Small-balance DSCR or portfolio lender needed for rural PA/NY refi

Buffalo, New YorkWantProfessionalsLender
Classifieds

Small-balance DSCR or portfolio lender needed for rural PA/NY refi

Rental Property Investor · Buffalo, NY · Member since 2018 · 17 posts · 11 votes

Interested in a portfolio lender that would be able to bundle all of these properties into one portfolio loan. My existing three loans on these properties are with a local bank with two rate locks having already expired and the third expires at year end. I am currently working with the same local bank that currently has had these for the last 5 years but would also like to check out some DSCR lenders if available to lend. I understand there might be some difficultly getting these all on one loan as they are in different states and one the properties is a commercial unit. Also they are in a mix of rural areas and a small micropolitan area. My goal is to take out some equity in cash and get a new 20-30 term on these.

Here is some information on the portfolio:

  • 4 unit Commercial Building in Chautauqua County NY: about $210k

  • Five rentals in the McKean County, PA area: $48k–$135k each, about $393k total

  • Total value about $603k

Current debt

  • $90.9k at 7.50%, (Floating)

  • $32.9k at 7.50%, (Floating)

  • $96.6k at 5.13%, (Expires at end of year, then floats)

  • Total about $220k, roughly 36% LTV

Does anyone have experience with a DSCR lender on a deal that has a similiar setup like this? I'm wondering what benefits, if any, of going with a DSCR lender vs. a local lender.

Thanks Much!!

Zack

7Reply
1,536 views

33 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Lender · Phoenix Arizona · Member since 2018 · 105 posts · 54 votes
    2d

    Zack, I’m Dallas with Sauer Capital. We handle rental portfolio and cash-out financing, along with commercial options for mixed-use properties. I’d compare financing the PA rentals together and handling the NY mixed-use separately against one blanket loan. Your roughly $100K cash-out target gives us something concrete to work toward, with the smaller property values and year-end timing being key pieces to confirm. Let me know if I can help!

  • Lender · Member since 2026 · 3 posts · 0 votes
    2d

    Depends on the lender, and it's usually two separate floors, a minimum loan amount and a minimum property value. On a blanket, the value floor often applies to each house, so the per-property number is the one to ask for.

    That's where your McKean County houses get interesting. At $48k to $135k each, about $393k total, the five together usually clear a loan minimum. It's the lower-value houses that get cut one at a time, even if your 60 to 70k read on the two single families is right.

    Before you pay for appraisals, I'd ask two things. Will they still lend if the appraiser marks those houses rural or finds thin comps? And if one house misses the value floor, can you drop it and still close the rest, or does the whole package fail?

    Get those answers in writing first so you're not paying for five appraisals on a structure that dies on one house.

    Happy to look at it with you if you want a second set of eyes.

  • Derek PattersonPro Member
    Developer · NV · Member since 2026 · 26 posts · 3 votes
    1d

    Zachary, at 36% LTV and nearly $11K a month in rent, the real issue is loan size and rural collateral, not the quality of your portfolio. Two thoughts. First, a blanket or portfolio refi with a local or regional bank, or a credit union that already lends in McKean and Chautauqua counties, often works better than six small DSCR loans, because many DSCR programs bottom out around $75K. Second, because the properties are already in an LLC with five years of payment history, it's worth building the LLC's own business credit profile alongside the refi: bureau files that match your entity records, rent flowing through the business account, and a few reporting tradelines. That's what gets you to an entity-level line for repairs and the next purchase, instead of a cash-out every time. Happy to share how I structure that if it's useful.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.