in month one has been failing ever since with nobody watching.

The things that go wrong quietly in a Memphis house over four or five unwatched months: a slow leak under a vanity or behind a toilet working on the subfloor, a roof leak that started as a stain, a condenser that stopped working in August and never got called in, and a drain line that's been backing up and getting plunged instead of reported.

None of those are visible in a drive-by and none of them are in the trash-out quote.

UTILITIES ARE THE OTHER ONE

If the power or water went off at any point during the non-payment, that changes the scope again.

Water off and then back on is how you discover the supply lines on an older house, because the system sat dry and then got pressurized. If it's cold when the house goes empty and the heat has been off, you have a freeze question. Power off in a Memphis summer means a closed-up house at high humidity for weeks, which is a mold and flooring question, not a cleaning question.

Ask whether the utilities stayed on. It changes what you should expect before anybody walks in.

WHAT I'D ACTUALLY DO

Scope the turn while the eviction is still running, not after. The scope doesn't require possession and it doesn't cost anything to have ready. If you wait until you have keys and then start collecting bids, you lose two weeks at exactly the moment the meter is running hardest. That's the single most common avoidable loss in this whole sequence.

Treat the trash-out and the condition assessment as one trip rather than two. The day the belongings come out is the first day anybody can actually see the floors, the walls and the wet areas. Have somebody there who can read a house, not just haul.

Turn the water on and watch it before you commit to a number. Fifteen minutes of running fixtures and looking underneath tells you more than the walkthrough does.

Pull the tenant's move-in inspection photos if they exist. That's what lets you price the delta between how they got it and how they left it, instead of pricing every imperfection in a house that's been lived in. It's also the document your deposit and damages claim rests on.

THE TIMING PART, SPECIFIC TO RIGHT NOW

It's late September. A filing today realistically gets possession sometime in late October or November, and then you're turning and listing into the thinnest part of the Memphis leasing calendar, because days on market widen noticeably from November through the new year.

That's an argument for moving faster, not for waiting. Every week of delay pushes the eventual list date deeper into the slow window while the arrears keep climbing. The version that goes worst is tolerating it into January and then facing the turn, the vacancy and the list in the slowest month having gained nothing.

THE HONEST COUNTERARGUMENT

A payment plan is not always the wrong answer. If the arrears are genuinely shrinking month over month, that's a temporary setback and it's usually cheaper to work with than to replace. The test isn't whether they're paying something, it's whether the balance is moving in the right direction. Flat or growing arrears with a plan attached is just a slower version of the same outcome.

And on the Section 8 side the math is different enough to be worth saying: when the housing authority portion is landing and the tenant portion is what's short, you're dealing with a much smaller number and a different decision.

Full disclosure, I run a construction company here in Memphis and turns are a big part of what we do, so I'm on the repair side of everything above. The parts that cost me money to tell you, like scoping early and doing the assessment in the same trip as the trash-out, are the ones I'd lead with anyway.

Curious what the local PMs and operators would add, especially anyone who's done a set-out recently. My view is from the day the house is empty forward, and the people who see the months before that have a better read on the leading indicators than I do.

0Reply
79 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Englewood, NJ · Member since 2018 · 461 posts · 80 votes
    1d

    josh your blind period framing is spot on. i've started thinking about it as a leading indicator problem rather than a rent collection problem. the tenant who stops calling about maintenance is usually a month or two ahead of the tenant who stops paying, and if i'm only watching the bank account i'm already behind.

    what i've been trying to do is track the service requests themselves as a signal. if a unit that used to call about small stuff suddenly goes quiet, that's when i start paying attention, not when the check bounces. same instinct you're describing but from the other direction.

    the other thing i'd add is the contractor relationship piece. i've learned that having somebody i can call before the writ even files, just to walk through and eyeball what's likely hiding, saves me two weeks of bid collection after i get keys. they can't do a full scope without access but they can usually tell me if i'm looking at a cosmetic turn or a gut job, and that changes the whole timeline decision.

    your point about scoping while the eviction is running is the one i'm going to steal. most operators i know wait until they have the unit in hand and then act surprised when the rehab takes longer than expected. by then the leasing window has already slipped.

  • Michael K GallagherBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · Columbus OH · Member since 2018 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    1d

    the blind period is an interesting concept. speaks to really that if we are sticking to the inspections we know we should be doing we will catch these things - regardless you are correct it does not require possession to enter and inspect per most leases.

  • Josh HandlerPro Member
    OP
    Contractor · Memphis, TN · Member since 2026 · 61 posts · 62 votes
    11h

    Igor, the service-request signal is the sharpest thing anybody has added to this, and I want to push on it because I think there's a trap in it worth naming.

    Silence is ambiguous. A unit goes quiet for three very different reasons and only one of them is the one you're hunting. They're happy and nothing is wrong. They've stopped believing anything will get fixed, which is your leading indicator. Or, the one I see most often from the repair side, they've started fixing things themselves. That third one looks identical to the first one in your data and it's the most expensive of the three. Tenant-performed repairs are how you end up with a water heater installed without a pan or a drain, a junction box behind drywall, and a hose bib somebody replaced by cutting the line. None of that generates a work order and all of it generates a claim eventually.

    So the version I'd run is a comparison against the unit's own history rather than the portfolio's, plus a second signal before you act. Quiet alone is noise. Quiet plus a partial payment, quiet plus a changed phone number, quiet plus a neighbor complaint, quiet plus a utility going into someone else's name, those are the pairs. And the cheap intervention is a scheduled non-punitive visit: filter change, smoke detector batteries, seasonal check. You get eyes inside legally and routinely without the tenant experiencing it as an inspection, which is what makes it repeatable.

    Michael, you're right that the leases generally allow it, and the honest problem isn't the lease. It's that the inspection schedule is the first thing that lapses the moment a tenant goes delinquent. Everybody shifts into legal mode, nobody wants to be in the unit while an eviction is pending, and so the house you most need to see is the one nobody goes into. It's worse if a third party manages it, because management fees are usually collected on collected rent. A non-paying unit produces zero revenue and maximum work, so the inspection that would save the owner the most money is precisely the one nobody is paid to perform. That isn't a character flaw in property managers, it's the fee structure, and it's why I'd write that visit into the eviction checklist rather than leaving it to good intentions.

    Igor, on the contractor call before the writ files, one refinement from my side of it. Ask for the binary rather than a scope. Cosmetic or gut. That's answerable from the outside, from the age of the house, the roofline, the condenser, the state of the yard and what the neighbors' houses look like, and it takes twenty minutes instead of a half day. Most of us will do that for free and be accurate about it. Ask for a number instead and you'll get either a refusal or a bad guess, because nobody can price what they can't see, and the guess is the thing that later feels like a bait and switch.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.