I bought a 4 unit property a couple years ago that was technically a 5 unit but the 5th unit was non conforming. I had to rip out the kitchen to decommission it and get a residential loan. There is potential to get the unit reinstated and add another to make it a 6 unit property. Its already zoned for up to 6 units but I am concerned about my current morgage and how adding the 2 units would affect it. Any insight would be greatly appreciated!
I think the best approach is to check with the lender and ask whether this is allowed and if any approval is needed. Theoretically, this shouldn’t trigger the due-on-sale clause. The issue would more likely be a change in the property’s use compared with when you originally obtained the mortgage.
This is absolutely something to talk about with the lender ahead of time. There is a big difference for lenders and zoning on 1-4 and 5+ unit properties.
A 5 unit is treated more like and office building than like a 4 family.
Typically, the lender has to be comfortable lending on the property's use before and after conversion. So if the lender only does 1-4 families, they wouldn't approve this. But if they do 5+ units as well, they might be able to.
There's also normally a leverage difference between 1-4 family properties and 5+ unit properties.
I typically see about 5-10% lower leverage for 5+ unit properties.
Meaning you may need to pay off some of the existing mortgage balance in order to have it be adjusted to a 5+ unit property.
Also, many lenders don't want to see major renovation during long term or permanent loans. Is this in a conventional or DSCR style loan?
What's the value, what do you owe on it now, and does your lender allow 5+ unit properties? Do they allow you to do major renovation to the property during their loan?
Do you plan to keep it forever? It’s highly likely you could actually lower the value by exceeding 4 units. The financing becomes so much more expensive with shorter terms, and you eliminate maybe. 80% of the SMF buyers, maybe 90%? (Remember you’re buying experience, you wouldn’t have paid the same for a 5 unit as a 4 because of the financing.)
If you do plan to keep to “forever” (at least until you die.) how will those two units affect the rent of the existing 4 units, how much will they go down? If yeh lender is ok with it, get it in writing. Then get it in writing from the city/county. Then Just do the math. It will cost x, you’ll bring in rent 5 and 6, rents 1-4 will go down x, and the value might go down x.
So the “investment” is build out cost plus lost building value. The “return” is rent 5&6 minus rent 1-4 discounts. If that return is is 15-20% you can consider it if you hope to die owning it. Ps. Also. Don’t forget to talk to the city/county about the additional property tax, and the water/gas/electricity/sewer hookup costs, those can be massive, or no big deal. Also contact your insurance guy about the new “commercial” policy.