Skip to content

Let's keep in touch

Subscribe to our newsletter for timely insights and actionable tips on your real estate journey.

By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions

Property Managers in Fort Myers, FL

3 investor-friendly Property Managers found in Fort Myers, FL as of October 7, 2026

  • business profile image

    Bartomeo Property Management

    Long-term rental: 12+ months

    HUD/Section 8

    4.7 stars
    150 Reviews
    2347 forum posts

    Long-term rental: 12+ months

    HUD/Section 8

    What sets us apart? We were Full Time Investors before we became Property Managers and learned how to manage properties by making mistakes with our properties, so, we don't make mistakes on yours. We are a full-service property management company that utilizes our proven systems, strategies, and experience to provide the highest levels of customer service while ensuring the maximum profitability for our owners. Our company culture revolves around continuous improvement and striving to increas... view more
  • business profile image

    Red Fortress Property Management Co.

    Long-term rental: 12+ months

    Mid-term rental: 1-12 months

    4.2 stars
    327 Reviews
    45 forum posts

    Long-term rental: 12+ months

    Mid-term rental: 1-12 months

    Being a real estate investor can be difficult. We know because we are investors ourselves and we created our company 35 years ago to help us and our clients equally with the same systems. We manage the liability for you from the increasing risks a landlord faces today. Our systems and relationship with our clients are designed to be more of a partnership than other companies. Find out why Red Fortress is the largest and preferred management company in the Fort Myers/ Cape Coral/ Lehigh ar... view more
  • business profile image

    The Brighthouse

    Long-term rental: 12+ months

    Short-term rental: less than 30 days

    4.5 stars
    15 Reviews
    17 forum posts

    Long-term rental: 12+ months

    Short-term rental: less than 30 days

    The Brighthouse is a boutique management company with a focus on unique and high end short term rentals. We also work with investors to selectively manage LTRs. We put our owners in passive income position and have a strong history of producing above average market returns. STR services include furnishing, design, marketing, and management. The Brighthouse is the vision of Erin Lenhardt, a food and hospitality entrepreneur who splits her time between San Francisco, Asheville (NC), and the... view more
Showing 1 - 3 of 3 Fort Myers Property Managers