Real Estate Agents: Are We Selling Properties or Helping Investors Build Wealth?

Real Estate Agents: Are We Selling Properties or Helping Investors Build Wealth?

Karen CubberleyBusiness Member
Realtor · Sevierville, TN · Member since 2026 · 44 posts · 11 votes

Here's a question for my fellow real estate agents on BiggerPockets.

How many agents truly understand the investment side of real estate, rather than just knowing how to sell a property?

Working with investors is a completely different conversation from helping someone purchase a primary residence.

An investor doesn't just need to know whether a property is beautiful or priced competitively. They need to understand whether the numbers make sense.

Here in the Smoky Mountains, where I work with short-term rental investors, I've seen firsthand how a beautiful cabin with incredible amenities can still be a poor investment if the purchase price, financing, operating expenses, and realistic rental income don't align.

I believe our responsibility as agents goes beyond finding properties and negotiating contracts.

Sometimes the most valuable thing we can tell an investor is, "I wouldn't buy this property at that price."

And sometimes walking away from a deal is the best advice we can give.

I'd love to hear from other agents across the country:

  1. What's the biggest mistake you see agents making when working with investors?

  2. Do you help your clients evaluate investment potential, or leave that entirely to the buyer?

  3. Have you ever advised a client NOT to purchase a property, even though it meant losing a commission?

Here's my biggest question: Are we building long-term relationships with investors, or simply chasing the next closing?

Looking forward to hearing different perspectives from agents in other markets.

Karen Cubberley
Tennessee Elite Realty | Smoky Mountains, TN

Tennessee Elite Realty 59 Reviews
View Page
0Reply
23 views

1 Reply

Jump to latestLatest
  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 438 posts · 144 votes
    3h

    Hi Karen — I really appreciate this question, and I agree with you completely. The biggest mistake I see is agents treating an investor like a primary-home buyer: leading with how pretty the home is instead of walking through the numbers, the realistic rent, and the real expenses together. I do help my clients evaluate a property's investment potential, but I'm always clear that the final decision is theirs — my job is to make sure they're looking at the full picture, not just the list price. And yes, I've advised clients not to buy, even when it meant no commission on that deal. A deal that doesn't work for the client doesn't build anything for either of us. Here in Memphis I see the same thing you describe in the Smokies: a beautiful home can still be a poor investment if the numbers don't line up. Relationships first, closings second.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.