Business Page
Reafco - Mike Paolucci
Agent
5.0 stars
11 Reviews
Markets served
Cleveland, OH
Columbus, OH
Cincinnati, OH
Dayton, OH
About us
Fix & Flip, MTR, LTR, BRRRR, House Hacking, & Multifamily. I’m an investor-friendly real estate agent based in Ohio, actively investing across Columbus, Dayton, and Cleveland. I currently own 7 doors personally and have another 11 doors through partnerships, so I’m in the trenches right alongside my clients. I got started in 2021 as an out-of-state investor, which gave me a strong understanding of how to analyze deals remotely, build the right team, and manage risk from a distance. In 2022, I transitioned into property management, focusing on maintenance and leasing—so I’ve seen firsthand what impacts cash flow, tenant quality, and long-term performance. Today, I work with investors at all stages—from first-time buyers to those scaling portfolios—helping them find solid opportunities, run numbers the right way, and execute with confidence. I’m especially focused on value-add and cash-flowing rental properties in growing Ohio markets. Always open to connecting with other investors, sharing insights, and helping however I can. If you’re investing in Ohio or looking to get started, feel free to reach out.
Specialties
Residential
Single-Family Rental
Primary Residence
Multi-Family (2-4 units)
Fix & flip
Short-term rental
Reviews (11)
5.0 stars
11 Reviews
0.0 star
0 Reviews
5.0 stars
11 Reviews
5.0 stars
24 days ago
Reviewed by
Franck Mujyanama
Mike did an outstanding job assisting us with the purchase of our investment property. His expertise in the market's geographic area was instrumental in determining a comptetitive purchase price. Mike was very involved in all aspects of the clsoing. He was friendly, responsive, and always gave great advice.
5.0 stars
10 months ago
Reviewed by
Junior Torres
I had the pleasure of working with Michael and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. From the very beginning, he was professional, knowledgeable, and always one step ahead in making sure the process went smoothly.
What really stood out was Michael’s communication. He kept me informed at every stage, answered all my questions with patience, and provided clear explanations that made the entire buying process far less stressful. He also had excellent knowledge of the local market, which gave me confidence that I was making the right decisions.
Beyond the technical expertise, Michael truly cared about my needs. He took the time to understand what I was looking for and worked tirelessly to find the best fit. Thanks to his dedication, I was able to buy my investment property quickly and at a great price.
5.0 stars
10 months ago
Reviewed by
Amos Lee
Mike Paolucci was amazing to work with! He’s very open, honest, and transparent about properties, and his knowledge of good investment opportunities really stood out. He was always responsive and communicative, and he connected me with great resources that made my 1031 exchange process so much easier. Highly recommend Mike if you’re looking for someone who truly has your best investment interests at heart!
5.0 stars
about 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Omri Amdursky
Mike did an awesome job representing my interests in a successful deal. Great service, super responsive, great referrals for lender, property manager etc to help me build my network in Columbus. Highly recommended, will definitely do business with him again.
5.0 stars
about 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Hayden Ontai
As a newbie investor looking to buy my 1st investment property out of state I was not disappointed working with Mike Paolucci! I was able to find a deal that I liked within the first month and close on it by the next. I recommend anyone to use Mike as your agent investing in the Ohio market. Mike is very aware and knowledgeable in the Ohio market and I will definitely be using him in the future!
5.0 stars
over 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Dylan Ha
I was on the market for about half a year trying to find the right for a realtor, and I stumbled upon Mike through the biggerpockets agent finder tool. I didn't think too much of it honestly, and basically expected nothing to come from it. I went through numerous realtors before, with most of them just unpleasant to deal with.
My partnership with Mike through the deal we just closed was nothing short of exceptional. The communication and professionalism rivals any other brilliant agent out there. He really listened to my asks and preferences and catered deals my way that actually resembled what I was looking for. He connected me with folks in his network for loan options and is very knowledgable about all things real estate. He is never too busy to take a call, respond to a message, or to go see a house for me. Truly it felt like I was his only client, and although that's not true, it's a testament to how present he is when he's working with me.
Though it was by chance of me meeting Mike, I'm glad to have connected with him and do a deal with him. I'm sure I'll do more with him in the future, and I'd recommend him to anyone interested in starting out or expanding their real estate portfolio.
5.0 stars
over 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Elan Boyarsky
I am an out-of-state investor from NJ and Mike successfully helped me get my first 2 deals out of state, a Single Family in Cleveland and a duplex in Columbus. Mike is very knowledgeable about the Ohio area and has been a great help to me throughout the whole process. He is honest, sincere, and introduced me to great property managers, lenders, and inspectors. Highly recommend!
5.0 stars
over 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Allison Rich
I just closed on my first out-of state property, a duplex in Columbus, with the help of Mike. He was knowledgeable, quick to respond and had answers to all of my questions. He was a great coach and gave me the confidence to complete the transaction. I would highly recommend Mike and look forward to working with him on my next investment property!
5.0 stars
over 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Aryn Christman
I just closed on a property with Mike at Reafco as my buyer agent and had a great experience. I worked with him over the course of three months on my first home purchase (from across the country). To say I had a lot of questions and lot of needed hand-holding is an understatement but he continued to work with me throughout the process. He had great communication, knew the neighborhoods very well, and took a lot of time with me to understand what I was looking for in a property as an investor. Highly recommend!
