This says sellers are commanding the market STRONGLY.

HUD determines "reasonable rent" based on its own comps and sometimes pays above what the private market commands, especially in lower-income areas.

There are also a few neighborhoods with septic and well water peppered throughout 44720 and I  stay away from those since the command lower rents.

Professionally Managed: $208.42 ADR (up 4%) vs. market avg $173.45👉 Investor Tip: Professionally managed units not only command higher nightly rates—they also outperform in occupancy.

A larger home might command premium bookings for groups or retreats, and if the STR market cools, it’s easier to pivot to a mid- or long-term rental strategy locally.As for markets to consider, if you stay close to Pennsylvania, the Poconos still perform well for STRs, and Lancaster or Gettysburg offer growing tourism potential.

I think a finished home would command a better price.

I think no pictures is unreasonable ( i leave command strips), stickers is unacceptable.   

Now we command and exhort such persons work peacefully and eat their own bread."

LTRBased on your home’s details (3/2.5/2, upgraded finishes, solar, great curb appeal), here's a quick market snapshot for 78224 as of May 2025:Long-Term Rental:Rent Range: ~$1,600 to $1,950/monthGiven the upgrades and former model status, your home could likely command closer to the top end—$1,850–$1,950.Best for: Predictable income, low turnover, and less active management.Mid-Term Rental: Rent Potential: ~$2,200–$2,600/monthEspecially strong if you furnish it and market to travel nurses, contractors, or military (Brooks City Base is nearby).Best for: Higher cash flow with less churn than STR.Short-Term Rental: Nightly Rate: ~$100–$140/nightTo reliably cover a mortgage, you’d need 20+ booked nights/month—which can be tough in this ZIP, as tourist demand is more modest compared to downtown San Antonio or New Braunfels.Best for: Experienced hosts or homes in high-demand leisure areas.Given your goals and desire for stability, LTR or MTR might be your sweet spot:LTR gives peace of mind and steady income.MTR could boost returns while staying relatively passive—especially if you furnish it once and cater to travel professionals.And please don’t feel discouraged—it’s completely normal to feel a bit uncertain when entering a new space.

Some of those Command strip picture hooks, maybe a gift card to a local restaurant/Walmart.