4 Plex conversion to possible 6 unit

4 Plex conversion to possible 6 unit

Member since 2024 · 1 post · 0 votes

I bought a 4 unit property a couple years ago that was technically a 5 unit but the 5th unit was non conforming. I had to rip out the kitchen to decommission it and get a residential loan. There is potential to get the unit reinstated and add another to make it a 6 unit property. Its already zoned for up to 6 units but I am concerned about my current morgage and how adding the 2 units would affect it. Any insight would be greatly appreciated!

0Reply
40 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Vaibhav PuranikPro Member
    Member since 2025 · 118 posts · 59 votes
    3h

    I think the best approach is to check with the lender and ask whether this is allowed and if any approval is needed. Theoretically, this shouldn’t trigger the due-on-sale clause. The issue would more likely be a change in the property’s use compared with when you originally obtained the mortgage.

  • Lender · Vernon, CT · Member since 2026 · 25 posts · 2 votes
    2h

    This is absolutely something to talk about with the lender ahead of time.
    There is a big difference for lenders and zoning on 1-4 and 5+ unit properties.

    A 5 unit is treated more like and office building than like a 4 family.

    Typically, the lender has to be comfortable lending on the property's use before and after conversion. So if the lender only does 1-4 families, they wouldn't approve this. But if they do 5+ units as well, they might be able to.

    There's also normally a leverage difference between 1-4 family properties and 5+ unit properties.

    I typically see about 5-10% lower leverage for 5+ unit properties.

    Meaning you may need to pay off some of the existing mortgage balance in order to have it be adjusted to a 5+ unit property.

    Also, many lenders don't want to see major renovation during long term or permanent loans. Is this in a conventional or DSCR style loan?

    What's the value, what do you owe on it now, and does your lender allow 5+ unit properties?
    Do they allow you to do major renovation to the property during their loan?

  • Investor · Las Vegas, NV · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 10k+ votes
    1h

    Do you plan to keep it forever? It’s highly likely you could actually lower the value by exceeding 4 units. The financing becomes so much more expensive with shorter terms, and you eliminate maybe. 80% of the SMF buyers, maybe 90%? (Remember you’re buying experience, you wouldn’t have paid the same for a 5 unit as a 4 because of the financing.)

    If you do plan to keep to “forever” (at least until you die.) how will those two units affect the rent of the existing 4 units, how much will they go down? If yeh lender is ok with it, get it in writing. Then get it in writing from the city/county. Then Just do the math. It will cost x, you’ll bring in rent 5 and 6, rents 1-4 will go down x, and the value might go down x.

    So the “investment” is build out cost plus lost building value. The “return” is rent 5&6 minus rent 1-4 discounts. If that return is is 15-20% you can consider it if you hope to die owning it. Ps. Also. Don’t forget to talk to the city/county about the additional property tax, and the water/gas/electricity/sewer hookup costs, those can be massive, or no big deal. Also contact your insurance guy about the new “commercial” policy.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.