Skip to content
Two investors reviewing resources on a laptop

Get industry-leading resources — for free

Unlock resources for every investing strategy and stage with a free account.

By continuing, you agree to BiggerPockets LLC's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Please log in or sign up for a free account to continue.

Business Page


business profile image

First Ohio Home Finance

Lender
4.9 stars
230 Reviews

Markets served


Ohio

Licenses


Additional Licenses & Information

Ohio: 1682105

More ways to connect


About us


I entered the mortgage industry in 2005 with First Ohio Home Finance. Throughout my tenure with the company I played a key role in developing our operations and underwriting policy and practices. In late 2017 I left my role as Operations Director to open a new sales branch in the Short North of Columbus, Oh. Since then we've developed the Wharton Lending Team with a focus on investor transactions covering acquisition to cash out to delayed financing.

Specialties


Conventional & Gov.

Refinance (investment)
Conventional Rental Loan
VA Loan
Conventional Loan
Refinance (primary home)
USDA Loan

Reviews (230)


4.9 stars
230 Reviews
4.9 stars
230 Reviews
0.0 star
0 Reviews

reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
3 weeks ago
Reviewed by Jenna Bollinger
Karen Starkey has been a dream to work with. She is extremely knowledgeable and she works very hard to ensure a smooth home financing process. Because this was my first home buying experience, I was very nervous and had lots of questions. Karen was always there to assist. She was recommended to me by my realtor, Nate Harvey and I am so thankful he did. Karen was very accessible throughout this process and was proactive to get documents, paperwork, etc completed quickly. I highly recommended Karen for your home financing needs!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 months ago
Reviewed by Jill Hann
I would highly recommend first Ohio home finance. They find the most competitive loan interest rates. John Igoe and Rachelle Smith were a great team for myself and my realtor to work with. They were both readily accessible and always attentive throughout every step of the loan process. Both were very knowledgeable and had me prepared for all the steps throughout the entire process. And they also provided me with accurate numbers. If you are looking to purchase a home or refinance a home do not hesitate to go through first Ohio home finance. You are in good and trusted hands with their team.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
3 months ago
Reviewed by Aunna Wireman
Absolutely love Lisa and Andrew! They are a great team and helped me and my boyfriend buy our first home together! They were sweet and helpful in every way possible! I greatly appreciate them!
reviewer image
1.0 star
|
4 months ago
Reviewed by Mermaid Jewel
I was disappointed with my experience. I asked many questions before applying and was told that most answers would only be available after a hard credit inquiry. After the credit pull, I was informed that I did not have sufficient assets for the loan program. When I asked about other options, including owner-occupied financing, I felt there was very little effort to explore alternatives or explain possible next steps. I was left feeling that most of the assistance ended once it became clear I did not qualify for the original loan. I understand lenders have guidelines they must follow, but I expected more guidance and transparency before authorizing a hard credit pull. Please fire Chris Wharton!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
5 months ago
Reviewed by Ji hye Kim
I feel so lucky that I met Chris Wharton and Nicole for my first out-of-state investment property while living in New York. They are both incredibly smart, professional, reliable, and efficient. Thanks to their hard work, excellent teamwork, and clear communication, I was able to close in less than 25 days, which was truly impressive. In a competitive multiple-offer situation, they worked quickly and strategically to help strengthen my offer and put me in the best position possible. Honestly, I don't believe this investment would have happened without Chris Wharton. His guidance, responsiveness, knowledge, and dedication made all the difference from start to finish. Nicole and Chris were always available to answer questions, solve problems, and keep everything moving forward. They are trustworthy, supportive, responsive, and genuinely care about their clients. I can confidently say they are on a completely different level compared to other lenders I have worked with or spoken to. I will absolutely work with this team again for my next investment property. Thank you so much, Chris Wharton and Nicole. You helped turn what felt like a difficult out-of-state investment into a smooth and successful experience. I truly appreciate everything you did. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by michael graney
Working with Tony and his team on our home's refinancing has been beyond easy. The path was clearly laid out in our initial meeting as to what we needed to prepare and how the First Ohio team would manage the process from there. It went exactly as described from start to finish. We were provided a number of progress reports along the way, great communication & great experience. If we could give more than 5 stars on this review we would...Thanks!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by Casey Bond