5.0 stars
almost 2 years ago
Reviewed by
Matthew Lisenby
I can’t recommend Mike enough. I’m an out of state investor and I had a million questions for Mike and he answered them all with amazing professionalism. He helped me purchase my first property and I can’t wait to get more with his help.
5.0 stars
almost 2 years ago
Reviewed by
Ursula Lovings
As a first time out of state investor, I was nervous about all the unknowns. Mike walked me through the process with patience, answered any and all questions, and talked me through my indecisiveness.
I feel confident about my first OOS investment. I’m already seeking out my next one.
5.0 stars
24 days ago
Reviewed by
Franck Mujyanama
Mike did an outstanding job assisting us with the purchase of our investment property. His expertise in the market's geographic area was instrumental in determining a comptetitive purchase price. Mike was very involved in all aspects of the clsoing. He was friendly, responsive, and always gave great advice.
5.0 stars
10 months ago
Reviewed by
Junior Torres
I had the pleasure of working with Michael and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. From the very beginning, he was professional, knowledgeable, and always one step ahead in making sure the process went smoothly.
What really stood out was Michael’s communication. He kept me informed at every stage, answered all my questions with patience, and provided clear explanations that made the entire buying process far less stressful. He also had excellent knowledge of the local market, which gave me confidence that I was making the right decisions.
Beyond the technical expertise, Michael truly cared about my needs. He took the time to understand what I was looking for and worked tirelessly to find the best fit. Thanks to his dedication, I was able to buy my investment property quickly and at a great price.
5.0 stars
10 months ago
Reviewed by
Amos Lee
Mike Paolucci was amazing to work with! He’s very open, honest, and transparent about properties, and his knowledge of good investment opportunities really stood out. He was always responsive and communicative, and he connected me with great resources that made my 1031 exchange process so much easier. Highly recommend Mike if you’re looking for someone who truly has your best investment interests at heart!
5.0 stars
about 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Omri Amdursky
Mike did an awesome job representing my interests in a successful deal. Great service, super responsive, great referrals for lender, property manager etc to help me build my network in Columbus. Highly recommended, will definitely do business with him again.
5.0 stars
about 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Hayden Ontai
As a newbie investor looking to buy my 1st investment property out of state I was not disappointed working with Mike Paolucci! I was able to find a deal that I liked within the first month and close on it by the next. I recommend anyone to use Mike as your agent investing in the Ohio market. Mike is very aware and knowledgeable in the Ohio market and I will definitely be using him in the future!
5.0 stars
over 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Dylan Ha
I was on the market for about half a year trying to find the right for a realtor, and I stumbled upon Mike through the biggerpockets agent finder tool. I didn't think too much of it honestly, and basically expected nothing to come from it. I went through numerous realtors before, with most of them just unpleasant to deal with.
My partnership with Mike through the deal we just closed was nothing short of exceptional. The communication and professionalism rivals any other brilliant agent out there. He really listened to my asks and preferences and catered deals my way that actually resembled what I was looking for. He connected me with folks in his network for loan options and is very knowledgable about all things real estate. He is never too busy to take a call, respond to a message, or to go see a house for me. Truly it felt like I was his only client, and although that's not true, it's a testament to how present he is when he's working with me.
Though it was by chance of me meeting Mike, I'm glad to have connected with him and do a deal with him. I'm sure I'll do more with him in the future, and I'd recommend him to anyone interested in starting out or expanding their real estate portfolio.
5.0 stars
over 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Elan Boyarsky
I am an out-of-state investor from NJ and Mike successfully helped me get my first 2 deals out of state, a Single Family in Cleveland and a duplex in Columbus. Mike is very knowledgeable about the Ohio area and has been a great help to me throughout the whole process. He is honest, sincere, and introduced me to great property managers, lenders, and inspectors. Highly recommend!
5.0 stars
over 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Allison Rich
I just closed on my first out-of state property, a duplex in Columbus, with the help of Mike. He was knowledgeable, quick to respond and had answers to all of my questions. He was a great coach and gave me the confidence to complete the transaction. I would highly recommend Mike and look forward to working with him on my next investment property!
5.0 stars
over 1 year ago
Reviewed by
Aryn Christman
I just closed on a property with Mike at Reafco as my buyer agent and had a great experience. I worked with him over the course of three months on my first home purchase (from across the country). To say I had a lot of questions and lot of needed hand-holding is an understatement but he continued to work with me throughout the process. He had great communication, knew the neighborhoods very well, and took a lot of time with me to understand what I was looking for in a property as an investor. Highly recommend!
5.0 stars
almost 2 years ago
Reviewed by
Matthew Lisenby
I can’t recommend Mike enough. I’m an out of state investor and I had a million questions for Mike and he answered them all with amazing professionalism. He helped me purchase my first property and I can’t wait to get more with his help.
5.0 stars
almost 2 years ago
Reviewed by
Ursula Lovings
As a first time out of state investor, I was nervous about all the unknowns. Mike walked me through the process with patience, answered any and all questions, and talked me through my indecisiveness.
I feel confident about my first OOS investment. I’m already seeking out my next one.