Quick question for active wholesalers

Quick question for active wholesalers

Virtual Assistant · Member since 2026 · 8 posts · 0 votes

I’m curious to hear from wholesalers working deals right now.

When reaching out to homeowners, what’s been more challenging lately —
getting people to actually talk, identifying real motivation, or staying consistent with follow-up?

Interested to learn what’s working in different markets.

0Reply
121 views

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Bo SmithPro Member
    Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 1k+ posts · 378 votes
    8mo

    For me it's identifying real motivation. I can get people on the phone, but sorting through the "just curious" calls from the genuinely motivated sellers is where I lose the most deals. I spend maybe 10 seconds in the first call just qualifying: Are they actually thinking about selling, or did they just want to know what their house is worth?

    The follow-up piece is harder than people admit. I try to stay in touch every 2-3 weeks with serious prospects, but I'm not in their face every day either -- that kills credibility. I use a simple CRM and tag deals by urgency. If someone's got a deadline (foreclosure, relocation, estate), they get weekly touches. If it's vague interest, maybe monthly. The key is consistency without being annoying.

    One thing that's worked: after the first conversation, I send them a video walkthrough of a recent deal I closed in their neighborhood -- not mine, just something that shows them what's possible. Real visual proof beats a dozen phone calls. Then I reference it in the next call: "Like that deal we talked about on video."

    What market are you in? I'm finding that motivation looks different in hot markets vs. slow ones -- the messaging that works in a buyer's market falls flat in a seller's market.

    • Virtual Assistant · Member since 2026 · 8 posts · 0 votes
      8mo
      Quote from @Bo Smith:

      For me it's identifying real motivation. I can get people on the phone, but sorting through the "just curious" calls from the genuinely motivated sellers is where I lose the most deals. I spend maybe 10 seconds in the first call just qualifying: Are they actually thinking about selling, or did they just want to know what their house is worth?

      The follow-up piece is harder than people admit. I try to stay in touch every 2-3 weeks with serious prospects, but I'm not in their face every day either -- that kills credibility. I use a simple CRM and tag deals by urgency. If someone's got a deadline (foreclosure, relocation, estate), they get weekly touches. If it's vague interest, maybe monthly. The key is consistency without being annoying.

      One thing that's worked: after the first conversation, I send them a video walkthrough of a recent deal I closed in their neighborhood -- not mine, just something that shows them what's possible. Real visual proof beats a dozen phone calls. Then I reference it in the next call: "Like that deal we talked about on video."

      What market are you in? I'm finding that motivation looks different in hot markets vs. slow ones -- the messaging that works in a buyer's market falls flat in a seller's market.






  • Bo SmithPro Member
    Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 1k+ posts · 378 votes
    8mo

    For me it's been consistency with follow-up. Getting people to talk is one thing -- actually converting them is another. Most wholesalers hit someone once and move on. The real money is in calling back the same list 30, 60, 90 days later when circumstances change. I've closed deals on callbacks that I wouldn't have touched on first contact.

    Identifying real motivation is important too. Someone saying "I might sell" is not motivation. Look for people with probate situations, job relocations, health issues, or actual financial pressure. Those conversations are different and shorter -- you're not trying to convince them, you're just finding out what they need. The difference in close rate is night and day.

    The third thing that kills most wholesalers: not building a repeatable system. You're calling, you're knocking, but are you tracking outcomes? Are you following up systematically? A lot of people are just hoping to get lucky on a single deal instead of building a machine. What's your follow-up process looking like -- are you on a CRM or just doing it manually?

  • Bo SmithPro Member
    Hinton, WV · Member since 2026 · 1k+ posts · 378 votes
    8mo

    Azeem, great question. From my experience sourcing deals, all three are challenging right now, but motivation is the hardest filter. You can improve your contact rates and follow-up systems, but you can't force someone to sell who isn't ready. I'm seeing a lot of tire kickers these days -- people willing to chat but not willing to move at your timeline or take your offer seriously.

    What's working best for me is pre-qualification before the first conversation even happens. If you're grabbing numbers from public records or lead sources, do a quick check -- recent divorce filings, probate notices, code enforcement issues, out-of-state owners. That tells you where real motivation probably sits. Then when you call, you're talking to people with actual reasons to sell, not just every property owner in your list. Consistency gets easier when you're not chasing dead leads.

    What markets are you working, and how are you sourcing leads right now?

    • Virtual Assistant · Member since 2026 · 8 posts · 0 votes
      8mo
      Quote from @Bo Smith:

      Azeem, great question. From my experience sourcing deals, all three are challenging right now, but motivation is the hardest filter. You can improve your contact rates and follow-up systems, but you can't force someone to sell who isn't ready. I'm seeing a lot of tire kickers these days -- people willing to chat but not willing to move at your timeline or take your offer seriously.

      What's working best for me is pre-qualification before the first conversation even happens. If you're grabbing numbers from public records or lead sources, do a quick check -- recent divorce filings, probate notices, code enforcement issues, out-of-state owners. That tells you where real motivation probably sits. Then when you call, you're talking to people with actual reasons to sell, not just every property owner in your list. Consistency gets easier when you're not chasing dead leads.

      What markets are you working, and how are you sourcing leads right now?



      Right now I’m mostly focused on US markets with steady investor activity — Texas, Florida, and parts of the Midwest — but I’m less tied to a single market and more interested in where motivation is actually showing up.


      On sourcing, I’ve seen the best signal when outreach starts with distress-based indicators rather than broad lists — things like absentee ownership layered with life events or compliance issues. It makes the first conversation more grounded and saves a lot of time on the follow-up side.


      Curious — are you seeing data quality matter more than market selection right now, or does one clearly outperform the other for you?





      Right now I’m mostly focused on US markets with steady investor activity — Texas, Florida, and parts of the Midwest — but I’m less tied to a single market and more interested in where motivation is actually showing up.


      On sourcing, I’ve seen the best signal when outreach starts with distress-based indicators rather than broad lists — things like absentee ownership layered with life events or compliance issues. It makes the first conversation more grounded and saves a lot of time on the follow-up side.


      Curious — are you seeing data quality matter more than market selection right now, or does one clearly outperform the other for you?


Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.