Real Estate Broker · Atlanta, GA · Member since 2015 · 65 posts · 25 votes
Looking for feedback from those using Rently, a lockbox/service which allows prospective tenants to let themselves in to view a property. http://use.rently.com/how-rently-works/
Property manager here. My company manages over 500 units in Southern California. We transitioned to Rently last year and it's been a huge success. I had the same reservations that most posters have had, but it turns out all my fears have been unfounded.
On the positive side, we have more showings and we are leasing properties quicker. I'm sure we lost many prospects in the past when they couldn't coordinate a convenient time to visit with our showing agent. Now they can schedule at their convenience.
The biggest issue we've had is that prospects have left lights on. My biggest fear going into Rently was similar to posters above: what might people do unsupervised? Sure, people could use a stolen credit card and steal the fridge. Or squat. But then again, the people that are looking to do those things can do a quick zillow search and see a dozen vacant homes for rent within a mile radius. It's just as easy to find an open window or jimmy a lock. In fact, id think that would be preferable to putting down a credit card on record.
It's not perfect, and there are some properties it doesn't work for, but I'm here to say I've had a positive experience so far.
I agree, but I see a sizable property management company using it locally on SFRs. The prospective tenant has to enter a credit card, but they could easily do more damage than they might be able to cover on their card. Who knows, the 99 cents they get charged might be the last 99 cents they have before their card is maxed out!
I guess I'm old fashioned - it sure wouldn't work for me. I consider property management a "people business" and I just don't think that lockbox would start building the relationship based transaction that I want.
Looking for feedback from those using Rently, a lockbox/service which allows prospective tenants to let themselves in to view a property. http://use.rently.com/how-rently-works/
Seems a little scary to me. Any horror stories?
There a few companies doing this. I would not trust the service. A better method is to get some trusted service vendor, say painter, say plumber and hire them for maintenance. Something you already need. Then schedule a self service house showing while the vendor was in the home.
The feedback I receive from our landlord associations seems to trend toward the larger property management companies being comfortable using the service. The most popular option for the individual owner/manager still appears to be scheduling open house style appointments allowing you to save some time with the individual appointments. It allows you to meet the potential renter(s) and can create a healthy dose of competition.
Hi, unless it's a special key someone could just go copy it and then access the house months later. Big legal liability as I see it.
I also agree with the above comment about PM being a "people business".
Christian Hansen
This comes down to control vs scalability. I can see myself using a service like this if I cross the 50 unit mark and if I want to avoid costs on hiring a staff on constantly driving over and showing the property.
I would probably add some additional controls and keep a camera monitor in the vacant house to make sure that the prospective tenant is not trashing the place or using the vacant bedroom for a "30min quickie" with a friend, ;)
Reminds me of the Robocop-2 movie from 1990 and their vision of the future, when the character visits his house for sale, an automated kiosk guides through him through the house without an agent.
Makes sense that property managers would like it, it saves them time and money, and hey, it's not their house, so why should they care? Something gets damaged and they just bill the owner.
But for those of us who own our own properties, the potential downsides exceed the benefit, IMHO.
I think this is a very irresponsible practice done by a lazy property manager. The credit card could be stolen, maxed out, cancelled, who knows? Unless the owner of the property has signed a contract allowing this-not a good idea.
Property manager here. My company manages over 500 units in Southern California. We transitioned to Rently last year and it's been a huge success. I had the same reservations that most posters have had, but it turns out all my fears have been unfounded.
On the positive side, we have more showings and we are leasing properties quicker. I'm sure we lost many prospects in the past when they couldn't coordinate a convenient time to visit with our showing agent. Now they can schedule at their convenience.
The biggest issue we've had is that prospects have left lights on. My biggest fear going into Rently was similar to posters above: what might people do unsupervised? Sure, people could use a stolen credit card and steal the fridge. Or squat. But then again, the people that are looking to do those things can do a quick zillow search and see a dozen vacant homes for rent within a mile radius. It's just as easy to find an open window or jimmy a lock. In fact, id think that would be preferable to putting down a credit card on record.
It's not perfect, and there are some properties it doesn't work for, but I'm here to say I've had a positive experience so far.
As a property manager, this wouldn't work for me. I typically show homes while they are still occupied, and as a tenant, there would be no way I would let someone access my home after paying .99. If all my units were vacant, I could see this being useful, but as part of my screening process is meeting the tenant, I would lose that huge benefit of showing the home.
I'm sure this would be beneficial to large companies. However, we used to leave keys to vacant units in a knox box for vendors. One of the plumber's employees took the keys, gave them to a friend who moved in the basics over the weekend and started to live there. Once they are in, have to go to court to get them out.
So if using, @Mike Makkar has a good idea about the camera (although think you have to post a notice about the camera) and I would also have someone making the rounds every other day to check on the property.
As a property mgr, I prefer to interact with prospective tenants and lay some ground rules about living in the unit. For instance (and this is for apartments not houses) I've had perspective tenants asking about loud music and parties to see if that would be an issue. I would answer that might not be a good idea because tenants living above will call police. That would often be enough to convince them to move on and I avoid potential problems. So, I would hesitate to use rently, but can see it's advantages for larger property owners.
My only experience with it so far is that I went to look at a SFR that had a Rently sign and number in the yard. When I punched the number into Rently's web site, it kept telling me "no such number". I tried searching by address and also couldn't find the house. I don't know whether the seller didn't have it set up right, or if Rently was screwing up, or what.
