Real Estate Agent · Boston, MA · Member since 2025 · 121 posts · 28 votes
October's Providence numbers are a strange mix. Realtor.com has the city's median sold price at $424,500, down about 15% year over year (one month's mix, but still), active listings up ~23%, and median rent at $2,300 — down ~4% year over year. Providence County is steadier: sold median $460,000, basically flat. So the city and the county are telling two different stories.
On top of that, Providence just tightened its "8-Law" affordable-housing tax treatment — the new ordinance (in effect this month) requires 40% of units at ≤60% AMI, or 51% at ≤80% AMI, to qualify — while a developer's fight over existing 8-Law deals is in front of the RI Supreme Court.
I'm a Realtor licensed in RI and an operator on the MA side, looking at Providence/Pawtucket small multifamily. For those already holding there: are you treating this as a buying window, or does the tax-treatment uncertainty change how you underwrite? Anyone repricing deals because of the 8-Law changes?
With the mixed signals you described, I would underwrite the deal twice: once with the tax treatment you hope for, and once without it. If the deal only works in the hopeful version, it is fragile, especially while the rules and a court case are still moving.
I would also verify the ordinance and its tax treatment with a local attorney or tax professional before relying on it, rather than treating a forum summary as settled law. The same applies to price and rent: base them on actual comparable sales and leases for the specific property type, not on a citywide median alone.
Finally, I would keep reserves for a slower lease-up or a lower rent, and ask what happens if the tax treatment changes after purchase. A deal that still works under the more cautious version is much easier to hold with confidence, even if the upside is smaller.
Appreciate this, Ametria — underwriting it twice is exactly how I'd frame Providence right now. If a deal only works with the hopeful tax treatment, it isn't really working, especially while the 8-Law rules and the court case are still moving.
On my side, I underwrite buy-and-hold to the cautious version first: real comps and leases for that property type, slower lease-up, softer rent. If it still holds there, the upside is a bonus — not the plan. And yes, verify the ordinance locally before relying on any summary, mine included.
Thanks for the thoughtful reply. Happy to connect — DMs open.