Detroit doesn't need to mean Detroit proper and probably shouldn't

Detroit doesn't need to mean Detroit proper and probably shouldn't

Kenneth JenkinsBusiness Member
Member since 2023 · 56 posts · 40 votes

Okay, so I may take a little bit of flack for this post, but I'm going to put this out there. The COC/ROI in the City of Detroit looks great on paper, until you get mired in the rental certification process or the 36th district court's slow performance. I concede at the start that some people can thread the needle and make it work in the city but we see a large cross section of investors, and on average their returns are worse than in the suburbs. A recent court ruling actually says that tenants do not owe back rent for non certified rental homes. While the dust hasn't quite settled on what that means there is some valid reason for concerns. Not allowing entry for the inspections and then claiming the home is unlivable is a well-known local tactic among renters in Detroit. Pair this with the 36th District court scrubbing tenants names from the Landlord Tenant court records and it can be the wild west.

We manage very successfully in Detroit, because we have strict screening and process guidelines designed to keep the investor's profit in mind. A good block is easy to find, and finding a good tenant takes work but it can also be done.

So what's important in determining whether you can successfully cash flow on your rental? Hey, your're on BP so I won't repeat the basics here. What I will do is talk about how LONG things take. This stuff adds potential risk to your economic vacancy. That day for day slippage is what kills things from a business and investment perspective. We manage about 400 homes in the Metro Detroit area and have exposure to both Detroit proper, and it's surrounding suburbs. I'll compare our experience in the City of Detroit with the City of Wayne: Time to first hearing for non payment after filing: Wayne 10 days, Detroit 24 days; Time to first inspection for rental certification: Wayne 7 days, Detroit 18 days; Percentage of tenants using free legal services to delay non-payment cases: Wayne 0%, Detroit 32%; Average wait time to get to a live operator for the water department: Wayne 3 rings, Detroit 1.5 hours.

Every day your rental sits vacant (or worse occupied by a non-paying tenant) is a day that costs you money as the owner. Every sub 600 credit score applicant placed can leave you with 6 months of unpaid rent, $1,200 in legal bills and an $8,000 repair bill puts a dent in your cash flow. The statutory maximum security deposit of 1.5 months rent doesn't come close to covering those costs.

What's the answer? Invest in the nearby suburbs and don't get lured in with the false promise of 20% ROI. Where do we love to invest: Canton, Livonia, Plymouth, City of Wayne, Westland, Garden City, Taylor, Woodhaven, Trenton, Southgate, Wyandotte, Lincoln Park and Dearborn Heights. If you find a gem in these cities you may actually REALLY have something amazing. Here we know, from experience, that the court systems function quickly, and fairly. We know the cities don't purposefully place barriers to landlords. That means your business runs more smoothly.

Propel Property Management4.3200 Reviews
View Page
0Reply
196 views

Most Popular Reply

Lender · Vernon, CT · Member since 2026 · 40 posts · 9 votes
3d

Detroit has long been one of those places that looks great on paper, but creates a bunch of headache after the fact.

I've seen the same, "If you want to invest in Detroit, try to invest in the suburbs". Has seemed largely true for Chicago and New York too. To a lesser degree Philadelphia.

The red tape, politics, and time make it a nightmare. I've seen evictions take multiple years in every one of these cities.
Though if someone is local to the area, maybe they can build the connections to make it work.

Are there any specific strategies that work really well within the city itself?

See this reply in the discussion

4 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Lender · Vernon, CT · Member since 2026 · 40 posts · 9 votes
    3d

    Detroit has long been one of those places that looks great on paper, but creates a bunch of headache after the fact.

    I've seen the same, "If you want to invest in Detroit, try to invest in the suburbs". Has seemed largely true for Chicago and New York too. To a lesser degree Philadelphia.

    The red tape, politics, and time make it a nightmare. I've seen evictions take multiple years in every one of these cities.
    Though if someone is local to the area, maybe they can build the connections to make it work.

    Are there any specific strategies that work really well within the city itself?

    • Kenneth JenkinsBusiness Member
      OP
      Member since 2023 · 56 posts · 40 votes
      3d

      Yes! The number one thing is to actually physically see the property yourself prior to purchasing. Boots on the ground in the form of agents are fine to narrow it down, but for your own sanity come see what you are buying. This limits surprises. It is by far the number 1 mistake I see out of state investors making. The number two thing is not working with professional property managers. In Michigan you're required to be a broker. That brings with it certain regulatory safeguards, but also adds a bit of cost. The cost is well worth it. The third most important thing (particularly in the city of Detroit) is get that rental certification complete. This provides you as the owner with access to the (slow) legal system to enforce your property rights. Without that you have no real recourse to evict. The fourth most important thing is do not overpay or overimprove thinking you are going to sell to a young professional in a war zone when there are clearly better options outside of the city at your target price point. Even if you plan to BRRR I've seen investors get burned on their post improvement appraisals to the point where they are upside down on the investment. It's disheartening to say the least.

      Propel Property Management4.3200 Reviews
      View Page
  • Realtor · Memphis, Shelby County · Member since 2026 · 487 posts · 166 votes
    3d

    Kenneth, this is a useful post, and the core lesson travels well beyond Detroit. The paper return is only half the deal — the other half is how long everything takes when something goes wrong. Economic vacancy is the cost that doesn't show up in the calculator, and a market where an eviction or a certification drags on for months can erase a year's cash flow.

    I see the same pattern in Memphis: the cheapest deals on paper are often the ones with the most operational friction, and investors who skip the local-process homework pay for it later. Your comparison of Wayne and Detroit is the kind of on-the-ground detail a spreadsheet can't give you.

    Stephen's question is a good one — I'd love to hear what works inside the city for the investors who do make it work. Thanks for sharing real numbers instead of just the headline return.

  • Drew SygitBusiness Member
    Property Manager · Royal Oak, MI · Member since 2012 · 13k+ posts · 9k+ votes
    3d

    Many valid points, which is why we created our color-coded Map of Detroit Neighborhoods - to help investors better understand the City of Detroit and make better investing decisions.

    One point to clarify, the referenced Michigan ONLY case, Skidmore vs Hayashi, the landlord had rented their property without obtaining the city’s required rental license.
    The Court ruled that because the city’s ordinance prohibited renting or occupying a rental property without the required certification, the lease was void from day one.

    As such, the court is allowing the tenant to pursue a claim for a refund of all rent paid during their 2-year lease.
    What’s more, this case has now set precedent for all jurisdictions in Michigan.


    The good news:

    • There's really been no ruling regarding tenants NOT having to pay rent

    • Same goes for rent refunds

    • It may get reviewed, and hopefully overturned, by the Michigan Supreme Court.

    We’ve consulted with our attorneys about this case, and they expect a bit of upcoming chaos for Michigan landlords with rentals without proper municipal licensing:

    ·         Tenants may try to use this to stop paying rent.

    ·         Nonprofit attorneys representing tenants in eviction cases may refer to this case to wipe out past due balances.

    ·         Personal Injury attorneys may start soliciting tenants to represent them in refund cases.

    How judges apply this ruling will depend on the individual jurisdictions and each judge.
    Our attorneys feel that it will be difficult for a court to allow nonpayment and/or refunds of rent because tenants:

    • Are NOT suppose to be living in the property

    • Are receiving a benefit of living in the rental

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.