This particular seller seems to have listed the house through one of those "we list your house on the MLS for $100, showings are your baby" services.
I guess I'm old fashioned - it sure wouldn't work for me. I consider property management a "people business" and I just don't think that lockbox would start building the relationship based transaction that I want.
I agree @Matt Clark my interview starts with that phone conversation.
@Mike McGeeI know that they don't accept pre-paid or stolen card information. It's natural to have reservations about letting Renter's into properties without an agent but it is a proven system to increase showings and lease faster. Human beings can only get so much done in a day and scheduling conflicts are often an issue (especially for people who work 9-5). If someone's going to commit a crime, they wont put a valid credit card on file and then check in under a monitored system to do it. Look at the vacation rental industry and ask yourself why theft and key copying doesn't occur there when often times the Renter just has a credit card on file and the key is left under the door mat (those are fully furnished homes being entrusted to people based on card information). Rently is an established company nationwide and if Security was an actual issue, they're business model probably wouldn't be so successful.
I have been using Showmojo on one property for the past few months, and requiring that they send their drivers license for verification. No issues as of yet, although we are holding off on putting all the new appliances in until after there are no more showings.
I know some investors with 160 rentals of mostly single family homes in the Chicago suburbs who don't use Rently or Showmojo, they just use mechanical lockboxes, and give out codes and tell people that the house has an alarm and cameras and if they aren't there at the right time the silent alarm will go off and cops will come. So far they haven't had any issues doing it that way. I am not sure if they get drivers license pictures texted to them or not. They only do rentals in B areas, maybe B-, but nothing below that.
I know I am late on this thread, but I am a property owner who was just robbed this week through the Rently lockbox system. Our washer/dryer and Viking stovetop were their biggest prizes (they tried to take our Viking double ovens, but couldn't get them out). The thieves stole our things in broad daylight and left trash in the house that looked as if they had been in there awhile, huffing computer duster cans and drinking. There was also evidence showing that they may have showered..? We weren't aware of the system that our property management company was using to show the property. We got updates and were sent links, so we thought the house was being watched over. Now we are trying to determine who is liable for our $3000 stove and the other $2,000 worth of stuff, not to mention the extra time we have to go without it being rented. I just wanted to caution everyone about this system, although it seems that most of you are hesitant anyway. The only good thing about Rently was that we were able to see the last person that came in and sure enough, it was her! I suppose this could happen to any vacant home, but at least when the agent is showing it, they are checking on the house more often. This person learned the system and used it to her advantage.
@Lindsay B. wow, good to know! Is the home located in the San Fran bay area?? We don't use Rently but when I researched it I thought they had some kind of insurance coverage of like 2k or 3k. If your PM didn't get your approval to use a system like this, they should be on the hook for the money you're out.
Yes, the house is located in the SF Bay Area. Our company has been very cooperative and they feel very bad. This hasn't happened to them before, but I'm kind of surprised that it doesn't happen more often since criminals could easily create a fake identity and use someone else's card.
Using Rently and it has been awesome and increases our efficiency with showings etc. All places get broken into period. I have has no break ins since using Rently but if you have a For Lease sign in the yard- chances are a criminal passing by has thought about breaking in. To say it has to do specifically with Rently is a little far fetched. They could easily just break the window and get in. Criminals will commit crime :/
True I have been using Rently for months now out in various parts of los angeles, I am talking DTLA Long Beach, Compton, San Fernando, it has saved me countless hours (not having to be in LA traffic) plus It has helped me save money on MLS commissions and other things too. I had someone break into one of my properties that Didn't have Rently on it, I feel like because the lockbox is there and people are coming and going it lets criminals know hey this property is being watched even closer. If I end up eating my words ill come back and post but so far so good!
Our property management company is currently using Showmojo. Same idea as Rently and I can tell you it has been FANTASTIC! Sure there have been some hiccups. However, we went from showing a maximum of 10 properties a day to almost unlimited showing times for all of our available properties. There are some properties that we don't place on lockboxes and obviously occupied showings are still done with an in person showing agent, but I love the lockbox idea now. I was so against it in the beginning and believed leasing should be an in-person job, however I believe it has contributed to our properties renting so fast during these slow months! We have had no issues with our properties and I like knowing we require credit cards or a picture of their driver's license. We are notified when doors are left unlocked and get instant feedback from the prospect. Excited to see what improvements lockbox companies will develop in upcoming years!
I'm ready to use Rently once I have a vacancy, as the traditional way is very time consuming (phone calls and showings) or expensive (hiring a property manager).
While I totally understand investors worrying about bad guys, and also understand the fact that when you meet someone face-to-face, you get a better feeling of who they are, but bad guys are capable of doing bad things regardless, and often times bad tenants look great face-to-face.
This is not a perfect comparison, but if we can have a stranger sleep over in your furnished house for a few days (Airbnb), we shouldn't worry about people coming in to your empty house for a few minutes.
With one exception, it looks like those who are worried or have negative views are those who never used Rently, while those who have been using have positive experience.
The prospective tenant has to enter a credit card, but they could easily do more damage than they might be able to cover on their card. Who knows, the 99 cents they get charged might be the last 99 cents they have before their card is maxed out!
Also, if 30 people go see the property, who are you going to try to collect on damages from?