Tony and his team were highly recommended by a family member when we were looking to buy our home. They were exceptional throughout the entire process. First Ohio Home Finance not only offered us multiple options that suited our situation but also provided the most competitive rates among the lenders we compared. This positive experience was repeated when we refinanced our mortgage a couple of years later to secure a better interest rate. My wife and I wholeheartedly recommend using Tony or anyone from his office for any lending needs.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by Omotayo Awosoji
Chris was phenomenal throughout the entire process of securing my second home. From start to finish, he demonstrated professionalism, deep knowledge, and genuine dedication. He took the time to explain every step clearly, answered all my questions promptly, and made what could have been a stressful experience feel smooth and manageable. What really stood out was his commitment to getting the best outcome for me. He went above and beyond to ensure everything stayed on track and closed successfully. I truly felt supported every step of the way. If you're looking for someone reliable, responsive, and highly skilled, I highly recommend Chris. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience! Thank you, Chris.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by Kayla Geyer
We have done business with this company for nearly 10 years. We tried to go through our bank for a loan for our second home, and I couldn't believe how unmotivated they were to help us even with our finances right in front of them. So I went back to Troy at FOHF, and he got us approved by the end of the day for the market. Troy helped us get into our first home; he was more on top of our inspection, remedy time period, and closing than our realtor. And now, Troy helped us with our second home, and he was happy to help us refinance into a lower rate. He and his team go above and beyond to get us the best deal, explain the process, and make signing documents as easy as possible. It's overwhelming to get into the housing market, but they have always answered all our questions and help us navigate realtors and title companies. My only mistake is not going back to Troy first when we were ready for our second home.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
7 months ago
Reviewed by Arianna Pappas
Karen Starkey is absolutely phenomenal! My boyfriend and I worked with her for several months while searching for our first home, and she made the entire experience so much easier. She was always in touch, day or night, and made herself available whenever we had questions, even while she was on vacation. Karen is incredibly knowledgeable, informative, and genuinely cares about her clients. I’ve heard horror stories from family members that at closing were suprised by the numbers and we knew exactly what to expect prior to closing so that we were able to ensure we were completely prepared which was so important to us. Buying a home can be stressful, but she guided us every step of the way and made us feel supported throughout the entire process. We are so grateful for everything she did for us. Her assistant, Raquel, was also wonderful, kind, responsive, and always helpful. Together, they truly had our backs. I can’t recommend Karen enough!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
3 weeks ago
Reviewed by Jenna Bollinger
Karen Starkey has been a dream to work with. She is extremely knowledgeable and she works very hard to ensure a smooth home financing process. Because this was my first home buying experience, I was very nervous and had lots of questions. Karen was always there to assist. She was recommended to me by my realtor, Nate Harvey and I am so thankful he did. Karen was very accessible throughout this process and was proactive to get documents, paperwork, etc completed quickly. I highly recommended Karen for your home financing needs!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
2 months ago
Reviewed by Jill Hann
I would highly recommend first Ohio home finance. They find the most competitive loan interest rates. John Igoe and Rachelle Smith were a great team for myself and my realtor to work with. They were both readily accessible and always attentive throughout every step of the loan process. Both were very knowledgeable and had me prepared for all the steps throughout the entire process. And they also provided me with accurate numbers. If you are looking to purchase a home or refinance a home do not hesitate to go through first Ohio home finance. You are in good and trusted hands with their team.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
3 months ago
Reviewed by Aunna Wireman
Absolutely love Lisa and Andrew! They are a great team and helped me and my boyfriend buy our first home together! They were sweet and helpful in every way possible! I greatly appreciate them!
reviewer image
1.0 star
|
4 months ago
Reviewed by Mermaid Jewel
I was disappointed with my experience. I asked many questions before applying and was told that most answers would only be available after a hard credit inquiry. After the credit pull, I was informed that I did not have sufficient assets for the loan program. When I asked about other options, including owner-occupied financing, I felt there was very little effort to explore alternatives or explain possible next steps. I was left feeling that most of the assistance ended once it became clear I did not qualify for the original loan. I understand lenders have guidelines they must follow, but I expected more guidance and transparency before authorizing a hard credit pull. Please fire Chris Wharton!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
