Tampa Bay at DSCR 1.25 with 20% down: Tampa 3, St. Pete 0, Clearwater 0
@Alacia Mahnken asked about St. Pete and Clearwater on my intro thread, so here's the whole metro side by side.
The screen: 13,194 homes for sale across Hillsborough, Pinellas, Pasco and Hernando with a rent estimate. Site-built only (I leave out mobile homes because lot rent isn't known), 30-year at 7.25% (7.625% on 2-4 units), full PITIA including HOA.
At DSCR 1.25 with 20% down it's 15 for the whole metro: Tampa 3, St. Pete 0, Clearwater 0. The rest are one or two each in places like New Port Richey, Port Richey, Dunedin, Largo, Brandon, Riverview and Spring Hill, all priced between $105k and $230k.
Drop the bar to rent covering the full payment (DSCR 1.0), at 20% / 25% / 30% down:
- Tampa: 94 / 152 / 253 (of 2,957)
- St. Pete: 21 / 36 / 63 (of 1,532)
- Clearwater: 4 / 13 / 31 (of 913)
- Whole metro: 276 / 491 / 906 (of 13,194)
The Pasco side beats St. Pete and Clearwater combined. New Port Richey, Port Richey and Holiday have 48 at 20% down, against 25 for St. Pete and Clearwater together. By ZIP at 25% down: 34668 Port Richey (36 of 248), 33605 Tampa (27 of 128), 33604 Tampa (24 of 197), 34691 Holiday (24 of 123), 33610 Tampa (19 of 158).
By county at 20% down: Hillsborough 138 of 4,991, Pasco 70 of 2,370, Pinellas 46 of 5,118, Hernando 22 of 714.
2-4 units do best per listing: 39 of 274 cover the payment at 20% down, about 1 in 7. Single-family is about 1 in 42, and condos 22 of 3,768.
Insurance is the swing number here. I'm using $1.80-$2.10 a square foot depending on the county, and 40-50% more in a flood zone. If your quotes run well above or below that, I'd like to hear it.
For Tampa Bay landlords: what is a 3-bed in 34668 or 33605 actually leasing for?
Disclosure: I built NetsPositive, which is where these counts come from.