Should these trees be trimmed or removed completely [pic]

Question

So I have a rental property with two fairly mature trees directly in front of it.  Its gotten to the point where I either need to trim them or just cut them down completely to the ground.  I am debating about this because I know most people like mature trees but in this particular case, they almost completely cover up the front of the house.  My thinking is that if I remove them completely it might bring back a little more curb appeal to the property and make it more inviting to potential renters.  I'm afraid if I just trim them I am just kicking the can down the road and will have to keep trimming them every few years.   They are both healthy and don't appear to be doing any damage to the house other than maybe dropping leaves and twigs every now and then.  Thoughts?

Matthew Paul · Answer

Get rid of them , the roots are right next to the foundation

Melanie Thomas · Answer

I would recommend to remove them completely. As you mentioned they really take away the visibility from the street and roots could pose problems down the stretch. Good luck & happy investing!

David Georgeson · Answer

The entire left side of the house is also lined with tall trees so taking these trees down would not hardly effect the amount of shade being cast on the home.  Im currently waiting for estimates on both cutting down the trees and just trimming them.

Im guessing its going to be upwards of about 1500 to 2000 to cut them both down but if I dont do it now, they are just going to get bigger and more expensive to cut down.

Michael J Cusanza · Answer

Hey David, I recommend contacting an arborist first to come evaluate. A good arborist will tell you the health of the tree and give a recommendation. Removing trees is expensive (trust me) and they do have benefits like shade and privacy. These guys look like they could use a trim for sure, and if they are solid mature trees with no rot, they are minimal to no risk to the house.

Granted I understand your thoughts about curb appeal, but it may be cheaper/better to go trim first and then evaluate.

Granted I understand your thoughts about curb appeal, but it may be cheaper/better to go trim first and then evaluate.

Theresa Harris · Answer

Let me start by saying I love trees, but these two were planted way too close to the house for their size.  I'd remove them and plant a new one (that doesn't get as big) closer to the road or a few smaller shrubs  (max height 3-4 ft) along the chain link fence.  Talk to a local nursery (not big box store) to get ideas for good trees to plant.

David Georgeson · Answer

And yes, in front of the tree on the right side is the power line coming in from the street so there is that to deal with also.

Should these trees be trimmed or removed completely [pic]

Should these trees be trimmed or removed completely [pic]

Most Popular Reply

6 Replies