5 months ago
Reviewed by Ji hye Kim
I feel so lucky that I met Chris Wharton and Nicole for my first out-of-state investment property while living in New York. They are both incredibly smart, professional, reliable, and efficient. Thanks to their hard work, excellent teamwork, and clear communication, I was able to close in less than 25 days, which was truly impressive. In a competitive multiple-offer situation, they worked quickly and strategically to help strengthen my offer and put me in the best position possible. Honestly, I don't believe this investment would have happened without Chris Wharton. His guidance, responsiveness, knowledge, and dedication made all the difference from start to finish. Nicole and Chris were always available to answer questions, solve problems, and keep everything moving forward. They are trustworthy, supportive, responsive, and genuinely care about their clients. I can confidently say they are on a completely different level compared to other lenders I have worked with or spoken to. I will absolutely work with this team again for my next investment property. Thank you so much, Chris Wharton and Nicole. You helped turn what felt like a difficult out-of-state investment into a smooth and successful experience. I truly appreciate everything you did. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by michael graney
Working with Tony and his team on our home's refinancing has been beyond easy. The path was clearly laid out in our initial meeting as to what we needed to prepare and how the First Ohio team would manage the process from there. It went exactly as described from start to finish. We were provided a number of progress reports along the way, great communication & great experience. If we could give more than 5 stars on this review we would...Thanks!
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by Casey Bond
Tony and his team were highly recommended by a family member when we were looking to buy our home. They were exceptional throughout the entire process. First Ohio Home Finance not only offered us multiple options that suited our situation but also provided the most competitive rates among the lenders we compared. This positive experience was repeated when we refinanced our mortgage a couple of years later to secure a better interest rate. My wife and I wholeheartedly recommend using Tony or anyone from his office for any lending needs.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by Omotayo Awosoji
Chris was phenomenal throughout the entire process of securing my second home. From start to finish, he demonstrated professionalism, deep knowledge, and genuine dedication. He took the time to explain every step clearly, answered all my questions promptly, and made what could have been a stressful experience feel smooth and manageable. What really stood out was his commitment to getting the best outcome for me. He went above and beyond to ensure everything stayed on track and closed successfully. I truly felt supported every step of the way. If you're looking for someone reliable, responsive, and highly skilled, I highly recommend Chris. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience! Thank you, Chris.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
6 months ago
Reviewed by Kayla Geyer
We have done business with this company for nearly 10 years. We tried to go through our bank for a loan for our second home, and I couldn't believe how unmotivated they were to help us even with our finances right in front of them. So I went back to Troy at FOHF, and he got us approved by the end of the day for the market. Troy helped us get into our first home; he was more on top of our inspection, remedy time period, and closing than our realtor. And now, Troy helped us with our second home, and he was happy to help us refinance into a lower rate. He and his team go above and beyond to get us the best deal, explain the process, and make signing documents as easy as possible. It's overwhelming to get into the housing market, but they have always answered all our questions and help us navigate realtors and title companies. My only mistake is not going back to Troy first when we were ready for our second home.
reviewer image
5.0 stars
|
7 months ago
Reviewed by Arianna Pappas
Karen Starkey is absolutely phenomenal! My boyfriend and I worked with her for several months while searching for our first home, and she made the entire experience so much easier. She was always in touch, day or night, and made herself available whenever we had questions, even while she was on vacation. Karen is incredibly knowledgeable, informative, and genuinely cares about her clients. I’ve heard horror stories from family members that at closing were suprised by the numbers and we knew exactly what to expect prior to closing so that we were able to ensure we were completely prepared which was so important to us. Buying a home can be stressful, but she guided us every step of the way and made us feel supported throughout the entire process. We are so grateful for everything she did for us. Her assistant, Raquel, was also wonderful, kind, responsive, and always helpful. Together, they truly had our backs. I can’t recommend Karen enough!

Our Team


Chris Wharton