Rental Property Investor · Miami, FL · Member since 2026 · 5 posts · 0 votes
A lot of Jackson pro formas I see online skip or lowball expenses. Here's how we underwrite a renovated 3/2 in 39206 leased at $1,395/month, all cash, year one:
- Gross rent: $16,740/yr - Vacancy and bad debt (8%): -$1,339 - Management (10% of collected): -$1,540 - Leasing fee, amortized: -$349 - Repairs and maintenance (8% of rent): -$1,339 - CapEx reserve: -$1,200 - Property tax (actual Hinds County bill): -$1,544 - Landlord insurance (estimate): -$1,800 - Legal and misc.: -$300 - NOI: about $7,329, so about 7% on a $105K price
That's a 15.9% gross yield turning into ~7% net. Things that move the result most in Jackson:
1. Taxes. Rentals are assessed at 15% of value vs. 10% for owner-occupied homes, so use the actual bill, not the seller's homestead number. 2. Insurance. Get a real quote for the address before you close. 3. Street-level variation. Two blocks can rent very differently. Check comparable leases, not just Zestimates. 4. Water. JXN Water has run the system under federal court oversight since 2022. Ask for the boil-water notice history of the address.
What expense lines are other Jackson investors seeing differently?
Good breakdown. This is why I underwrite the hold, not just the buy. In Memphis I see the same thing street to street, which is why I stay in the same nine ZIP codes: 38109, 38111, 38112, 38114, 38116, 38117, 38118, 38122, and 38128. I know those streets, and I do not have to guess. Your $1,395 rent is the low end of what I see for Section 8 on a 3-bed-plus house in Memphis, $1,395-$1,950. I buy single-family under $100K, target an ARV of $180K-$265K, and I still run the 1% rule first. If the real tax bill, insurance, management, and repairs eat the deal, I pass. My in-house property management team has to live with the numbers after closing, so I would rather pass on a tight deal than own a house that only works on paper.
Thanks James, agreed: underwrite the hold, not the buy. Same approach here: we stick to a handful of North Jackson zips and walk the comps street by street before we buy.
Interesting on the Section 8 range in Memphis. Our $1,395 is a market-rate lease, and in Jackson the Section 8 payment standards for a 3-bed are lower than what you're seeing in Memphis, so we underwrite most homes at market rent and treat Section 8 as a backup, not the base case.
Curious how insurance is running for you in those Memphis zips lately. That's the line I see moving the most year over year in Jackson.
Me and my company were considering in take a look at Memphis, is good finding someone whos already working there
Bruno, I will not give you a single insurance number for Memphis, because there is not one. It moves by address, by roof, and by carrier, so I get a real quote for the address before I close, just as you said. That quote goes into the hold numbers with the real tax bill, management, and repairs, and if those lines eat the deal, I pass.
You are right to underwrite the hold, not the buy. In Memphis I stay in the same 9 ZIPs: 38109, 38111, 38112, 38114, 38116, 38117, 38118, 38122, and 38128. I buy single-family houses under $100K, I target an ARV of $180K-$265K, and I run the 1% rule first. Section 8 rent of $1,395-$1,950 for a 3BR+ is the base case for me there, not the backup.
If you come to Memphis, walk the streets first and underwrite one ZIP at a time. Happy to compare notes on what you find.
Thanks James, that's a clear framework. Memphis is definitely on my radar, and I'd like to compare notes when I start looking at specific ZIPs there.
Interesting that Section 8 is your base case in those ZIPs. In Jackson we mostly underwrite at market rent, with homes in the $50K–$115K range leased at $775–$1,550. Curious how your turnover and repair costs compare between Section 8 and market tenants.
Bruno, thank you for sharing real numbers — this is the kind of honest breakdown that actually helps people underwrite. I'm a Realtor in Memphis, so your question about coming here caught my eye, and I agree with James: underwrite the hold, not the buy, and get a real insurance quote for the address before you close, because it moves by roof, carrier, and street just like taxes do. Memphis has the same street-to-street variation you describe in Jackson, so the comparable leases on that block matter far more than any citywide average. If you do look at Memphis, take it one ZIP at a time and walk the streets first — and a local agent who knows the rental blocks can help you check those comparable leases before you make an offer.
Thank you Ametria, appreciate it. Agreed on comps from the same block: that's exactly how we work in Jackson, where our base is today. Memphis is on my radar, so I'll reach out when I start looking at specific ZIPs. Good to know a local agent who knows the rental blocks.